Even the opening lines of Iyengaru veetu azhage is just Mahaganapathim.
In the Sugumari song there comes a veena bit which is from Sampurna Ramayanam, IIRC (Malayalil padum ragam edhu? and then the veena).
Printable View
Even the opening lines of Iyengaru veetu azhage is just Mahaganapathim.
In the Sugumari song there comes a veena bit which is from Sampurna Ramayanam, IIRC (Malayalil padum ragam edhu? and then the veena).
Veda, Music director of Jaishankar days was an expert in copying Hindi songs to suit tamil . Most of his songs are clear and straight copying from Hindi hit songs.
Not to forget Shankar Ganesh , specialists in copying.
Originals are from MSV and IR . They are genius in their own right.
Not only the opening lines vijayr, The whole song is 100% ditto of the maha ganapathim !Quote:
Originally Posted by vijayr
NagaS
sadly no :PQuote:
Originally Posted by alias
here are complete lifts from Hj in Anniyan ( From ARR )
I have recorded only the copied bits so its easy to listen,here!!
1.Kumari ( 1) En Uyri Tozhiyea (1)
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176425/En_Uyir1.mp3.html
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176448/kumari_1.mp3.html
-Style!! how the piano & the female voice introduction
2.Kumari ( 2) En Uyir Tozhiyea (2)
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176476/En_Uyir2.mp3.html
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176505/kumari_2.mp3.html
- how the male singer sings the line & female voice enters with using same word for Guys ( Kumara & Un Uyir Tozhiyea)
3.Kumari (3) Baba Kichu Kichu
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176352/Baba_Kumari.mp3.html
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176398/Kumari_baba.mp3.html
- Do i need to say more,listen to ur self!
4.Randaka Gopala
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176538/Gopala.mp3.html
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176519/Randaka.mp3.html
- Starting beat,i think the tempo is diff!!
5.Kadhal Yaanai Sa Re Ga Me
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176547/sare_game.mp3.html
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176560/k...yanai.mp3.html
-Same style ( is it coz of genre? )
6.Iyengaaru Narumugaye
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176584/Narumugaye.mp3.html
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176573/Iyengaaru.mp3.html
-Pure class copy!! only tempo is diff.... ( is this veenai in any original carnatic music ?? if it is,please accept my appology)
7.Discovered by Aravind :
Iyengaaru Sneghidene
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176884/Snegithane.mp3.html
http://rapidshare.de/files/3176849/aiyangaru.mp3.html
-Hmmm....eventhough 9 secs,lift is still a lift!
Not only Vedha, Shanker Ganesh, Deva.... many music dorectors copying from Hindi tunes or from old tunes.....
S.A.Rajkumar will compose 10 songs with one tune.
In previous days we can easily find out what are all copied tunes, because there will be verieties of tunes. But now..?????
See, what is the different in tunes for the following songs:
Appadi podu...podu...podu...
Dhimsukattai...ai...ai..dhimsukattai....
Aalthotta boopathy naanada....
Machaan peru madurey......
Nee endha ooru naan endha ooru.....
all are 'xerox' of one tune.
Recently in "Raaga Maaliga" programme (in Jaya TV) SPB came as judge. One male singer sung Ilaiyaraja's "Pazhamuthir chollai unakkagathaan" (varusham 16). Suddenly SPB pointed out that, this song is from R.D.Burman's Hindi tune, and SPB sung the Hindi song also.
IR has plenty of inspired songs from old HFM MDs. saradha, do you remember atleast a couple of the words of the RDB song which SPB mentioned?
Hello,Quote:
Originally Posted by vijayr
Pls pls for heaven's sake do not drag IR here. IR is God's gift to Tamil music and nobody can reach his levels .
Lets not drag IR here and also MSV . They are genius in their way.
Their contribution to Tamil music cannot be measured.
When making allegations, please substantiate with the song names so that we can verify.
By the by, RD Burman was named Chor D Burman in Usenet RMIM newsgroups for his countless lifts :lol: :lol: