Which MD is best suited for Rajini?

Rude Me! Where were you when said that earlier! :evil:

narayanan,

What? I do understand whats your point now. "Lata M is the nightingale of India" She & her sisters contributions towards indian/tamil music is something amazing & proud to be forever.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Scale

Rude Me! Where were you when said that earlier! :evil:

.

---

I can expect such things from thumburu.. But not from you.. Anyhow Leave it..

<dgn>

Many people (whom u respect for music knowledge) ridiculed GODFATHER Album to the core.. and ofcourse the movie and their expectations.. Where were u at that time? Just curious. NO offense meant.. I am seeing this from many people.. who ridicule the album and compare it with parasuraam, etc

</dgn>

Selva,

Trust me, He is the most dignified hubber here. Most of his posts are eyeopener. Read his GF review again... He defended a lift-claim & genuinely points IR's song similarity. I have seen him several times, different topics postings solely. But he never crossed his limit like narabali, calling nick names against hubbers. He is the one who technically analysed every MD in the industry mostly neutrally.

END. :wave:

ramakrishna :evil: .....idhu theavaya......ellam nee start panna topicnaladhan.....unna paarka varuvenla appa paarthukkuran..... :lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

ramakrishna :evil: .....idhu theavaya......ellam nee start panna topicnaladhan.....unna paarka varuvenla appa paarthukkuran..... :lol:

---

:lol: :lol: :lol:

How about Thai Veedu? SG stole all the Hindi tunes from Bappilahari.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rajasaranam

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea

Narayan, but both of Rajini's home production movies PADAYAPPA and BABA had ARR right !!! :)
When BABA was made, Rajini was even willing to wait for ARR and get the music offline, all the way from London !! Does that mean something ?? :? :?

---

It Doesn't mean anything other than the pathetic situation Rajini is in.
He had Raja Score for his home production 'Ragavendra' and almost a directorial debut 'Valli'. [Rajini Wrote the Story, Screenpaly and dialogues for this movie.]. valli got released in 1993 after ARR's entry.
It is IR who started Rejecting Rajini's movies after 'Annamalai' produced by Kavithalayaa and IR was coaxed a lot to do 'Veera' for the sake of Panju Arunachalam. After that Rajini's attempts to Team up with IR had gone waste and he patched up the realtion just during 'Thiruvasagam' release.
Thats why for the Movies 'Chandramukhi' and 'sivaji' Both IR's and Rajini's fans had huge expectation of Them Working together again. Just before the team's announcement for Shivaji...Shankar was seen in IR's daughter Bava's Marriage function. (Mind it He had never attened any of IR's family functions before.) It shows how much effort Rajini is putting in to Team up with IR again.
But IR's Adamancy is well known :(
and I hope he comes out his shell and team up with all those like Manirathnam, Barathiraja, rajinikanth et all who are dying to do so

---

* What pathetic situation are you talkin abt ? I thought he got himself into a bad situation only after the flop of BABA ... Before that, he was still havin a great time ... Otherwise, the expectations for that movie wouldnt have skyrocketed that much !! :D

* I think you've put it exactly the other way round ... Rajini doesnt have to coax anybody to score music for his movies ... Even if VS does it, the album will still be a best seller for his own brand and image !! :notworthy:

* "IR's adamancy is well known" .. You said it !! :thumbsup:

* Again, BR, MR, and all who once used to team up with IR have found an equivalent if not a better subsitue in ARR !!! :clap:

In my opinion, any first movie for RK would be phenomenol for the any MD, coz I guess every director has a story line for RK and way they want to portray it, So expecting Muthu to be good is seriously no-brainer or Chandramukhi by VS for the matter of fact. If I can see consistency ( cannot talk about VS ), IR seems to have the edge. after churning out so many movies he always had the niche of differentiating RK's movie songs (poetic justice). In my opinion, ARR's first was good, padayappa ( i did not like it), baba (a couple of songs were good). Deva was consistently good for the 3 movies.
My vote will go to IR, followed by Deva, and ARR (with regards to consistency), but Sivaji could prove different for ARR as it is shankars movie. Wait and see would be a good thing. most suited-IR has the crown and the edge.

Iam one of the big fan of IR's music. I hv. a collection of almost all of his songs.

My views are that IR is a natural born genius. Not the one, who puts lot of brains into work like ARR. He does not do anything special for composing. It does come naturally from him and thats why he is gifted.

At the same time, he is not so good in dealing with people. and is very difficult person to move along. If he had used his brains, with his natural born talent, he would hv definitely conquered the world with his enchanting music.(unfortunately, he is foolish).

still, if IR joins hands with the likes of manirathnam, bharathiraja, rajinikant, we will be gifted with everlasting musicals.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Aravind_06

Iam one of the big fan of IR's music. I hv. a collection of almost all of his songs.

My views are that IR is a natural born genius. Not the one, who puts lot of brains into work like ARR. He does not do anything special for composing. It does come naturally from him and thats why he is gifted.

---

Ennatha sollavaruringa.. ??