PDA

View Full Version : Nominations for "Poorly Picturised Songs"



mexicomeat
21st March 2010, 07:32 AM
Let me start with my nominations for the 'poorly picturised songs' in tamil cinema:

1. Nakka Mukka (Kadhalil Vizhundein)

2. Taxi Taxi (Sakkarakatti)

3. Come on Come on Oh Kamatchi (Love Birds)

Dilbert
21st March 2010, 09:52 AM
Let me start with my nominations for the 'poorly picturised songs' in tamil cinema:

1. Nakka Mukka (Kadhalil Vizhundein)

2. Taxi Taxi (Sakkarakatti)

3. Come on Come on Oh Kamatchi (Love Birds)


1) Thillana Thillana - Muthu

2) Kuluvalilae - Muthu

3) Chotta Chotta - Taj mahal

4) Viru Viru Virumandi - Virumandi

5) Andha Arabi Kadaloram - Bombay (way too Artifical) only plus is dance

Many more to follow.. great thread btw.. :)

Anban
21st March 2010, 10:34 AM
Let me start with my nominations for the 'poorly picturised songs' in tamil cinema:

1. Nakka Mukka (Kadhalil Vizhundein)

2. Taxi Taxi (Sakkarakatti)

3. Come on Come on Oh Kamatchi (Love Birds)


1) Thillana Thillana - Muthu

2) Kuluvalilae - Muthu

3) Chotta Chotta - Taj mahal

4) Viru Viru Virumandi - Virumandi

5) Andha Arabi Kadaloram - Bombay (way too Artifical) only plus is dance

Many more to follow.. great thread btw.. :) :twisted: :evil: :fishgrin: :banghead: :bangcomp: :argh: :hammer: :huh: :argue: :angry2: :frightened: :devil: :notthatway: :rant: :yakyak: :boo: :x :o :evil: :twisted:

P_R
21st March 2010, 10:46 AM
3) Chotta Chotta - Taj mahal :?
BR கிட்ட சிக்கியும் பிழைச்ச ஒரு சில பாட்டுகள்ல இது ஒண்ணு
மடை திறந்து எல்லாம் பார்த்தீங்கன்னா கண்லேர்ந்து ரத்தம் வரும்


4) Viru Viru Virumandi - Virumandi என்னாது !!!


5) Andha Arabi Kadaloram - Bombay (way too Artifical) only plus is dance :x இதற்கு Sonali co-crusher Compli சரியான பதில் சொல்வார்

Dilbert
21st March 2010, 11:14 AM
Many more to follow.. great thread btw.. :) :twisted: :evil: :fishgrin: :banghead: :bangcomp: :argh: :hammer: :huh: :argue: :angry2: :frightened: :devil: :notthatway: :rant: :yakyak: :boo: :x :o :evil: :twisted:[/quote]


Btw these are :lol: some of my fav songs.. but poorly picturised.. !

Scale
21st March 2010, 11:26 AM
New York Nagaram :suicide effect: What Microsoft missed to include in their Power point Presentation.

Sarna
21st March 2010, 12:29 PM
மடை திறந்து எல்லாம் பார்த்தீங்கன்னா கண்லேர்ந்து ரத்தம் வரும்


Whats bad (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PucI_AZLaA0) :huh:

for me, its one of the best among BR's song picturisation :bow: :bow:

isai'la venum'naa avan maamedhayaa irukkaalaam... but for him city-life, high-class society etc something like that he never seen in his life.... mittaai kadaya paaththa gramaththaan maadhiri, music chance kedachcha udana, avan manasula enna maadhiriyaana karpanaigal Odumgradha BR visual'aa kaattiyirukkaar :clap: simply beautiful :bow: :bow:

Anban
21st March 2010, 12:34 PM
3) Chotta Chotta - Taj mahal :?
BR கிட்ட சிக்கியும் பிழைச்ச ஒரு சில பாட்டுகள்ல இது ஒண்ணு
மடை திறந்து எல்லாம் பார்த்தீங்கன்னா கண்லேர்ந்து ரத்தம் வரும்


4) Viru Viru Virumandi - Virumandi என்னாது !!!


5) Andha Arabi Kadaloram - Bombay (way too Artifical) only plus is dance :x இதற்கு Sonali co-crusher Compli சரியான பதில் சொல்வார் dilbert cant read tamil..

complicateur
21st March 2010, 12:40 PM
5) Andha Arabi Kadaloram - Bombay (way too Artifical) only plus is dance :x இதற்கு Sonali co-crusher Compli சரியான பதில் சொல்வார்
Actually there are quite a few unnecessary intrusions by Manisha and AS in the song. :lol2:

Gautham is a prime candidate for this diskassan

ajaybaskar
21st March 2010, 12:44 PM
All the songs of Kangalaal Kaidhu Sei. Madurai Ambika theatrela FDFS paathutu irundha 10 perum thalaiyila kaiya vachukittu irundhaanga!

Roshan
21st March 2010, 12:46 PM
All the songs of Kangalaal Kaidhu Sei. Madurai Ambika theatrela FDFS paathutu irundha 10 perum thalaiyila kaiya vachukittu irundhaanga!

But thats again BR - avaru nalla picturise paNNaathaan naama pEsanum

mr_karthik
21st March 2010, 05:44 PM
All the songs of Kangalaal Kaidhu Sei. Madurai Ambika theatrela FDFS paathutu irundha 10 perum thalaiyila kaiya vachukittu irundhaanga!

But thats again BR - avaru nalla picturise paNNaathaan naama pEsanum
Correctly said... அது எப்பவாவது ஒரு தடவைதான்... :evil:
once in a red moon

interz
21st March 2010, 09:28 PM
Im very dissapointed with how Thaiya Thaiya (Uyire) was picturized.

I nominate Thaiya Thaiya from Uyire.

Its a huge challenge for directors to make rahmans songs look good visually.

ajaybaskar
21st March 2010, 09:30 PM
what's the prob with Thaiya Thaiya?

venkkiram
21st March 2010, 09:45 PM
All the songs of Kangalaal Kaidhu Sei. Madurai Ambika theatrela FDFS paathutu irundha 10 perum thalaiyila kaiya vachukittu irundhaanga!

But thats again BR - avaru nalla picturise paNNaathaan naama pEsanum
Correctly said... அது எப்பவாவது ஒரு தடவைதான்... :evil:
once in a red moon

பாரதிராஜாவின் வழக்கமான Visual Touch லிருந்து வேறுபட்டா அது படத்தில் பார்க்க நன்றாக இருக்கும் :)

groucho070
22nd March 2010, 07:43 AM
Sanggamam. Arguably one of ARR's best...and you will weep when you watch the song sequences :evil:

AudazJay
22nd March 2010, 10:00 AM
Nenjam Ellam, Hey Goodbye Nanba and Dol Dol from Aayutha Ezhuthu :evil:

Kadhalar Dhinam and Kadhal Virus songs- Kathir! :hammer: :curse:

There are quite a number of Raaja's songs which I love and just about recently, I got the opportunity to watch them on screen. What a waste of good songs :? Can't remember much now but one of them is definitely Aanantha Raagam from Panner Pushpangal. And I agree with PR on the Madai Thiranthe song...Chandrasekhar and his red clown suit are a definite eye-sore!

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 10:03 AM
And the award goes to Ninaivellam Nithya

AudazJay
22nd March 2010, 10:14 AM
Btw, what's wrong with Thaiya Thaiya (Malaika Arora :slurp: ) and Arabic Kadaloram? :roll:

MADDY
22nd March 2010, 10:33 AM
And the award goes to Ninaivellam Nithya

which shaang?

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 10:40 AM
பாரதிராஜா நல்லாப்பாடல் காட்சிகளைக்காட்டினால் அதிசயமா? அநியாயத்திலும் அநியாயம் இது :-(

முதல் மரியாதை மாதிரியெல்லாம் பாடல்களும் கதையோட்டமும் இணைந்து செல்லுவது அவர் மாதிரி சிலருக்கு மட்டுமே முடிந்த கலை. சும்மா MTV வீடியோ மாதிரி எடுத்து கதைக்கோ படத்துக்கோ ஒரு சம்பந்தமுமில்லாமல் முக்கால் வாசி நேரம் தாளித்துக்கொட்டும் (பார்க்கப்பளபளப்பாக இருந்தாலும் பொருந்தவே பொருந்தாமல் FF செய்ய வைக்கிற) எந்த ஒரு பிற்கால இயக்குநனரையும் விடப்பன்மடங்கு உயர்ந்தவை மஞ்சக்குளிச்சு முதலான ஏகப்பட்ட பாரதிராசா பாடல்கள்.

பரிதாபமான நடிகர்களான சத்யராஜையும், ரேகாவையும் பலநூறு முறை பார்க்கும்படி கடலோரக்கவிதைகளாக வடிக்க மற்ற கொம்பன்களிடம் சொல்லிப்பாருங்கள், ஓடியே போயிடுவார்கள்!

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 10:43 AM
I don't think people should simply pass comments on "videos" of BR songs just by seeing youteeb stuff.

One has to see the whole movie to appreciate how each of them so nicely fit into the narration. Simple example - the most celebrated 16 vayadhinilE!

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 10:45 AM
That doesn't mean that "stand alone" videos were always unimpressive for BR. There are tons of great samples - sigappu rOjAkkaL, tik-tik-tik are a couple of quick recalls!

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 10:48 AM
Personally I'm not a fan of picturisation of nizhalkaL songs - those that I musically regard as among the best ever in TFM! However, more than BR, it were those artists who couldn't perform, IMO. Had it been even 25% of what KH-RK could generally do, they would have turned out to be great numbers.

Thirumaran
22nd March 2010, 11:03 AM
And the award goes to Ninaivellam Nithya

which shaang?

pani vizhum malar vanam onnu poathumae.. :huh:

btw those songs at least brings us some humor. :lol2:

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 11:08 AM
Personally I'm not a fan of picturisation of nizhalkaL songs - those that I musically regard as among the best ever in TFM! However, more than BR, it were those artists who couldn't perform, IMO. Had it been even 25% of what KH-RK could generally do, they would have turned out to be great numbers.
In BR films, if the actors *act*, it is in spite of BR and definitely not because of BR.

Please don't get me started about BR songs - Extreme close-up montages of actors grinning, gubeer gubeer nu thalaya thookaradhu, ladies starring wide-eyed and dumb, with angels and paraphernalia to boot!

MM - Yeah the songs were woven into the narrative and of course, it had Nadigar Thilagam :)
"Andha nilava thaan naan kayyila pudichen" ellam endha category la poda mudiyin? :twisted:

Have you watched Kangalaal Kaidhi Sei songs?

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 11:09 AM
And the award goes to Ninaivellam Nithya

which shaang?

pani vizhum malar vanam onnu poathumae.. :huh:

btw those songs at least brings us some humor. :lol2:
Pani Vizhum Malar Vanam
Nee dhaane endhan pon vasandham

Anban
22nd March 2010, 11:10 AM
பாரதிராஜா நல்லாப்பாடல் காட்சிகளைக்காட்டினால் அதிசயமா? அநியாயத்திலும் அநியாயம் இது :-(

முதல் மரியாதை மாதிரியெல்லாம் பாடல்களும் கதையோட்டமும் இணைந்து செல்லுவது அவர் மாதிரி சிலருக்கு மட்டுமே முடிந்த கலை. சும்மா MTV வீடியோ மாதிரி எடுத்து கதைக்கோ படத்துக்கோ ஒரு சம்பந்தமுமில்லாமல் முக்கால் வாசி நேரம் தாளித்துக்கொட்டும் (பார்க்கப்பளபளப்பாக இருந்தாலும் பொருந்தவே பொருந்தாமல் FF செய்ய வைக்கிற) எந்த ஒரு பிற்கால இயக்குநனரையும் விடப்பன்மடங்கு உயர்ந்தவை மஞ்சக்குளிச்சு முதலான ஏகப்பட்ட பாரதிராசா பாடல்கள்.

பரிதாபமான நடிகர்களான சத்யராஜையும், ரேகாவையும் பலநூறு முறை பார்க்கும்படி கடலோரக்கவிதைகளாக வடிக்க மற்ற கொம்பன்களிடம் சொல்லிப்பாருங்கள், ஓடியே போயிடுவார்கள்! 100% agree.. this generation is filled with westernized aravekkaadus

Scale
22nd March 2010, 11:18 AM
Nenjam Ellam, Hey Goodbye Nanba and Dol Dol from Aayutha Ezhuthu :evil:

bigger :evil: :lol:

I liked Dol Dol (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSD6sJVExgg&feature=related). Infact it looks weird on the first viewing, if you watch closely MR cleverly flashed the liveliness of a rogue's behaviour when 'thuttu' is bubbling over. What so interesting & innovative thought is going for an upbeat, techo beats. :thumbsup: Do I have to say Maddy & MJ rocked bigtime!

Hey Goodbye Nanba (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZaIXf3myPvY&feature=related) is gorgeous song & beautifully picturized. Trishava ivvalavu azhaga kaatta mudiayaadhu. The sea shore, boat, camera angles, slow motion ellam sethukiruppaaru..

2 kodikku set pottu song edukkura aal illaingha ivaru. Simple, Stylish, naturally beautiful & technically brilliant.

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 11:19 AM
:omg:
Mani peru ellam indha thread la mention panradhe maha paavam! :evil:

Scale
22nd March 2010, 11:24 AM
:exactly:


Bala should also be excluded from this category.

MADDY
22nd March 2010, 11:28 AM
:omg:
Mani peru ellam indha thread la mention panradhe maha paavam! :evil:

:lol: yea.......but i was disappointed with fanaa picturisation - maybe due to my over expectation......i expected "desert rose - sting" kinda picturisation and ended up seeing a ordinary disco number picturisation........maybe mani wanted a normal disco number and rahman did more than kuduthha kaasu - but im disappointed :D

hey goodbye nanba is gorgeous picturisation :bow: .............handi-cama kooda avalavu easy-a suthha mudiyaadhu, the way ravi.k.chandran(?) rotated the big camera :lol:

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 11:30 AM
Bala should also be excluded from this category.
:yes:

Mani is the best in aesthetics, freshness etc

Bala is the best in the beauty of narrative expression (edho thonichu, whatever that means :lol2: )

oh, ennadhidhu worst thread la best-a kattindrukkom? :oops:

P_R
22nd March 2010, 11:31 AM
app, songs that move the storyline should be consciously excluded from this discussion. AppuRam naan Visu ellAm izhuppEn :-)

Peerly as reprieve music videos, it is my humble submission that BR is a disaster.


பாரதிராஜா நல்லாப்பாடல் காட்சிகளைக்காட்டினால் அதிசயமா? அநியாயத்திலும் அநியாயம் இது :-(

White fairies, prancing Chandrashekar in a Taj doorman coat, equispaced cots all over brindavan gardens... right upto PriyamaNi trying to quite physically enter the kero's heart.

Of course Bagyaraj is a guru-vai minjiya sishyan.

Dinesh84
22nd March 2010, 11:31 AM
Shankar's film songs :thumbsup:

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 11:32 AM
right upto PriyamaNi trying to quite physically enter the kero's heart.

:rotfl3:
Maddy, dialogue please...

raghavendran
22nd March 2010, 11:32 AM
all sakkarakatti songs...poorly picturised..arr totally wasted

MADDY
22nd March 2010, 11:33 AM
Please don't get me started about BR songs - Extreme close-up montages of actors grinning, gubeer gubeer nu thalaya thookaradhu, ladies starring wide-eyed and dumb, with angels and paraphernalia to boot!

:rotfl: alternating closeups of faces and butterfly, birds, sparrows, tender leaves etc fluttering - they normally translate to a crescendo in music from raja/rahman side.......but there is a song "yaarum velayadum koottam" in nadodi thendral where there are some extraordinary angles used :bow: ......with rahman, BR has been pretty clueless all throughout


Have you watched Kangalaal Kaidhi Sei songs?

theekuruvil song: priyamani like a bottle rotates into vaseegaran's heart keeping up with what vadivelu threatens r.sundarrajan in "saba" joke :lol:

Dinesh84
22nd March 2010, 11:34 AM
Peerly as reprieve music videos, it is my humble submission that BR is a disaster.

:yes: kero keroini jumping in slow motion and running along the beaches.. :x

equanimus
22nd March 2010, 11:44 AM
Peerly as reprieve music videos, it is my humble submission that BR is a disaster.
PR, the question perhaps is why a song needs to be picturised as a music video.

raghavendran
22nd March 2010, 11:47 AM
theekuruvil song: priyamani like a bottle rotates into vaseegaran's heart keeping up with what vadivelu threatens r.sundarrajan in "saba" joke :lol:
typical barathiraja.....semme comedy,,apdiye poetikka solraram...

Anban
22nd March 2010, 11:53 AM
barathiraja has done some superb picturisations too..

ex.. Tik Tik Tik.. :clap:


dol dol by mani is more than an irritation

P_R
22nd March 2010, 11:55 AM
Peerly as reprieve music videos, it is my humble submission that BR is a disaster.
PR, the question perhaps is why a song needs to be picturised as a music video. Does not necessarily have to be. But it is an acknowledgement that a song is always something unreal.

Scale
22nd March 2010, 11:55 AM
Yeah, the narrative expression is what all I want to talk about. Not necessarily all songs but MR, Bala are the Masters! What Mani Sir says is that the song picturisation has to be an extensive view of the narration and it shouldnt be repeatative and Dol Dol is one fine example.

I would also like to see more from Balaji Sakthivel, provided he makes more films. Kaadhal & Kalloori are definite pillars of song picturizations.

Shankar gets my nomination here & Sahana is his best of worst picturizations.

P_R
22nd March 2010, 11:56 AM
theekuruvil song: priyamani like a bottle rotates into vaseegaran's heart keeping up with what vadivelu threatens r.sundarrajan in "saba" joke :lol: :rotfl2:

raghavendran
22nd March 2010, 11:59 AM
Yeah, the narrative expression is what all I want to talk about. Not necessarily all songs but MR, Bala are the Masters! What Mani Sir says is that the song picturisation has to be an extensive view of the narration and it shouldnt be repeatative and Dol Dol is one fine example.

I would also like to see more from Balaji Sakthivel, provided he makes more films. Kaadhal & Kalloori are definite pillars of song picturizations.

Shankar gets my nomination here & Sahana is his best of worst picturizations.
i like shankar's songs...bramandam konduvaruvaar...mostly
with picturisation his songs r better...like athiradee,columbus...mukkabula..songlam imagine pannave mudyadhu..oru cowboy padam patha madhiri irukkum

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 12:00 PM
ex.. Tik Tik Tik.. :clap:

I hope you don't mean "Idhu Oru Nila Kaalam"! Oru genius composition-a 1-2-3-4 jumping jack mass drill pottu sedhaichiruppaaru :x

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 12:01 PM
I would also like to see more from Balaji Sakthivel, provided he makes more films. Kaadhal & Kalloori are definite pillars of song picturizations.

Moongil kaadugale is fantastic

raghavendran
22nd March 2010, 12:03 PM
I would also like to see more from Balaji Sakthivel, provided he makes more films. Kaadhal & Kalloori are definite pillars of song picturizations.

Moongil kaadugale is fantastic
yes bala....gr8 picturisation...also harriss oda 1 of the few best compositions....vikram super

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 12:04 PM
And adhu enna oru unconditional rural=good, western/urban=bad ngara karuthu peddling? When we talk about bad picturizations of BR, it is not bad *because* it is rural. Singaravelan la solra madhiri "Sciene evvalavu valarndhirukku, idha yen neenga thing panna maatreenga?"
Reminds me of the MGR formula ezhainga=good, panakkaaranga=bad
:twisted:

equanimus
22nd March 2010, 12:08 PM
And let's not forget the brilliant atmospherics of தண்டட்டி கருப்பாயி. Magnificent stuff.

Scale
22nd March 2010, 12:10 PM
MR = Urban = Good
Raadha Mohan = Urban = Good & Bad (AT & Mozhi)
KK = Urban = Good & Bad.

Poo = Rural = Good & Bad
Nadodigal/Subramaniapuram = Rural = Good
Veyil/PV = Rural = Good

Bala, dont know where its peddling?

The fact is we have good film makers on Rural script than urbans... (mothalla indha turbana kelattanum)

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 12:12 PM
MR = Urban = Good
Raadha Mohan = Urban = Good & Bad (AT & Mozhi)
KK = Urban = Good & Bad.

Poo = Rural = Good & Bad
Nadodigal/Subramaniapuram = Rural = Good
Veyil/PV = Rural = Good

Bala, dont know where its peddling?

The fact is we have good film makers on Rural script than urbans... (mothalla indha turbana kelattanum)
Scale,
I was referring to such a sentiment being expressed by Anban and app_engine - "we diss BR songs because they are rural and we praise others because they are MTV style" etc...

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 12:14 PM
And let's not forget the brilliant atmospherics of
தண்டட்டி கருப்பாயி. Magnificent stuff.
ரெம்ப நாளா இந்த சந்தேகம். 'தண்டட்டி' - என்ன அர்த்தம்?

Anban
22nd March 2010, 12:16 PM
bala, i liked the visual feel of the song.. ambuttuthen..

Scale
22nd March 2010, 12:16 PM
Oh, mistaken!

joe
22nd March 2010, 12:17 PM
And the award goes to Ninaivellam Nithya

:exactly:

This movie comes to my mind when i see the topic.

P_R
22nd March 2010, 12:17 PM
And let's not forget the brilliant atmospherics of
தண்டட்டி கருப்பாயி. Magnificent stuff.
ரெம்ப நாளா இந்த சந்தேகம். 'தண்டட்டி' - என்ன அர்த்தம்?
பாம்படம் 'ம்பாய்ங்களே.

