Yuvan and A.R.Rahman

**MADDY** · 7th April 2006, 06:29 PM

njv, i fully did not understand ur post....but i bought IR here to make judge realise "criticism" is a 2-way sword......no offence meant to the maestro....

kadavul, we wud really like to see YSR make ARR retire one day.....but is he capable of doing it???u know, wat i mean, put ARR out of business......y do top directors and big banners still prefer ARR, if he is retiring???

**Google Adsense** · 7th April 2006 06:29 PM

**rashid2raj** · 7th April 2006, 09:38 PM

Its just a gamble...I feel very soon, Harris would call Deva and ask to sing him for a copied song in his music or Deva would call Harris to sing a copied song in his music...

How do you people feel when that combo happens !!!...

**genesis** · 7th April 2006, 09:46 PM

What kind of discussion is this? All MD's and their family members shall stop singing. That will be good for all of us.

We have not heard much of a good singer like Unni Krishnan for last 2-3 years. Here we are discussing about YSR and ARR singing? Crap!!

**rashid2raj** · 7th April 2006, 09:55 PM

Originally Posted by genesis

What kind of discussion is this? All MD's and their family members shall stop singing. That will be good for all of us.

We have not heard much of a good singer like Unni Krishnan for last 2-3 years. Here we are discussing about YSR and ARR singing? Crap!!

Pooodang' ... Just imagine Unni singin' Thee Pidikka thee pidikka..

After that you might change ur opinion whether Unni should be singin today or not. Anyway, try listen Naresh Iyer..

**dinesh2002** · 7th April 2006, 09:59 PM

but i think the Raja's family needs to get this in thier head...they r practicly bring thier family members to sing in their songs...lately i heard premji is related to YSR...goodnes...whose next???

ARR has only let his sis,daughters & nephew to sing selected once...not like make them sing in every album!!!!

**slperson1** · 7th April 2006, 11:09 PM

I dont see why ARRahmans work which is much better than YSR's goes unnoticed. For example: Meenaxi,Bose, & Mangal Pandey in hindhi. WOHE in Chinese or even his chaiya chaiya getting a spot in a hollywood film (Inside Man) even his bombay theme was in Lord of War (Nichola Cage film) Bombay theme is found in multiple indian cd compilations.

But if any other md even reaches one ounce of his accomplishments they are suddenly great and better then him?IR's thiruvasagam is really nothing when compared to what ARR has done already with his international projects,but that was given more credit for less work?

There is an anti-rahman wave for what reason?

**genesis** · 8th April 2006, 12:28 AM

pooodang'..... I like it!!

Anyway to counter why dont you have Shankar Mahadevan or Naresh Iyer sing "Thoda Thoda Malarthathenna Poove"... you will have the same result as UK singing Theepidikka.

My point was when we have so many great singers, there is no need for MDs to sing (unless they are relly good, and song suits them.. like Yeh Jo Desh Tera just suited ARR very well)....

**njv** · 8th April 2006, 02:12 AM

Originally Posted by MADDY

njv, i fully did not understand ur post....but i bought IR here to make judge realise "criticism" is a 2-way sword......no offence meant to the maestro....

kadavul, we wud really like to see YSR make ARR retire one day.....but is he capable of doing it???u know, wat i mean, put ARR out of business......y do top directors and big banners still prefer ARR, if he is retiring???

Everybody retire and IR is by no mean exception. Is he retired - from 40 movies / year to 10 movies / year - looks like he is retired but he is not. Watch out this year.

**svaisn** · 8th April 2006, 07:11 AM

Originally Posted by MADDY

aruvi, listen to ARR's voice in:

Vellai pookal ( KM)
Yeh jo des hai tera (Swades)
Lukka chuppi (RDBasanti)
Desh mere(legend of bhagat singh)
Theeyil vizhunda(Godfather)

and then make ur judgement....

its a gud question, actually.....there were unconfirmed reports 4-5 years back that ARR called Bavatharini to sing in a song, but it didn't materialise.......i guess ARR singing for YSR is more possible than YSR singing for ARR.....

yes

Maddy it was for the film yelelo... parthiban's movie/..

but it was dropped

**Scale** · 8th April 2006, 10:07 AM

Originally Posted by slperson1

I dont see why ARRahmans work which is much better than YSR's goes unnoticed. For example: Meenaxi,Bose, & Mangal Pandey in hindhi. WOHE in Chinese or even his chaiya chaiya getting a spot in a hollywood film (Inside Man) even his bombay theme was in Lord of War (Nichola Cage film) Bombay theme is found in multiple indian cd compilations.

But if any other md even reaches one ounce of his accomplishments they are suddenly great and better then him?IR's thiruvasagam is really nothing when compared to what ARR has done already with his international projects,but that was given more credit for less work?

There is an anti-rahman wave for what reason?

Excellent post dude!

Learn it, how your post gets unnoticed here!