PDA

View Full Version : Best Director-MD Combo



kokarako
2nd August 2006, 08:28 AM
Which of the following is the best Director-MD combo?

Manirathnam-IR
Manirathnam-ARR
Fazil-IR
Shankar-ARR
Selvaraghavan-Yuvan

I think I've ordered it correctly.

bingleguy
2nd August 2006, 08:54 AM
MR-IR and MR-ARR

form an awesome combo !

nilavupriyan
2nd August 2006, 09:12 AM
barathiraja-ir..a nice combo

bingleguy
2nd August 2006, 09:23 AM
are we considering only the current age ??

kokarako
2nd August 2006, 11:04 AM
I am considering IR era from mid 80's only. Maybe, we can add Sridhar-MSV, Bharathiraja-IR to the list.

selvakumar
2nd August 2006, 12:47 PM
SelvaRagavan - Yuvan.
Lovely combo that can comeout with youthful and class songs. !

Bala - IR too

MADDY
2nd August 2006, 01:58 PM
SelvaRagavan - Yuvan.
Lovely combo that can comeout with youthful and class songs. !

Bala - IR too

u still like Bala??? :shock:

that guy shuld be banned from TF after wat he did to Thala..... :evil:

i guess BR is the best director in xtracting gud songs out of MDs.....so i guess my choice is BR-IR and BR-ARR.......but MR-ARR comes a close second................

current gen- HJ and Gautam......they r 2 gud.....

selvakumar
2nd August 2006, 02:06 PM
u still like Bala??? :shock:
that guy shuld be banned from TF after wat he did to Thala..... :evil:
.

Yes.. He should be banned.. He is one filthy criminal who should be banned from TF.
But considering the past, I think BALA - IR combination was fine. esp SETHU
and in future anytime, Bala - the creator might get recognition. But BALA the man has already gone and the animal is present now !

I mean.. Bala the creator has gone and we have an animal present now (IMO)

rashid2raj
2nd August 2006, 03:24 PM
ARR - SHANKAR never fails..

manuel
29th August 2006, 05:10 PM
MR-IR have given some truly memorable films

Renault
31st August 2006, 07:34 AM
br - ir in my opinion was the best, simply due the great mental chemistry they had. In fact br had some fantastic songs from ARR as well.

MR-IR might come second. These days Selva-Yuvan and Goutham-HJ is good.

smss_engineer
17th September 2006, 04:21 PM
Best Director-MD combo


Manirathnam-Ilayaraja & ARR.

Bharathiraja-Ilayaraja.

Mahendran-Ilayaraja.

Balachander-MSV & Ilayaraja.

SPMuthuraman-Ilayaraja.

Shankar-ARR.

Gautam-HJ.

Selvaragavan-Yuvan.

Ramakrishna
17th September 2006, 06:07 PM
Mani-ARR
Shankar-ARR
Kathir-ARR
Rajeev menon-ARR
Gautham-HJ
Selva-Yuvan
Vikraman-S.A.Rajkumar
Dharani-VS
Ameer-Yuvan

kokarako
18th September 2006, 02:52 PM
Dear Ramakrishna,
Have u decided not to compare IR with others? Why no IR in ur list.

dinesh2002
18th September 2006, 07:13 PM
my list:

1.Shankar - ARR
2.Mani - ARR / Mani - IR
3.Bharatiraja - ARR / Bharatiraja - IR
4.Rajeev Menon - ARR
5.Gautham - HJ
6.Selvaragavan - YSR
7.Vishnuvardhan - YSR
8.Dharani - VS
9. Saran - Baradwaj

these strike in my mind when u say BEST COMBO....

Scale
18th September 2006, 07:20 PM
Dear Ramakrishna,
Have u decided not to compare IR with others? Why no IR in ur list.

[tscii:e6a946de4d]Ramakrishna why to insult Directors by including IR to the list

An Interviewer asked :

1. Who is your fav director & which combo you liked the most?

IR: What did they do? :mottaiya soriren:

2. Who is your favourite singer?

IR: Didn’t you hear my songs? :loosappa nee:

3. How could your melodies has so much soul to it, Evergreen classics?

IR: I make sure I always use Violin in the Ist interlude & Tabla in the charanam to revamp my original tunes so that it doesn’t look similar in anyway whoever be the singer SPB/JC/YD :smile:

4. Your Son is creating storm in TFM Industry, But he hasn’t been awarded for this year's filmfare award?

IR: Ridiculous! Even Karthikraja wasn’t noticed earlier. Filmfare award committee shud have checked itwofs a blatant lift and 2 others songs inspired by HJ in Anniyan. In what way does the music lift the film? Atleast they shud have checked FH nominees & votes. Idiots! Next year Bhava will be awarded for Amirtham Sure! :Happy:

Sorry Guys, The above post is just for fun. Knowing IR's attitude please don’t associate anyone to him other than his family members. He is the Lonely Master in his own right. And all his fans has to abide his principles. Thanks!

I repeat, The above is just for fun and appreciate the poll conducted by FH. It is more justifiable!
[/tscii:e6a946de4d]

Ramakrishna
18th September 2006, 08:28 PM
Dear Ramakrishna,
Have u decided not to compare IR with others? Why no IR in ur list.

Infact, Some didn't bother to include ARR in their list. Why didn't u question them too. Yaen IR name illanaa mattum thaan unga kannu uruthumaa :wink:

karthik_sa2
19th September 2006, 05:03 PM
IMO
1.msv sridhar
2.balachander msv ir
3.br-ir
4.maniratnam ir
5.kamalhasan ir
6.maniratnam-arr
7.shankar-arr
8.yuvan-selva
9.yuvan-ameer
10.yuvan-vishnuvardhan
hate the combo of harris and gowtam though they become popular.

rashid2raj
19th September 2006, 05:11 PM
ARR - Shankar
&
ARR - Maniratnam

:musicsmile:

vasanth2006
19th September 2006, 06:13 PM
Manirathnam -- IR
Bharathiraja -- IR
Balachandar -- IR
Balumahendra -- IR (simple and Lovely picturisation)
SunderRajan -- IR
Fazil -- IR
Kamal -- IR
Manirathnam -- ARR
Shankar -- ARR
Selvaraghavan -- yuvan
Simbu -- yuvan
Vishnuvarthan -- yuvan
Ameer -- yuvan
Goutham -- HJ
Jeeva -- HJ
Saran -- Bharadvaj
Karu pazhaniyappan -- vidyasagar
dharani -- vidyasagar

MADDY
20th September 2006, 02:32 AM
IR has given better songs to Mohan and Sundarrajan than to Bharathiraja and Maniratnam...... :D ......

ARR doesent have much to write about apart from Mani and Shankar in Tamil.......but in Hindi he has the best combos.....

yuvan-selva, HJ-Gowtham are good but their combos have a long way to go...

Sanjeevi
20th September 2006, 10:29 AM
IR-BR / IR-MR
IR-BM / IR-Mahendran
IR-BC / IR-Fazil
IR-Sundarrajan / IR-Manivannan / IR-SPM
ARR-Mani
Yuvan-Selva / Yuvan-Ameer
ARR-Shankar / ARR-Kathir
HJ-Gautham
IR-BALA
IR-Rajkiran