The huge-block earrings that pull the lobes.

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 12:19 PM
Nandri-nga

groucho070
22nd March 2010, 12:24 PM
Anyone seen the song sequence for Kurinji Malarin Vadintha Rasatthil?

film: Azhage Unnai Aaradhikiren (1979).

Crime: A Kamal wannabe and Jeyasudha's sister romping it out in the garden in what appears to be ancient dance to the God of Bad Taste :banghead:

Roshan
22nd March 2010, 12:29 PM
Anyone seen the song sequence for Kurinji Malarin Vadintha Rasatthil?

film: Azhage Unnai Aaradhikiren (1979).

Crime: A Kamal wannabe and Jeyasudha's sister romping it out in the garden in what appears to be ancient dance to the God of Bad Taste :banghead:

:lol:

Guru-V
22nd March 2010, 01:02 PM
theekuruvil song: priyamani like a bottle rotates into vaseegaran's heart keeping up with what vadivelu threatens r.sundarrajan in "saba" joke :lol: :rotfl2:

:lol:

saradhaa_sn
22nd March 2010, 01:15 PM
பாரதிராஜா நல்லாப்பாடல் காட்சிகளைக்காட்டினால் அதிசயமா? அநியாயத்திலும் அநியாயம் இது :-(

முதல் மரியாதை மாதிரியெல்லாம் பாடல்களும் கதையோட்டமும் இணைந்து செல்லுவது அவர் மாதிரி சிலருக்கு மட்டுமே முடிந்த கலை. சும்மா MTV வீடியோ மாதிரி எடுத்து கதைக்கோ படத்துக்கோ ஒரு சம்பந்தமுமில்லாமல் முக்கால் வாசி நேரம் தாளித்துக்கொட்டும் (பார்க்கப்பளபளப்பாக இருந்தாலும் பொருந்தவே பொருந்தாமல் FF செய்ய வைக்கிற) எந்த ஒரு பிற்கால இயக்குநனரையும்...
நீங்க யாரைச்சொல்றீங்கன்னு புரியாவிட்டாலும்.... 'ரண்டக்க... ரண்டக்க...' பாடலில் சில வினாடிகளே வரக்கூடிய காட்சிகளுக்காக...

ஒரு முழு பாலத்துக்கும் பெயிண்ட் அடித்து படம் வரைந்து...

லாரிகளுக்கு மீசையும் கண்களும் வரைந்து...

தார் ரோட்டுக்கு கலர் பெயிண்ட் அடித்து, அதில் படம் வரைந்து... கூத்து பண்ணிய 'ஷங்கரை'ச்சொன்னதாக எடுத்துக்கொள்ளவில்லை.

ஓவர் டு பாரதிராஜா....
எத்தனை முறைதான் குரூப் டான்ஸர்ஸ் வெள்ளை உடையணிந்து காற்றில் நீச்சலடிப்பது..?
எத்தனை முறைதான் குளோசப்பில் கதாநாயகி இரு கையால் முகத்தை மறைத்து பின்னர் ஒரு கையை கீழிறக்கி பாதி முகம் காட்டுவது..?
எத்தனை முறைதான் சூரியகாந்தி தோட்டத்தையே பார்ப்பது...?.
எத்தனை முறைதான், பாடலின் இடையே இசையை நிறுத்தி சத்தமில்லாமல் ஃபிலிமை ஓடவிட்டு, பின் துவங்குவது..?.

சமீபத்தில் 'புதுமைப்பெண்' படம் பார்த்தேன் (பாடல் மட்டும் அல்ல). பாடல் காட்சிகளனைத்தும் செம போர். அதிலும் அந்த 'கஸ்தூரி மானே' பாடலில் குட்டி, குட்டி கட்டில்களும், குரூப் டான்ஸர்களும்.... கொடுமை.

saradhaa_sn
22nd March 2010, 01:24 PM
சுற்றிலும் ஐம்பது பேர் நின்று கொண்டு 'தையா தக்கா' என்று குதித்தால்தான் கதாநாயகனுக்கும், கதாநாயகிக்கும் 'டூயட்' பாட வருமென்று காட்டப்பட்ட அத்தனை பாடல்காட்சிகளூம் "குப்பை"தான்.

அது 1948-ல் வந்த பாடலாக இருந்தாலும் சரி... இன்று காலை 10 மணிக்கு வெளியான பாடலாக இருந்தாலும் சரி.

Sanjeevi
22nd March 2010, 01:51 PM
மடை திறந்து எல்லாம் பார்த்தீங்கன்னா கண்லேர்ந்து ரத்தம் வரும்


Whats bad (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PucI_AZLaA0) :huh:

for me, its one of the best among BR's song picturisation :bow: :bow:

isai'la venum'naa avan maamedhayaa irukkaalaam... but for him city-life, high-class society etc something like that he never seen in his life.... mittaai kadaya paaththa gramaththaan maadhiri, music chance kedachcha udana, avan manasula enna maadhiriyaana karpanaigal Odumgradha BR visual'aa kaattiyirukkaar :clap: simply beautiful :bow: :bow:

Yes I too liked madai thiranthu picturisation especially the vellaikkara ammanigal and Chandrasekar's jumps :lol:. BR is the one who tried a lot to picturise a song and ofcourse he was the trendsetter in song picturisation :). Let us agree to disagree & like to dislike, he tried a lot. The problem is he is in his period not moved to next gen

Sanjeevi
22nd March 2010, 01:56 PM
And song in a movie is itself a fantacy. So you can't complain about the group dance if you like songs in movie. Only thing we can judge that it is nicely choreographed or not?

Roshan
22nd March 2010, 02:26 PM
:omg:
Mani peru ellam indha thread la mention panradhe maha paavam! :evil:

:lol: yea.......but i was disappointed with fanaa picturisation -

Adhula paarunga VM vERa..

yAkkai thiri kaadhal sudar anbE
jeevan nadhi kaadhal kadal nenjE
piRavi pizhai kaadhal thiruththam nenjE

appadinnu orE illakkiya vaasanaila kavithai ezhuthi iruppaar. Yes that was a bit let down for me in terms of picturisation.

joe
22nd March 2010, 02:31 PM
Chinna puRa onTru - a great song wasted with poor picturisation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fcuJKKem0eQ

joe
22nd March 2010, 02:35 PM
இளமை எனும் பூங்காற்று
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HgtdUBQHEY

P_R
22nd March 2010, 02:38 PM
Chinna puRa onTru - a great song wasted with poor picturisation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fcuJKKem0eQ
VaiyApuri indha pAttai oru thadavai virumbi TV-la pOda vachchAr. Saying ThEngai is very stylish in this song :lol:

groucho070
22nd March 2010, 02:41 PM
Chinna puRa onTru - a great song wasted with poor picturisation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fcuJKKem0eQ
VaiyApuri indha pAttai oru thadavai virumbi TV-la pOda vachchAr. Saying ThEngai is very stylish in this song :lol: :lol: Now, I am sure I don't want to see the picturisation of Enakkoru Kathali Irukkindrar...(add Jai Ganesh, double the horror :shock: )

19thmay
22nd March 2010, 02:42 PM
Kannodu Kaanbadhellam Thalaiva - Such a beautiful song but... :x

joe
22nd March 2010, 02:45 PM
Ore jeevan ontre uLLam - what a song ,but :oops:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hc1-ylTuye4

joe
22nd March 2010, 02:49 PM
Pani vizhum malarvanam
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dtXXEYS-5Yk

enna kodumai sir ithu :lol:

Plum
22nd March 2010, 03:02 PM
Personally I'm not a fan of picturisation of nizhalkaL songs - those that I musically regard as among the best ever in TFM! However, more than BR, it were those artists who couldn't perform, IMO. Had it been even 25% of what KH-RK could generally do, they would have turned out to be great numbers.
Other way around app. KH-NT nAla sila paadalgaL pozhaichiruchu!

Ye RaasathipArthirukkIngaLA - vintage Bharathiraja. He has to be evaluated by those standards only - 16V and MM are exceptions, and obviously, the reason is quite evident.

Well, maybe I'd pick mudhal mudhalAga froM NMP as a song where his weird sense got some semblance of interesting picturisation - despite sudhaagar and arasi madam; the andi pandaaram riff was particularly well done.

Plum
22nd March 2010, 03:05 PM
Of course Bagyaraj is a guru-vai minjiya sishyan.

athai chollunga. He escapes in such discussions usually although he is a worse offender than his guru

Plum
22nd March 2010, 03:10 PM
பாரதிராஜா நல்லாப்பாடல் காட்சிகளைக்காட்டினால் அதிசயமா? அநியாயத்திலும் அநியாயம் இது :-(

முதல் மரியாதை மாதிரியெல்லாம் பாடல்களும் கதையோட்டமும் இணைந்து செல்லுவது அவர் மாதிரி சிலருக்கு மட்டுமே முடிந்த கலை. சும்மா MTV வீடியோ மாதிரி எடுத்து கதைக்கோ படத்துக்கோ ஒரு சம்பந்தமுமில்லாமல் முக்கால் வாசி நேரம் தாளித்துக்கொட்டும் (பார்க்கப்பளபளப்பாக இருந்தாலும் பொருந்தவே பொருந்தாமல் FF செய்ய வைக்கிற) எந்த ஒரு பிற்கால இயக்குநனரையும்...
நீங்க யாரைச்சொல்றீங்கன்னு புரியாவிட்டாலும்.... 'ரண்டக்க... ரண்டக்க...' பாடலில் சில வினாடிகளே வரக்கூடிய காட்சிகளுக்காக...

ஒரு முழு பாலத்துக்கும் பெயிண்ட் அடித்து படம் வரைந்து...

லாரிகளுக்கு மீசையும் கண்களும் வரைந்து...

தார் ரோட்டுக்கு கலர் பெயிண்ட் அடித்து, அதில் படம் வரைந்து... கூத்து பண்ணிய 'ஷங்கரை'ச்சொன்னதாக எடுத்துக்கொள்ளவில்லை.

ஓவர் டு பாரதிராஜா....
எத்தனை முறைதான் குரூப் டான்ஸர்ஸ் வெள்ளை உடையணிந்து காற்றில் நீச்சலடிப்பது..?
எத்தனை முறைதான் குளோசப்பில் கதாநாயகி இரு கையால் முகத்தை மறைத்து பின்னர் ஒரு கையை கீழிறக்கி பாதி முகம் காட்டுவது..?
எத்தனை முறைதான் சூரியகாந்தி தோட்டத்தையே பார்ப்பது...?.
எத்தனை முறைதான், பாடலின் இடையே இசையை நிறுத்தி சத்தமில்லாமல் ஃபிலிமை ஓடவிட்டு, பின் துவங்குவது..?.

