what do you hate OR like in MD ?

DISCUSS here fault and quality of every md

for me
ilayaraja's fault is he don't know use the western instrument in his songs
quality, he is original, use tradition instrument very well, he have own music

rahman's fault: is he take 5 or 6 month to give one album and copy the music of western
quality: good choice of singers, good mix of western and traditionnel music, quality of songs

vidyasagar fault: same style of duppanguttu songs, choice of singers in some songs, singers who don't prononced tamil very well
quality:his "dappanguttu" songs, some melodys

yuvansangar raja fault: his music look like to arr.
quality: his music look like too much arr's, foottapping songs, melodys

hj fault : he is an veritable copy cut of arr, openning of his songs with words who don't exist in tamil.
quality: good choice of singer, melodys.

coucou,
what do you mean by 'western' instruments ??
IMO, when it comes to violin (viola, cello, bass), Guitar, Piano, various wind instruments (trumpet, Horns, Clarinet etc)
Raja's the best.

Pls list your 'western' instruments.

haahahaha...athane parthen,y no one came & talk about that portion yet.....:P:P!yes shankar,he has used many western instruments,but he never succeed in giving a number which rocked the whole world,he cant even do half of what YSR is doing!im sure u agree with me rite?!

coucou,

first of all,the allegations that u hve put on MDs are wrong atleast for ARR and IR....

IR has used western instruments but his recording quality was not good...so u feel he has never used western instruments

ARR has never copied from western albums....pls i'm sick and tired of this accusation....its just he has used the s/w loops from western albums....his tunes r original........infact he never uses loops as such- he reprogrammes them and then uses it.......

pls yaar, post accusations after reading our comments atleast :D ....we have explained these things 1000 times atleast....

interesting thread, why did coucou not comment on rahman?? was he afraid of arr rahmans fans reactions??

i don't say ir don't use western music but he don't know how use in one song. i hate every songs of ir wher he use western instrument.

maddy i want to say arr inspire of western music

interz i haven't comment arr because i can't find fault in arr. it is most difficile.

i can,1 of ARR's fault is he gives credit for the musican who is involved in his music,with that,many of the musicans fans claiming that that particular song the musican worked on was composed & done by that musician,like Harris jeyaraj and Ranjit barot..many hJ fans claiming that Mudhalvane in mudhalvan was done by Hj,and many bgm for ARR's movies was done by Hj...Ranjit barot too claiming he composed 2 songs in KKKK...

one more fault is that ARR used many western instruments nowdays,it was soothing to listen Sangamam when it got released...and its been a gap we listen to a pure clasical number from ARR,duncha guys think?!

>>yes shankar,he has used many western instruments,but he never succeed in giving a number which rocked the whole world,he cant even do half of what YSR is doing!im sure u agree with me rite?!<<

I generally refrain from arguing with imbeciles...

...and in case you know what a bass guitar is, pls listen to songs like "iLam pani thuLir vidum nEram" (from ArAdhanai) to know Raja's expertise in using them.

other arr's fault he doesn't choose KK. why? WHY? WHY?

http://www.behindwoods.com/features/...ectors-10.html

WHY ilayaraja isn't here?

"WHY ilayaraja isn't here?"

maybe they thought he was 2 gr8 to be added in that list :D ....

"listen to songs like "iLam pani thuLir vidum nEram" (from ArAdhanai) "....gr8....but compare it with chaiyya chaiyya interlude.......ARR ceases the competition with superior sound quality.....

ARR fans r learning finer aspects of music.....summa 1980la irundhu oru paatu solli, andha paatu madhiri varumannu bayamooruthathinga...... :lol:

hey 1 aspect that i dislike abt both ARR and IR is the fact that they dont give music for the masses anymore.....not just masses, they dunt even listen to their fan's requests........very bad....maybe gr8 artistes are such........ :D

"and its been a gap we listen to a pure clasical number from ARR,duncha guys think?!"

u said wats exactly was on my mind,dinesh :D ......i think there r still many carnatic buffs who think ARR is weak in carnatic music.....he shuld do a "shankarabaranam" style movie to seal their mouths.....i wud definitely travel to chennai to see subbudu's face when ARR succeeds in this.........