சமீபத்தில் 'புதுமைப்பெண்' படம் பார்த்தேன் (பாடல் மட்டும் அல்ல). பாடல் காட்சிகளனைத்தும் செம போர். அதிலும் அந்த 'கஸ்தூரி மானே' பாடலில் குட்டி, குட்டி கட்டில்களும், குரூப் டான்ஸர்களும்.... கொடுமை.

அட நீங்க என்னங்க "எத்தனை முறை"-ஙறீங. முதல் முறையே சகிக்காது!

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 03:12 PM
Many actually.. From my POV.

1. Aararai Kodi - Ah Aah
2. Ella pugazhum iravanuke - Azhagiya Thamizh Maghan
3. Style - Sivaji - PD is the culprit here, although I can understand the reason for the sluggishness in the choreo. After all, Shankar wanted it to be as static as possible for him to play with the graphics.
4. Taxi Taxi - Sakkarakati - ithanaikum thiruvaalar Dhaanu avargal re-shoot seidha paadal :lol:
5. Khajiraho - oru naal oru kanavu - ice creams, grapes, water melons and what not :lol:

btw, New york nagaram ellam indha threadla irukardhae paavam.. such a beautiful song.. best picturisation, one of its kind and first of its kind !

joe
22nd March 2010, 03:13 PM
மலரே குறிஞ்சி மலரே - what an amazing song ,but even with NT , picturization is not good :oops:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVtXP2xlaoU

Plum
22nd March 2010, 03:16 PM
But whatever songs are brought here for discussion, there is one song of the 80's, which set the Gold standard for worst picturisation, has never been surpassed in TFM history and never will be.

One of IR's most brilliant sensuous songs with some outstanding phrases. I couldnt get a video but if someone can, please link - I wont comment any more or reveal any more as the full impact can only be obtained on viewing it.(People who know are requested to not reveal it here until a link can be found)
ilamanadhu from Selvi.

In the director's defence, the alternative was picturising a sensuous song on Revathy, who, as Prabhu Ram observed recently, is prone to measured, balanced expressions, and may not have got marks for picturisation any way.

P_R
22nd March 2010, 03:21 PM
O man, the single most hilarious song (if it is what I think it is). summA uruNdu uruNdu sirichEn when I saw it on TV - and I was a kid then who was supposed to find it amusing. :rotfl:

Wibha
22nd March 2010, 03:22 PM
New York Nagaram :evil:

Kambar_Kannagi
22nd March 2010, 03:23 PM
New York Nagaram :evil:

Yes, the slide show wasn't a good idea afterall...

littlemaster1982
22nd March 2010, 03:24 PM
O man, the single most hilarious song (if it is what I think it is). summA uruNdu uruNdu sirichEn when I saw it on TV - and I was a kid then who was supposed to find it amusing. :rotfl:

I remember that song :lol:

Wibha
22nd March 2010, 03:26 PM
kadhal virus-all songs :x :x

and azhagai pookuthey from ninaithale inikum

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 03:29 PM
In the director's defence, the alternative was picturising a sensuous song on Revathy, who, as Prabhu Ram observed recently, is prone to measured, balanced expressions, and may not have got marks for picturisation any way.

:lol: I think we have already discussed this one ... irundhaalum neenga Revathy pathi ippadi pesa koodaadhu.. I think the only area where she lacked her acting skills

Plum
22nd March 2010, 03:35 PM
In the director's defence, the alternative was picturising a sensuous song on Revathy, who, as Prabhu Ram observed recently, is prone to measured, balanced expressions, and may not have got marks for picturisation any way.

:lol: I think we have already discussed this one ... irundhaalum neenga Revathy pathi ippadi pesa koodaadhu.. I think the only area where she lacked her acting skills

Yuvi aNNE, Revathy ellAm huge favourite for me. But sila vishayangaL solli dhAnE aagaNum.
[Repeat fact alert]


திருமணத்துக்கு பிறகு ரேவதியிடம் காதல் காட்சிகளில் முன்பிருந்த சரளம் இல்லை


என்னமோ அதுக்கு முன்னாடி மட்டும் இருந்த மாதிரி!

Plum
22nd March 2010, 03:36 PM
BTW, I am not sure if you placed the song in question. Recently discussed(pudhumai pEN) song illai,

A video link becomes very necessary now - LM, nInga dhAn kandu pidikkaNum link.

Dinesh84
22nd March 2010, 03:38 PM
People, one reqostu.. u can also diss abt the songs that was pictured nicely.. :)

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 03:41 PM
BTW, I am not sure if you placed the song in question. Recently discussed(pudhumai pEN) song illai,

A video link becomes very necessary now - LM, nInga dhAn kandu pidikkaNum link.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AhKbiLueiq8 - I hope this is the one.. if not :oops:

P_R
22nd March 2010, 03:43 PM
BTW, I am not sure if you placed the song in question.

ஞமலிகள் பண்பாடி புரவியேறி
அமளிகள் செய்திடுங் கானம்தானே ?

Plum
22nd March 2010, 04:00 PM
BTW, I am not sure if you placed the song in question. Recently discussed(pudhumai pEN) song illai,

A video link becomes very necessary now - LM, nInga dhAn kandu pidikkaNum link.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AhKbiLueiq8 - I hope this is the one.. if not :oops:

No, AV. I guessed you were talking about this one. I am talking about a song which doesnt have Revathy in a movie which had her.

Plum
22nd March 2010, 04:01 PM
BTW, I am not sure if you placed the song in question.

ஞமலிகள் பண்பாடி புரவியேறி
அமளிகள் செய்திடுங் கானம்தானே ?

அதே அதே!

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 04:19 PM
oh ok..

My next and the recent one in the list..
Kannukul Kannai from VTV - Guess the choreo guy lost it big time with the fast beats of Rahman. It was an old trick to use 5 random guys using random movements and merge at the last.. All other songs were just excellent !

Roshan
22nd March 2010, 04:29 PM
Kannodu Kaanbadhellam Thalaiva - Such a beautiful song but... :x

Enakku romba pidikkum. That's freaking hilarious. Raju Sundaram, Senthil, S V Shekar, Lakshmi, Aishwarya ellaarumE super'a paNNuvaanga. eppa paarthaalum I keep :rotfl:

BM
22nd March 2010, 04:34 PM
Kannodu Kaanbadhellam Thalaiva - Such a beautiful song but... :x

Enakku romba pidikkum. That's freaking hilarious. Raju Sundaram, Senthil, S V Shekar, Lakshmi, Aishwarya ellaarumE super'a paNNuvaanga. eppa paarthaalum I keep :rotfl:

Kadaisiya antha skeleton vanakkam vera vechitu pogum :rotfl2:

Scale
22nd March 2010, 04:40 PM
//NYN, first of its kind//

Not Really! Have seen a Ramarajan song sometime back the screen is splitted into half and two slideshows were running simultaenously Ramaraajan in a green suit, trademark white shoes walking like moving objects ---->:<------ in a pachai pasel BG stretching his hands (KA quote "if Amjad khan is alive today he would certainly chop these hands :rotfl:)

If you want to show something as a flash back refer to the old technique one big ((( ))) and show the actuals. Viewers are not that stupid. paambaratha suthi vitta maathiri NYN slideshow vodi kitte irukkum.

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 04:44 PM
Again.. NYN is first of its kind.. as you have rightly mentioned in your first para.. NYN doesnt have two screens side by sidegiving the audience an option to see what they want..

This is a well edited song sequence with difference locations/costumes/ coming in a split second without changing the color of the song .. One positive thing that I would take out of the movie (from director's book) is this song.

Again, we are already made stupid in this song, with lyrics starting "Newyork Nagaram" and the song entirely shot in Switzerland.

Scale
22nd March 2010, 04:58 PM
Atleast, RR/makers have gauged some viewers resistance and showed only it for few seconds 4mins 30 secs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vg2n_mG_ocM) <thala suthuthu & others have described adequately.>

Refer the comments, enga shoot panna enna idhellam mattera alla.

saradhaa_sn
22nd March 2010, 05:07 PM
மலரே குறிஞ்சி மலரே - what an amazing song ,but even with NT , picturization is not good :oops:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVtXP2xlaoU
நீங்க சொன்னது ரொம்ப கரெக்ட்.... சரியான ஏமாற்றமே.

அதுபோல திரு எம்.ஜி.ஆர். பாடல்களில் எப்போது பார்த்தாலும் என் வயிறு எரியும்படியான படமாக்கம்... "சந்திரோதயம் ஒரு பெண்ணானதோ" என்ன ஒரு அருமையான பாடலை கெடுத்து வச்சிருப்பாங்க. மெல்லிசை மன்னரின் அருமையான உழைப்பை இப்படியா குப்பையில் தூக்கி எரிய வேண்டும்..?.

Roshan
22nd March 2010, 05:12 PM
Kannodu Kaanbadhellam Thalaiva - Such a beautiful song but... :x

Enakku romba pidikkum. That's freaking hilarious. Raju Sundaram, Senthil, S V Shekar, Lakshmi, Aishwarya ellaarumE super'a paNNuvaanga. eppa paarthaalum I keep :rotfl:

Kadaisiya antha skeleton vanakkam vera vechitu pogum :rotfl2:

Yeah :rotfl2:

mexicomeat
22nd March 2010, 05:41 PM
roja ondru mutham ketkum neram

vairamuthu was once asked what was the difficult question he has ever faced from the reporters.

his response was "oru nirubar kettar....."roja ondru mutham ketkum neram" ivvalo azhagana paadal adarndha thaadikki pinnal siridalavu kooda mugathil unarchi illadha nadippil azhindu ponnadai patri ungal karuththu?"

mexicomeat
22nd March 2010, 05:43 PM
and in my opinion balu mahendra picturises his songs really well.. i can cite a number of examples..

littlemaster1982
22nd March 2010, 05:46 PM
A video link becomes very necessary now - LM, nInga dhAn kandu pidikkaNum link.

Video kidaikkuma-nu theriyala. But I'm sure Revathi is not there in the song. So, unga reasoning thappu :P

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 05:46 PM
P_R,

I have no issues if poorly picturized, unimaginative, repetitive, out-of-context works of BR are whipped (which I agree are quite a handful).

Feel free to pick them individually and thrash them.

OTOH, comments like the one below are totally unwarranted :




But thats again BR - avaru nalla picturise paNNaathaan naama pEsanum
Correctly said... அது எப்பவாவது ஒரு தடவைதான்... :evil:
once in a red moon

At the minimum, BR had done four movies with Kamalahasan (out of which two had Sridevi) that had above average, decent picturizations and one with Sivaji which is quite exemplary. Add kadalOrakkavidhaigaL that had songs that are powerful on-screen.

He had Niwas for the first 5 movies who had done some brilliant camera work for the time period. ninaivO oru paravai / indha minmiNikku were way advanced for the time period they appeared. (I'm not allowing my personal grAmaththu bias here, B(K) :-) )

30 years after sendhoorappoovE, I still feel the on-screen things endearing (while I can't endure many acclaimed ones of current big names even a couple of times). Even the poovarasam poo has a ton of nice things going on, if you look for innovations for the time period.

So, my indignation was against unjust flogging of an innovator in TF and such ones are rare in its history! It was not BR's fault that IR's standards were way beyond what TF could ever match with (technological and other limitations). That way, 'ninnukkOri' is a comedy piece on screen!

littlemaster1982
22nd March 2010, 05:55 PM
A video link becomes very necessary now - LM, nInga dhAn kandu pidikkaNum link.

Video kidaikkuma-nu theriyala. But I'm sure Revathi is not there in the song. So, unga reasoning thappu :P

Got it (http://www.megavideo.com/?v=TBQBUU7F). Warning: Not safe for work.

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 05:55 PM
Another thing, how many TF directors had EVER had the courage to make lead actors out of Sudhakar, Pandiyan, Sathyaraj and the likes and made silver jubilee stuff? (People had to come to theater to watch songs those days and there were any number of repeat viewers, songs like the alaigaL Oyvathillai ones which people can easily trash today as funnily picturized ones were the rage of youngsters when released who made it to the theater just to watch Ayiram thAmarai and kAdhal Oviyam).

I repeat, youteeb is NOT the way to measure the picturization of a TF song! There are few directors in TF ever who could conceptualize a song like 'vizhiyil vizhundhu' for the first time!

P_R
22nd March 2010, 05:56 PM
Badly picturized songs are not a rarity with BR. Check saradha's post, those are the images that pop up in our memory when thinking of BR songs.

Sure he has done his montages, narration moving sequences etc. But (I think) that's not what we are talking about. Then Raghuvaran spraying pesticide to his half of the door in samsAram adhu minsAram - would also need to figure in 'good picturization'.

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 05:57 PM
One doubt: One hears of keros and keroines getting thittu/kuttu from dance directors. avvalavu selvaakka avangalukku?

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 05:58 PM
P_R,
I'm fine with thrashing "really bad" ones here :-)

Total "thAr adichchal" is what I'm against.

raghavendran
22nd March 2010, 05:58 PM
One doubt: One hears of keros and keroines getting thittu/kuttu from dance directors. avvalavu selvaakka avangalukku?
PRABHU DEVA....semmeya thittuvarnnu solluvange...vj pokkiri shooting appo asked prabhudeva to stay away from him and asked him not to c his dance rehersals it seems....maththavange paththi theriyale

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 06:02 PM
When BR had a producer who could spend relatively lavishly (KRG who made sigappu roses) and KH-SD as lead pair, he did enjoyable numbers - that also didn't stick out like a sore thumb.

Just give this man some credit, yaar :-)

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 06:06 PM
Rudriah trying to do a BR-style work :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gv-KRI-PvNU

:-)

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 06:11 PM
ok, பொதுஜன விருப்பப்படி, ஒரு பாரதிராஜா கோமாளித்தனம் இங்கே :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mab2DPwCu9Y

One of the best ever compositions in TFM murdered :-(

Watch the face of nizhalgaL Ravi when the girl jumps into the pond :lol:

Avadi to America
22nd March 2010, 06:22 PM
இளமை எனும் பூங்காற்று
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HgtdUBQHEY

intha patta parkumu pozuthu ellam ennaku vayiru eriyum.... antha manuzhan kashtapttu kalthukum nikkura mathiri parra pottu irrukaan..... picturisation.... athilum herovoda facila expression.... narayana :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil:

raghavendran
22nd March 2010, 06:25 PM
"ADIYE RASATHI"...another magic by B.R.....enne padamnnu nyabagam ille....

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 06:55 PM
"ADIYE RASATHI"...another magic by B.R.....enne padamnnu nyabagam ille....
En Uyir Thozhan

MADDY
22nd March 2010, 06:57 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZWay1Y-1Yc

bass devastation*........adhu eppadi indha manushan (raja) can draw such a brash, beautiful painting without any "inputs" or a "drawing board" (writing/theme) :bow: ......

and picturisation - sit back and relax - u can watch it in office, yeah

*which brings me to the point- did raja stop with his bass work with this song or round abt that period?? i didnt see much guitar delights in 90s - can someone like plum or bala enlighten??

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 06:58 PM
இளமை எனும் பூங்காற்று
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HgtdUBQHEY

intha patta parkumu pozuthu ellam ennaku vayiru eriyum.... antha manuzhan kashtapttu kalthukum nikkura mathiri parra pottu irrukaan..... picturisation.... athilum herovoda facila expression.... narayana :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil:
Yucky video
Friend's comment: "Dei, avan enna push-ups aada edukkaraan. Close-up la kaatti face la vervayellam focus panraanga"

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 07:02 PM
இளமை எனும் பூங்காற்று
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HgtdUBQHEY

intha patta parkumu pozuthu ellam ennaku vayiru eriyum.... antha manuzhan kashtapttu kalthukum nikkura mathiri parra pottu irrukaan..... picturisation.... athilum herovoda facila expression.... narayana :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil:
Yucky video
Friend's comment: "Dei, avan enna push-ups aada edukkaraan. Close-up la kaatti face la vervayellam focus panraanga"

This film director would have had his ass print in Parangimalai Jothi during his college/assistant director days .. appadiyae indha paatla theriyudhu :twisted:

MADDY
22nd March 2010, 07:10 PM
to app's support and to support my fav director Barathiraja heres wat i was talking abt:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=02merlhLX2Q

yarum vilyadum koottam from nadodi thendral

gr8 camerwork - caressing long shots and getting everything in a frame right from when karthik enters the scene from 2:20....:thumbsup: it also features latest sensation Ranjita in it :lol2:

sadly i cant remember any ARR song that BR has picturised well :roll:

PARAMASHIVAN
22nd March 2010, 07:12 PM
Ilamai enum poongatru from 'Pagalil iravu' awsome song by IR + SPB, worst picturisation ever

Thirumaran
22nd March 2010, 07:16 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZWay1Y-1Yc

bass devastation*........adhu eppadi indha manushan (raja) can draw such a brash, beautiful painting without any "inputs" or a "drawing board" (writing/theme) :bow: ......

and picturisation - sit back and relax - u can watch it in office, yeah

*which brings me to the point- did raja stop with his bass work with this song or round abt that period?? i didnt see much guitar delights in 90s - can someone like plum or bala enlighten??

Sema Steps in the yellow outfits by Ramaraasu :cool2:

PD is lucky that Rama was not in the contest during PD's peak :P

Anban
22nd March 2010, 07:31 PM
to app's support and to support my fav director Barathiraja heres wat i was talking abt:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=02merlhLX2Q

yarum vilyadum koottam from nadodi thendral

gr8 camerwork - caressing long shots and getting everything in a frame right from when karthik enters the scene from 2:20....:thumbsup: it also features latest sensation Ranjita in it :lol2:

sadly i cant remember any ARR song that BR has picturised well :roll: karuthamma and kizhakku seemaiyile..

Plum
22nd March 2010, 07:34 PM
A video link becomes very necessary now - LM, nInga dhAn kandu pidikkaNum link.

Video kidaikkuma-nu theriyala. But I'm sure Revathi is not there in the song. So, unga reasoning thappu :P
Ada adhaanga sonnen. Aalavanthaar revathi irukkara songnu thappa purinjittu vera link pottuttaar. Adhai clear panna thaan correct link ketten. Unga thiramaikkku epdiyum kedaikkum - thedi paarunga!

Bala (Karthik)
22nd March 2010, 07:37 PM
Plum,
Link-a Link Master yerkanave pottaachu pottaachu!




A video link becomes very necessary now - LM, nInga dhAn kandu pidikkaNum link.

Video kidaikkuma-nu theriyala. But I'm sure Revathi is not there in the song. So, unga reasoning thappu :P

Got it (http://www.megavideo.com/?v=TBQBUU7F). Warning: Not safe for work.

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 07:42 PM
to app's support and to support my fav director Barathiraja heres wat i was talking abt:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=02merlhLX2Q

yarum vilyadum koottam from nadodi thendral

gr8 camerwork - caressing long shots and getting everything in a frame right from when karthik enters the scene from 2:20....:thumbsup: it also features latest sensation Ranjita in it :lol2:

sadly i cant remember any ARR song that BR has picturised well :roll: karuthamma and kizhakku seemaiyile..

:yes: I liked pacha kili paadum ooru and thenmErku paruvakAtril albeit Maheshwari out of curiosity, lip synched for Unni Krishnan (in thenmErku) :lol2:

Plum
22nd March 2010, 07:43 PM
Cool, bala.I think indha videovai paarthappuramum matha songs pathi indha threadla esanuma?
I

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 07:48 PM
Plum. அது ஒரு genre.

joe
22nd March 2010, 08:20 PM
இளமை எனும் பூங்காற்று
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HgtdUBQHEY

intha patta parkumu pozuthu ellam ennaku vayiru eriyum.... antha manuzhan kashtapttu kalthukum nikkura mathiri parra pottu irrukaan..... picturisation.... athilum herovoda facila expression.... narayana :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil:
Yucky video
Friend's comment: "Dei, avan enna push-ups aada edukkaraan. Close-up la kaatti face la vervayellam focus panraanga"

Ivar thaane ippo Radika TV serial-layellam appa-va vaRraru :)

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 08:21 PM
இளமை எனும் பூங்காற்று
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HgtdUBQHEY

intha patta parkumu pozuthu ellam ennaku vayiru eriyum.... antha manuzhan kashtapttu kalthukum nikkura mathiri parra pottu irrukaan..... picturisation.... athilum herovoda facila expression.... narayana :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil:
Yucky video
Friend's comment: "Dei, avan enna push-ups aada edukkaraan. Close-up la kaatti face la vervayellam focus panraanga"

Ivar thaane ippo Radika TV serial-layellam appa-va vaRraru :)

ippavum ivara close upla thaan kaaturaanunga .. bloody buckets :twisted:

complicateur
22nd March 2010, 08:22 PM
appa paNNathukku ippO anubavikkirAru joe. Dheivam ninRu kollum!

Dilbert
22nd March 2010, 08:33 PM
I am really suprised ARR WASTED so many beautiful songs on BR and KRB

Seriously think about Sangar directing ONLY SONGS for Duet !