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by coucou

other arr's fault he doesn't choose KK. why? WHY? WHY?

---

yes he did,in MK ,after he shot fame there,i think ARR let him go on his own way!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Shankar

...and in case you know what a bass guitar is, pls listen to songs like "iLam pani thuLir vidum nEram" (from ArAdhanai) to know Raja's expertise in using them.

---

i though u didin wanna entertain 'imbecile'? y did u bother to answer man,i guess u cant stop ur self from answering!;)...but anywayz,if u didint know,Sivamani mention IR never credits the musicans when they really gave something great,so im sure that particular bit must have been contributed by some1 & IR gets the credit...no time for protg... :twisted:.. :twisted:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

"and its been a gap we listen to a pure clasical number from ARR,duncha guys think?!"

u said wats exactly was on my mind,dinesh :D ......i think there r still many carnatic buffs who think ARR is weak in carnatic music.....he shuld do a "shankarabaranam" style movie to seal their mouths.....i wud definitely travel to chennai to see subbudu's face when ARR succeeds in this.........

---

yes man,im really thirst for a complete clasical songs from ARR like sangamam!if ARR manage to got some carnatic situational like anniyan,im sure ARR would have satisfy many...but sadly those great situational songs went to waste in Anniyan....

every md has plus & minus points,but 1 good thing all the current md shares,they introduce new singers & give them a good market!!

I was expecting Parthiban's Yelelo for ARR to comeback an album in tamil like sangamam, a pure folkish. Unfortunately its shelved.

Hope he reviews it again.

btw, Rising & Meenaxi arent Hindustani classicals.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Scale

Damn! Parthiban's Yelelo is dropped. Hope he reviews it again.

---

consider yelelo gone man...sure no chance :P

The reason for KK departure from ARR is his arrogance.. KK is very arrogant man and I was watching Fame GuruKul and I saw how arrogant is he like Alka Yagnik when judging the singer.. I dont know who made his Judge under what credibility?

And yes Behindwoods is right in saying ARR is number one out there. And also IR should have around no. 6-7 in the list taking Joshwa Sridhar out of the list.

numer 2 is hj, number 3 is ysr. idon't agree with this classement. ysr is much better than hj now. what do you think?

Looking at the list, except ARR, HJ, YSR, VS and Bharadwaj, rest of them should be removed.

I am sad to see that IR is not in the list, inspite of giving good numbers this year (MX, AOKK, ONOK), but I am not bothered about it.

I am also surprised that HJ is ahead of YSR. On the long run YSR will be way ahead of the rest of them.

http://www.behindwoods.com/features/...n-actor-1.html

check the above link (Rajni - CM biggest hit & Kamal missing) and u can understand why IR is not in behindwoods list

Vijayakanth at no: 5 :lol: :lol: pls dont start another thread :evil:

Hmm. Scale you made a good point. They are probably not considering them with the "current" list of folks. Makes perfect sense.

They have "Top 10 Legend", so they will add IR, Rajni, Kamal in there.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by njv

They have "Top 10 Legend", so they will add IR, Rajni, Kamal in there.

---

njv! I thought the above list is a prediction for 2010. Still ARR rocks.... :clap: so they have ignored all IR, Rajni,Kamal & MR. Apart from others certainly Rajni shud be included for his super dooper hit CM (I am not a Rajni fan). Top 10 songs & movies r the worst list I have ever seen. :twisted:

If your point is on top 10 legends, then will they include IR on top 5, for which he certainly deserves (MSV, MGR, Sivaji, KB, BR, BM, TMS,SPB,KJY, Janaki, actress lists & the missed one IR, Rajni,Kamal & MR.) :poke: pettai rap :rotfl: ....

kola kuthu thaan, better they dont disclose top 10 legends :lol:

What I LIKE in MDs is when they give their projects their all and come out with fresh compositions. Fresh is a term that cannot be easily put into words-- one must hear first to know if a song is fresh or not. I think I have mentioned this several times before.