Songs were just superb.. Meenakshi totally wasted + Ramesh ! :huh:

P_R
22nd March 2010, 08:38 PM
appa paNNathukku ippO anubavikkirAru joe. Dheivam ninRu kollum! anubavikkiradhu naama dhaan. Or as Plum would say ' 'as TM would say 'avar dhaan annikkE anubavichuttArE' '

Plum
22nd March 2010, 08:39 PM
appa paNNathukku ippO anubavikkirAru joe. Dheivam ninRu kollum!
CommailAm use pandradhillayA? Joe-vai thaan solringalonu nenaichutten modhalla :lol:

joe
22nd March 2010, 09:01 PM
appa paNNathukku ippO anubavikkirAru joe. Dheivam ninRu kollum!
CommailAm use pandradhillayA? Joe-vai thaan solringalonu nenaichutten modhalla :lol:

:)

rsubras
22nd March 2010, 09:09 PM
there were several IR songs which I hated till i got to hear the audio alone, Loved the songs when i only listened, so obviously the discredit shud go to the picturisation

1. ilaiya nila pozhigirathu - Chancey illatha lyrics, antha lyrics ku more than uyirottam kodutha music..... but all this picturised in a dungeon house amidst a kosu kadiyaal kashtapattu kondirukkum S.Ve.Shekar

2. Devathai Ilam devi - Camera mattum suthi suthi vanthu Coconut Srinivasan ah zoom pannitu pogum

3. Kaadhal Oviyam - Nothing wrong with the picturisation, but when hearing the audio alone we can feel the tune is much richer than the picturisation.. Infact this is what I feel with most of BR songs........

4. One duet song in neengal kettavai with Archana and the second hero in that movie... Arumaiyana song and your mood about that song vanishes into dark once u see Archana and that guy in a paarkave kan koosum oru costume

5. Thenmozhi from Solla Thudikuthu manasu - Super melodic song only to be wasted by the director ...... Infact all the songs in this movie were amazing..but other than the poove semboove nothing else remains in ur memory only bcoz of the picturisation of those songs...

Avadi to America
22nd March 2010, 09:11 PM
இளமை எனும் பூங்காற்று
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HgtdUBQHEY

intha patta parkumu pozuthu ellam ennaku vayiru eriyum.... antha manuzhan kashtapttu kalthukum nikkura mathiri parra pottu irrukaan..... picturisation.... athilum herovoda facila expression.... narayana :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil:
Yucky video
Friend's comment: "Dei, avan enna push-ups aada edukkaraan. Close-up la kaatti face la vervayellam focus panraanga"

Ivar thaane ippo Radika TV serial-layellam appa-va vaRraru :)

ippavum ivara close upla thaan kaaturaanunga .. bloody buckets :twisted:

i nominate this song as a worst picturized song.... probably one of the best melodys from TF......

thuku support pandravanga appadiey kaiya thooki nominate pannunga....

complicateur
22nd March 2010, 09:12 PM
4. Oh Vasantha RAjA.
5. :exactly:

joe
22nd March 2010, 09:14 PM
4. One duet song in neengal kettavai with Archana and the second hero in that movie... Arumaiyana song and your mood about that song vanishes into dark once u see Archana and that guy in a paarkave kan koosum oru costume

O vasantha Raaja (My alltime fav)?

ajaybaskar
22nd March 2010, 09:15 PM
rsubras,

The Neengal Kettavai song is 'Oh Vasantha Raja'. Banu Chandar showing his 6 packs, Archana in her glamarous(???) best. That sure was a purely picturised song..

complicateur
22nd March 2010, 09:15 PM
AmAm,, (with interest) joe. Oru sequence-la shirt illAma varuvAr pArunga....

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 09:17 PM
1. ilaiya nila pozhigirathu - Chancey illatha lyrics, antha lyrics ku more than uyirottam kodutha music..... but all this picturised in a dungeon house amidst a kosu kadiyaal kashtapattu kondirukkum S.Ve.Shekar


Rejected!

Quite an innovative setting for a film song, watch the movie and comment - youteeb is not the way to watch this song! (That Mohan doesn't play the notes correctly is an irritant if one knows guitar strings but even Sridevi is guilty of such in en vAnilE orE veNNilA)

rsubras
22nd March 2010, 09:20 PM
yea yea that is oh Vasantha Raja song only........ therila i hate that song when i see that in video, but like to listen it :)

and ilaya nila pozhigirathu is purely imo......... that has so much of creativity flowing in it that it does not deserve such a setting..probably from a director and movie point of view that cud be a apt picturisation but from a music point of view athai eppadi eppadiyo eduthirukkalam is IMO :)

venkkiram
22nd March 2010, 09:33 PM
probably from a director and movie point of view that cud be a apt picturisation but from a music point of view athai eppadi eppadiyo eduthirukkalam is IMO :)

முழுவதும் உடன்படுகிறேன், உங்கள் கருத்துக்கு.

இயக்குனர்களுக்கு இசையமைப்பாளர்களும், கவிஞர்களும் ஒரு கடலை பர்பியை தருவதற்கு பதிலாக பல நேரங்களில் தலை வாழ சாப்பாடே கொடுத்துவிடுகிறார்கள். பாடல்களை கேட்கும் நமக்கு, மனதில் கற்பனைகள் எல்லையில்லாத வெளியில் விரிகின்றன எல்லா திசைகளிலும். அந்த கற்பனையோடு, நாம் நிஜத்தை(திரையில் பாடல் பதிவாக்கப்பட்டதை) சந்திக்கும் போது, நிலைமை தாறுமாறாய் போய்விடுகிறது.

"சின்னப் புறா ஒன்று" பாடலை திரையில் பார்த்து விட்டு, மனதில் சா-பூ-த்ரி போட்டு, இனி பாடல் படமாக்கப் பட்ட விதத்தை ஒரு போதும் பாடலை கேட்கும் போது நினைக்கக் கூடாது என்ற முடிவுக்கு வந்து பல வருடங்கள் ஆகிவிட்டது. இதுபோன்ற படத்தில் பார்க்க சகிக்காத பாடல்களுக்கு நமக்கு நாமே இயக்குனர்; நாமே பாடலை கேட்கும் போது நம் எண்ணங்களுக்கு ஏற்ப நினைத்துக்கொள்ள வேண்டியதுதான்.

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 09:43 PM
rsubras,

I think the "better" TF directors have an inner conflict all the time - whether to accommodate a song (unavoidable in the IFM scenario even in 2010, due to the culture this and that) as a "realistic" one or a total fantasy.

In addition, TF music had some phenomenal talents disproportionate to their project managers :-)

R Sundarrajan (a start-up, first film youngster with some good ideas but a lot of limitations - financially, technologically and creativity-wise) v/s the firmly grounded genius Ilayaraja. I'm glad that RS at least thought of presenting the song in the "as it happened in real-life" mode, rather than risking to get into a fantasy mode :-)

OTOH, that he could more than do justice to the 'yEh AththA' in fantasy mode speaks for his capabilities as a director!

Yuvi
22nd March 2010, 09:55 PM
I think the director (Balu M I guess, so I wont blame him) and so the choreographer should be blamed for O Vasantha Raaja.

Raaja has used mirudhangam in the pallavi and first charanam with different thaalams and have transformed into western in the second charanam.

So until, first charanam (including the interlude), you will see the bharathanaatiyam costume from Archana and a little less costume from Bhanu Chander. Archana tries her best to do a bit of bharathanaatiyam and we end up seeing a bit of both BS (ting) and Archana (violin) in the end of the prelude.

when the second interlude starts, Raaja transforms into western and so is the costume of Archana (note: Bhanu Chander stays topless) into a pant and bottom-knot shirt and doing a bit of lazyy dancing in the beach.

Summary is that the choreographer has gone by books to use bharathanaatiyam (costume) for mirudhangam and western (costume) for drums.. Idhuku poi avara thittalaama :lol2:

venkkiram
22nd March 2010, 10:02 PM
எப்போதும் பார்த்து ரசிக்கிற அளவுக்கு பாடல்களை படமாக்கியவர்கள் என்றால் உடனே நினைவுக்கு வருவது மகேந்திரன் படங்கள்தான்.

அதற்கு அடுத்தபடியாக,

பாலச்சந்தர், பாலு மகேந்திரா, பாரதிராஜா (ஒரு சிலப் பாடல்கள்), மணிரத்னம் , ஷங்கர் , பாலா, ராஜீவ் மேனன், ஜீவா(மறைந்த)
தங்கர் பச்சான், லிங்குசாமி, சரண், வசந்த்

rsubras
22nd March 2010, 10:09 PM
probably........ IMO it will be fair to say that in the late 70's and early 80's IR gave songs that wud have been best for a seperate music album and show cased his skills and free flowing creativity...... and not to forget VM who was at his lyrical best and free from other aspirations (Money + Fame)....So antha time la many songs were just too much for a particular situation or a movie..... Stalwarts like Mahendran or BR or MR had handled that adroitly but first time directors were not too adept in handling that........

Also I feel, Late 80's and 90's la IR gave many songs that are more apt for the movie and situations..... so the visual medium complemented the music and vice versa.....

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 10:15 PM
One of the worst picturized songs (that I musically cherish) is

ஏதேதோ எண்ணம் வளர்த்தேன், உன் கையில் என்னைக்கொடுத்தேன்

KB was sure out of his mind when he nominated this as a "literal-title-song" :-(

app_engine
22nd March 2010, 11:23 PM
rsubras,

If iLaya nilA is irritating to you, by the same yardstick, what's your opinion on 'ninnukkOri varNam'? :-)

Sanjeevi
22nd March 2010, 11:34 PM
New songs are 'oppethufied' by some good cinematography and new technologies. So don't blame blindly old age directors' works. But at the same time, many (probably all) could not do justice to marvelous IR songs. (And this can apply to other MDs musically brilliant songs too).

app_engine
23rd March 2010, 12:50 AM
VM's take on this subject :

http://chandanaar.blogspot.com/2010/03/blog-post_12.html



திடீரென்று ஒரு கேள்வியை வீசினேன். "நீங்கள் எழுதிய பாடல்களை இசையோடு கேட்கும் ரசிகனுக்கு மனதில் காட்சிகள் அற்புதமாய் விரிகின்றன. ஆனால் அவை படமாக்கப்படும் போது அவை எங்கேயோ தொலைந்து விடுகின்றன. ஒரு படைப்பாளியாக உங்கள் கவிதை வரிகள் படமாக்கப்படுவதில் உங்களுக்கு திருப்தி இருக்கிறதா? " கவிஞர் என்னை நிமிர்ந்து பார்த்தார். சற்று நிதானித்து விட்டு " இது ஒரு நல்ல கேள்வி உங்களுக்கு. தர்மசங்கடமான கேள்வி எனக்கு " என்று வெடித்து சிரித்தார். தன பாடல் வரிகள் காட்சியமைப்புகளில்வீணாக்கபடுவதில் அவருக்குள் இருந்த வருத்தம் எனக்கு துல்லியமாக தெரிந்தது. ராஜாவின் பல பாடல்களுக்கும் நிகழ்ந்த துயரம் இது. ராஜாவின் ஒற்றை வயலின் உயிரை அறுக்கும் இசைக்கு கதாநாயகியின் இடுப்பு நெளிந்து கொண்டிருக்கும். "இருந்தாலும் நான் நினைத்ததை விட சிறப்பாக படமாக்கப்பட்ட பாடல்களில் எனக்கு பிடித்தவை 'ஆயிரம் தாமரை மொட்டுகளே',' உயிரே உயிரே (பாம்பே) ' போன்ற பாடல்கள் .." என்றார்.

mgb
23rd March 2010, 01:01 AM
2. Devathai Ilam devi - Camera mattum suthi suthi vanthu Coconut Srinivasan ah zoom pannitu pogum
I think, neenga "chinna pura ondru" song'a solla varinganu

Bala (Karthik)
23rd March 2010, 01:12 AM
1. ilaiya nila pozhigirathu - Chancey illatha lyrics, antha lyrics ku more than uyirottam kodutha music..... but all this picturised in a dungeon house amidst a kosu kadiyaal kashtapattu kondirukkum S.Ve.Shekar

The lyrics were written for the tune if i'm not wrong :)
IMHO, everything else in this song is light years behind the music. Not that its such a negative, its just a class apart. Where language cannot go, music will



4. One duet song in neengal kettavai with Archana and the second hero in that movie... Arumaiyana song and your mood about that song vanishes into dark once u see Archana and that guy in a paarkave kan koosum oru costume

:lol: "Oh vasantha Raaja". By the way, andha guy (Bhanu Chandar) ku edhunga costume. Topless-a dhana thirivaaru - Saawariya towel nonsense ku pala varusham munnaadi vandha post-modern munnodi indha song :lol2:

app_engine
23rd March 2010, 01:17 AM
The lyrics were written for the tune if i'm not wrong :)


அதுவும் அழகாக 'சலவை நிலா' என்று எழுதியதை இந்த ராசா அவர் பேருக்குத்தக்க 'இளைய நிலா'வாக மாற்றியது அநியாயம் :-)

Bala (Karthik)
23rd March 2010, 01:20 AM
The lyrics were written for the tune if i'm not wrong :)


அதுவும் அழகாக 'சலவை நிலா' என்று எழுதியதை இந்த ராசா அவர் பேருக்குத்தக்க 'இளைய நிலா'வாக மாற்றியது அநியாயம் :-)
:razz:

Bala (Karthik)
23rd March 2010, 01:27 AM
Aana app,
Raasa vaasicha guitar-a kettuttu, screen la Mohan strumming and picking ellam paakkumbodhu........... bhava bayaharam!

Nerd
23rd March 2010, 02:04 AM
3. Style - Sivaji - PD is the culprit here, although I can understand the reason for the sluggishness in the choreo. After all, Shankar wanted it to be as static as possible for him to play with the graphics.

Three much boss. Its one of the best.

jaiganes
23rd March 2010, 02:21 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZWay1Y-1Yc

bass devastation*........adhu eppadi indha manushan (raja) can draw such a brash, beautiful painting without any "inputs" or a "drawing board" (writing/theme) :bow: ......

and picturisation - sit back and relax - u can watch it in office, yeah

*which brings me to the point- did raja stop with his bass work with this song or round abt that period?? i didnt see much guitar delights in 90s - can someone like plum or bala enlighten??
his Bass guitar prominence kinda faded out in late 90s. Till 1995 there was bass guitar with all the gusto - checkout Raasave unnai vidamaaten from Aranmanai kili which has very good picturisation for 65% of the song - remaining 35% the lady in the picture spoils it.
Off late Bass guitar is back with full prominence and eminence - listen to chal chalein, paa, kannukkuLLe and madhiya chennai songs.
Chal chalein has one of the worst picturiasations ever possibile and madhiya chennai takes the cake for thamizh films.

app_engine
23rd March 2010, 02:25 AM
Aana app,
Raasa vaasicha guitar-a kettuttu, screen la Mohan strumming and picking ellam paakkumbodhu........... bhava bayaharam!

I agree. :-) However, with the exception of a few artists, most show ignorance when handling musical instruments illeengaLA?

For a naive movie-goer (most were / are) , Mohan was so adorable in that movie that ran for a silver jubilee - and the success was powered by Raja's name & songs. (The loud arrival of Gounder was enjoyed by many as well at that time).

Any negative opinion on the "songs on screen" would have killed the movie then :-)

Though "popular opinion" should not be a criteria for the hub, though the picturization didn't measure up to the greatness of the song in every respect, I find it difficult to classify as a bad / worst case as well.

The song situation - of an affluent girl writing a poem that slips through the window, falls in a poor neighborhood "store" houses and getting composed into a song was so enjoyable to me personally. I felt very real, going by any average TN town neighborhood - Chennai is no exception.

We don't get such nice "situations" that often in our movies:-)

AudazJay
23rd March 2010, 07:11 AM
Pani vizhum malarvanam
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dtXXEYS-5Yk

enna kodumai sir ithu :lol:

The dancing was horrible! And check out Karthik's dance step at 2.51-3.00! :lol: :rotfl3:

Roshan
23rd March 2010, 10:14 AM
VM's take on this subject :

http://chandanaar.blogspot.com/2010/03/blog-post_12.html



திடீரென்று ஒரு கேள்வியை வீசினேன். "நீங்கள் எழுதிய பாடல்களை இசையோடு கேட்கும் ரசிகனுக்கு மனதில் காட்சிகள் அற்புதமாய் விரிகின்றன. ஆனால் அவை படமாக்கப்படும் போது அவை எங்கேயோ தொலைந்து விடுகின்றன. ஒரு படைப்பாளியாக உங்கள் கவிதை வரிகள் படமாக்கப்படுவதில் உங்களுக்கு திருப்தி இருக்கிறதா? " கவிஞர் என்னை நிமிர்ந்து பார்த்தார். சற்று நிதானித்து விட்டு " இது ஒரு நல்ல கேள்வி உங்களுக்கு. தர்மசங்கடமான கேள்வி எனக்கு " என்று வெடித்து சிரித்தார். தன பாடல் வரிகள் காட்சியமைப்புகளில்வீணாக்கபடுவதில் அவருக்குள் இருந்த வருத்தம் எனக்கு துல்லியமாக தெரிந்தது. ராஜாவின் பல பாடல்களுக்கும் நிகழ்ந்த துயரம் இது. ராஜாவின் ஒற்றை வயலின் உயிரை அறுக்கும் இசைக்கு கதாநாயகியின் இடுப்பு நெளிந்து கொண்டிருக்கும். "இருந்தாலும் நான் நினைத்ததை விட சிறப்பாக படமாக்கப்பட்ட பாடல்களில் எனக்கு பிடித்தவை 'ஆயிரம் தாமரை மொட்டுகளே',' உயிரே உயிரே (பாம்பே) ' போன்ற பாடல்கள் .." என்றார்.


Thanks for this link a_e :)

Plum
23rd March 2010, 10:39 AM
how many TF directors had EVER had the courage to make lead actors out of Sudhakar, Pandiyan, Sathyaraj and the likes

App, nInga vEra - idhellAm blessing, idhaiyellAm solli varuthapadakUdadhu?!

Plum
23rd March 2010, 10:40 AM
Plum. அது ஒரு genre.

nInga enna arthathula solrInga ;-)

Plum
23rd March 2010, 10:42 AM
The lyrics were written for the tune if i'm not wrong :)


அதுவும் அழகாக 'சலவை நிலா' என்று எழுதியதை இந்த ராசா அவர் பேருக்குத்தக்க 'இளைய நிலா'வாக மாற்றியது அநியாயம் :-)
:razz:
:D

app_engine
23rd March 2010, 07:14 PM
how many TF directors had EVER had the courage to make lead actors out of Sudhakar, Pandiyan, Sathyaraj and the likes

App, nInga vEra - idhellAm blessing, idhaiyellAm solli varuthapadakUdadhu?!

:lol:

Jyothsna
23rd March 2010, 09:08 PM
Vaseegara- Minnale

Kadhalenum mudiviliyil kadigara neram kidayathe na- udane framela oru kadigaram :banghead:

HonestRaj
23rd March 2010, 09:36 PM
how many TF directors had EVER had the courage to make lead actors out of Sudhakar, Pandiyan, Sathyaraj and the likes

App, nInga vEra - idhellAm blessing, idhaiyellAm solli varuthapadakUdadhu?!

and the likes

yaradhu.. yaradhu.. enakku ippave therinjaganum :twisted:

tamizharasan
24th March 2010, 01:29 AM
Vaseegara- Minnale

Kadhalenum mudiviliyil kadigara neram kidayathe na- udane framela oru kadigaram :banghead:

I have been thinking of writing this for a long time. I had so much expectations for this song after hearing. After seeing the song in the movie I was disappointed to say the least. Aaj main Upar aasman neeche on Khamoshi was also equally disappointing picturisation for me.

bingleguy
24th March 2010, 01:44 AM
Vaseegara- Minnale

Kadhalenum mudiviliyil kadigara neram kidayathe na- udane framela oru kadigaram :banghead:

:thumbsup: sariyAna choice ....
:omg: paatu first time kekkum podhe i listened it for almost 10-12 times continuous aaa ..... lost the interest when i saw it on screen ... :(

app_engine
24th March 2010, 02:04 AM
and the likes

yaradhu.. yaradhu.. enakku ippave therinjaganum :twisted:

Bala(Karthik) had given another example - the boy in 'அந்த நெலாவத்தான் என் கையில புடிச்சேன்'. K Bhagyaraj was funny in pudhiya vArppugaL ('வான் மேகங்களே'யில் இவரும் ரதியும் செய்யும் வேடிக்கைகள் சிரிப்பு ரகம்).

For that matter, every new hero intro'd by BR, with the rare exception of Karthik, were funny specimens :-)

AudazJay
24th March 2010, 01:36 PM
and the likes

yaradhu.. yaradhu.. enakku ippave therinjaganum :twisted:

Bala(Karthik) had given another example - the boy in 'அந்த நெலாவத்தான் என் கையில புடிச்சேன்'. K Bhagyaraj was funny in pudhiya vArppugaL ('வான் மேகங்களே'யில் இவரும் ரதியும் செய்யும் வேடிக்கைகள் சிரிப்பு ரகம்).