What I HATE in MDs is when they do something just because everybody else is doing it. If MDs are doing this, you will know it.


Regards,
Nityananda Pillai

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

"WHY ilayaraja isn't here?"

maybe they thought he was 2 gr8 to be added in that list :D ....

"listen to songs like "iLam pani thuLir vidum nEram" (from ArAdhanai) "....gr8....but compare it with chaiyya chaiyya interlude.......ARR ceases the competition with superior sound quality.....

ARR fans r learning finer aspects of music.....summa 1980la irundhu oru paatu solli, andha paatu madhiri varumannu bayamooruthathinga...... :lol:

hey 1 aspect that i dislike abt both ARR and IR is the fact that they dont give music for the masses anymore.....not just masses, they dunt even listen to their fan's requests........very bad....maybe gr8 artistes are such........ :D

---

I don't have to quote some obscure song to prove my point.....If you are an objective listener (as you are so fond of saying every now and then - arr's music has made you tolerant :-) ) listen to this with an open mind...lend ur ears to the Bass guitar in the BG and decide urself...

http://as01.coolgoose.com/music/download.php?id=153093

-

maybe u should try indiaglitz they praise ilayaraja above skyes.

why arr doesn't inspire of other young md LIKE YSR, vs??
HE WILL BE LIKE BY EVERBODY.
listen's anniyan's song, it is not original, it is inspired (or copy) of songs arr, but it is hit. :rotfl:

http://www.behindwoods.com/features/...-legend-1.html

ilayaraja is no 1 legend of india, woooooooooooooooooooov!!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by coucou

http://www.behindwoods.com/features/Topten/legends/tamil-cinema-legend-1.html

ilayaraja is no 1 legend of india, woooooooooooooooooooov!!!!

---

:clap: :clap: :clap: :clap: , I have no regrets for this maestro to be picked as top on the list. ALL IR-Fans (esp. njv) time to celebrate atleast behindwoods have given due credits to the maestro finally.

Is MR at 4, Damn! His 1 movie either anjali or roja will throw everyone/others out of the list.... Personally, I feel a top legend should be only a movie director, who has taken every pain to complete a movie successfully.

ayyo pavam KH - 6th.... kodumada saami.. (An Actor, Singer, Director)

Balachander might overwhelm anyone with numbers but MR after BR is the big farce.
BR may be a trendsetter in Tamil but it was MR who took Tamil films to National levels.
And Rajni at 5! They’ve treated the self-proclaimed King harshly. :lol:

Who is at 7,8,9,10(Am not able to go after 6)

KH at 6 after Rajni is a shame.What's the basis for this list?

that shows music overtakes movies,dirs,and actors....GREAT!!!:D:D:D...MUSIC LIVESS!! :D

This is totally unbelievable...IR now 1...cannot accept it. Legends are the one who continues to entertain ppl. till their end of lives, but IR music has stopped at 90s. So he cannot be called a legend same thing with BR and Balachander... The legends are Superstar, kamal Hassan, Mani Ratnam, MGR, Shivaji Ganesan

Scale

THANKS A LOT. Yes, I am celebrating.

Alias

Like dinesh mentioned, Music overtakes the rest. Music Livessssssss.

Here is my list

Musical Legends
IR, MSV, ARR

Lyrists
Kannadasan, Vaali, Vairamuthu

Actors
MGR, Sivaji, Rajni & Kamal

Actress
Savithri

Comedians
Nagesh, Chandrababu, Manorama, Koundamani-Senthil

Directors
KB, Bharathiraja, Manirathnam

Singers
SPB, KJY, Janaki, VJ

I think just what njv did, they should have seperated in their individual field instead of combining them. And how come Sivaji Ganesan name is missing?