For that matter, every new hero intro'd by BR, with the rare exception of Karthik, were funny specimens :-)

Even Karthik was funny when he was first introduced :P

Thirumaran
24th March 2010, 01:42 PM
how many TF directors had EVER had the courage to make lead actors out of Sudhakar, Pandiyan, Sathyaraj and the likes

App, nInga vEra - idhellAm blessing, idhaiyellAm solli varuthapadakUdadhu?!

and the likes

yaradhu.. yaradhu.. enakku ippave therinjaganum :twisted:

Vijaykantha thaan solraanga :poke:

Thirumaran
24th March 2010, 01:43 PM
Vaseegara- Minnale

Kadhalenum mudiviliyil kadigara neram kidayathe na- udane framela oru kadigaram :banghead:

:thumbsup: sariyAna choice ....
:omg: paatu first time kekkum podhe i listened it for almost 10-12 times continuous aaa ..... lost the interest when i saw it on screen ... :(

antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

MADDY
24th March 2010, 02:55 PM
antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

//Hanumaar avatar vechikittu pesura pechha idhu - no decent, no culture//

hattori_hanzo
24th March 2010, 03:08 PM
"சந்தன்கள் பாடாத..." from Auto Raja

Thirumaran
24th March 2010, 03:21 PM
antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

//Hanumaar avatar vechikittu pesura pechha idhu - no decent, no culture//

vittaa naan hanuman avatar vachchathukaaga en wife a divorce pannanumnu solluveenga poala :lol2:

appadi pannaa athu nallathu thaangrathu vaera vishayam :|

mnaren555
24th March 2010, 03:27 PM
antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

//Hanumaar avatar vechikittu pesura pechha idhu - no decent, no culture//

vittaa naan hanuman avatar vachchathukaaga en wife a divorce pannanumnu solluveenga poala :lol2:

appadi pannaa athu nallathu thaangrathu vaera vishayam :|anni number kodunga na ennala mudinja help pandrean :lol:

avven
24th March 2010, 03:28 PM
antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

//Hanumaar avatar vechikittu pesura pechha idhu - no decent, no culture//

vittaa naan hanuman avatar vachchathukaaga en wife a divorce pannanumnu solluveenga poala :lol2:

appadi pannaa athu nallathu thaangrathu vaera vishayam :|

sabaaa entha ball potalum goal adikirarei(vadivel style la) :lol: :twisted:

Thirumaran
24th March 2010, 03:39 PM
antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

//Hanumaar avatar vechikittu pesura pechha idhu - no decent, no culture//

vittaa naan hanuman avatar vachchathukaaga en wife a divorce pannanumnu solluveenga poala :lol2:

appadi pannaa athu nallathu thaangrathu vaera vishayam :|anni number kodunga na ennala mudinja help pandrean :lol:

naan ungala ellaam ivlo kastapaduthiyum enakku help panna thudikereengalae .. enakku paechchae varala :cry:

mnaren555
24th March 2010, 03:41 PM
antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

//Hanumaar avatar vechikittu pesura pechha idhu - no decent, no culture//

vittaa naan hanuman avatar vachchathukaaga en wife a divorce pannanumnu solluveenga poala :lol2:

appadi pannaa athu nallathu thaangrathu vaera vishayam :|anni number kodunga na ennala mudinja help pandrean :lol:

naan ungala ellaam ivlo kastapaduthiyum enakku help panna thudikereengalae .. enakku paechchae varala :cry:arasiyala ithu ellam saathaRANAM na :lol:

saradhaa_sn
24th March 2010, 05:30 PM
antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

//Hanumaar avatar vechikittu pesura pechha idhu - no decent, no culture//

vittaa naan hanuman avatar vachchathukaaga en wife a divorce pannanumnu solluveenga poala :lol2:

appadi pannaa athu nallathu thaangrathu vaera vishayam :|anni number kodunga na ennala mudinja help pandrean :lol:
//dig
அவரு டைவர்ஸ்தான் கேட்டாரு...
நீங்க அவருக்கு இன்னைக்கு சோறே கிடைக்காம செஞ்சிடுவீங்க போலிருக்கு.//

saradhaa_sn
24th March 2010, 05:35 PM
"சந்தன்கள் பாடாத..." from Auto Raja
'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத தமிழை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது'

MADDY
24th March 2010, 05:45 PM
antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

//Hanumaar avatar vechikittu pesura pechha idhu - no decent, no culture//

vittaa naan hanuman avatar vachchathukaaga en wife a divorce pannanumnu solluveenga poala :lol2:

hanumar madhiri strict bachoolar-a illatiyum, atleast hanumar-oda idol sri ramachandra murthy madhiri eka pathni viradhan-a irukklaam-la.......neenga ennada naa ega-patta pathni viradhan-a irukkanumnnu aasa padreenga :P

Plum
24th March 2010, 05:51 PM
ega-patta pathni viradhan
:lol:

Plum
24th March 2010, 05:51 PM
"சந்தன்கள் பாடாத..." from Auto Raja
'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத தமிழை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது'

சங்கத்தில் பாடாத கவிதை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது

:-)

raghavendran
24th March 2010, 05:54 PM
"சந்தன்கள் பாடாத..." from Auto Raja
'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத தமிழை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது'

சங்கத்தில் பாடாத கவிதை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது

:-)
yaar mesic?

Plum
24th March 2010, 05:54 PM
"சந்தன்கள் பாடாத..." from Auto Raja
'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத தமிழை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது'

சங்கத்தில் பாடாத கவிதை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது

:-)
yaar mesic?
IR

Thirumaran
24th March 2010, 05:57 PM
antha periya kambaththa pidichittu, ippadiyum appadiyum reema aadurathu nallaa irukkum paa :roll:

//Hanumaar avatar vechikittu pesura pechha idhu - no decent, no culture//

vittaa naan hanuman avatar vachchathukaaga en wife a divorce pannanumnu solluveenga poala :lol2:

appadi pannaa athu nallathu thaangrathu vaera vishayam :|anni number kodunga na ennala mudinja help pandrean :lol:
//dig
அவரு டைவர்ஸ்தான் கேட்டாரு...
நீங்க அவருக்கு இன்னைக்கு சோறே கிடைக்காம செஞ்சிடுவீங்க போலிருக்கு.//
nallathu thaan... inimaelaachchum hotel la nalla soaru saapidalaam :cheer:

Thirumaran
24th March 2010, 06:00 PM
hanumar madhiri strict bachoolar-a illatiyum, atleast hanumar-oda idol sri ramachandra murthy madhiri eka pathni viradhan-a irukklaam-la.......neenga ennada naa ega-patta pathni viradhan-a irukkanumnnu aasa padreenga :P

:rotfl:

hmmm neenga sollra rumour unmayaa irunthaa evvalavu nallaa irukkum :sigh2:

Jyothsna
24th March 2010, 06:17 PM
hanumar madhiri strict bachoolar-a illatiyum, atleast hanumar-oda idol sri ramachandra murthy madhiri eka pathni viradhan-a irukklaam-la.......neenga ennada naa ega-patta pathni viradhan-a irukkanumnnu aasa padreenga :P

:rotfl:

hmmm neenga sollra rumour unmayaa irunthaa evvalavu nallaa irukkum :sigh2:

TM anna.. Krishnaroda avatar vachikonga poruthama irukkum 8-)

HonestRaj
24th March 2010, 06:36 PM
"சந்தன்கள் பாடாத..." from Auto Raja
'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத தமிழை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது'

சங்கத்தில் பாடாத கவிதை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது

:-)
yaar mesic?

vEra yaar :)

Thirumaran
24th March 2010, 10:40 PM
hanumar madhiri strict bachoolar-a illatiyum, atleast hanumar-oda idol sri ramachandra murthy madhiri eka pathni viradhan-a irukklaam-la.......neenga ennada naa ega-patta pathni viradhan-a irukkanumnnu aasa padreenga :P

:rotfl:

hmmm neenga sollra rumour unmayaa irunthaa evvalavu nallaa irukkum :sigh2:

TM anna.. Krishnaroda avatar vachikonga poruthama irukkum 8-)

:mrgreen: Krishnar naughty yaa irunthaa ellaarum like panraanga..naan naughty yaa irunthaa ellaarum kamnaaaty ngraanga :evil:

hattori_hanzo
25th March 2010, 04:51 PM
"சந்தன்கள் பாடாத..." from Auto Raja
'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத தமிழை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது'

சங்கத்தில் பாடாத கவிதை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது

:-)
yaar mesic?

It is an early 80's movie : Superb meesic + IR & Janaki's voices + Konjam sensuous lyrics (The music was later copied in a Jewellery Shop advertisement). Ellam irundhum, picturisation was a major letdown. Andha heroinea nenacha rombave bayamma thaan irukku.

saradhaa_sn
25th March 2010, 07:02 PM
"சந்தன்கள் பாடாத..." from Auto Raja
'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத தமிழை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது'

சங்கத்தில் பாடாத கவிதை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது

:-)
yaar mesic?

It is an early 80's movie : Superb meesic + IR & Janaki's voices + Konjam sensuous lyrics (The music was later copied in a Jewellery Shop advertisement). Ellam irundhum, picturisation was a major letdown. Andha heroinea nenacha rombave bayamma thaan irukku.
முதலில் இந்த ட்யூன் 'ஓளங்கள்' என்ற (அம்பிகா, பூர்ணிமா நடித்த) மலையாள படத்தில் வரும் 'தும்பி வா' பாடலுக்காகத்தான் இளையராஜாவால் கம்போஸ் செய்யப்பட்டு அப்படத்தில் இடம்பெற்றது. பின்னர் அவரே இதை அவர் இசையமைத்த 'ஆட்டோ ராஜா' படத்தில் வரும் 'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத கவிதை' பாடலுக்காக பயன்படுத்திக்கொண்டார்.

Thirumaran
25th March 2010, 07:08 PM
Youtube link for the song

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eEQa7c4UAx4

raghavendran
25th March 2010, 07:21 PM
"சந்தன்கள் பாடாத..." from Auto Raja
'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத தமிழை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது'

சங்கத்தில் பாடாத கவிதை
அங்கத்தில் யார் தந்தது

:-)
yaar mesic?

It is an early 80's movie : Superb meesic + IR & Janaki's voices + Konjam sensuous lyrics (The music was later copied in a Jewellery Shop advertisement). Ellam irundhum, picturisation was a major letdown. Andha heroinea nenacha rombave bayamma thaan irukku.
முதலில் இந்த ட்யூன் 'ஓளங்கள்' என்ற (அம்பிகா, பூர்ணிமா நடித்த) மலையாள படத்தில் வரும் 'தும்பி வா' பாடலுக்காகத்தான் இளையராஜாவால் கம்போஸ் செய்யப்பட்டு அப்படத்தில் இடம்பெற்றது. பின்னர் அவரே இதை அவர் இசையமைத்த 'ஆட்டோ ராஜா' படத்தில் வரும் 'சங்கத்தில் பாடாத கவிதை' பாடலுக்காக பயன்படுத்திக்கொண்டார்.
ya thumbeeva...my frnds have performed this song in a competition....i remember now

Plum
25th March 2010, 07:46 PM
That tune has nine lives.

app_engine
25th March 2010, 08:13 PM
[tscii:8d7d5970c2]From another thread :



* Actually the movie “Auto Raja” has music composed by none other than Shankar Ganesh. The producer of the movie was impressed by the song “Thumbi Vaa” from Olangal.So he requested our Maestro Ilaiyaraaja to compose the same tune in Tamil and the final product is “ Sangathil Paadatha Kavidhai”

[/tscii:8d7d5970c2]

Scale
1st April 2010, 11:44 AM
Madonna Paadala Nee (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sURnnOL1ccc) :banghead:

One of the worst, thoughtless song, lyrics, picturization, costumes, dance movements from KR-KH-PD is quiet scandalizing. ammani :yessir:

priya32
1st April 2010, 07:43 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TC3QjPkI76c

Such a beautiful song to hear as an audio...video? Waste of time, money...everything! :banghead: