Was only kidding. ARR had more inspiration from MSV than IR and even IR has his inspiration from MSV. Nothing wrong in it. MSV showed the way to IR and ARR. MSV is a musical pithamagan.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scale
Printable View
Was only kidding. ARR had more inspiration from MSV than IR and even IR has his inspiration from MSV. Nothing wrong in it. MSV showed the way to IR and ARR. MSV is a musical pithamagan.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scale
hey i can accept the pukar one but not the Swades song.....undhan desathin kural is one of ARR's best songs it is 100% ARR's and not a MSV-inspired song.....Quote:
Originally Posted by Music4Ever
:clap: :clap:Quote:
Originally Posted by vijayr
well said vijay, YSR, who is supposed to replace ARRahman at the top, blatantly remixes IR's songs.....
Can't ignore when two have contested my observation :)
First of all, I believe the song is an inspiration and not a blatant lift. And now for the exact postion, listen after Gangai unnai azhaikkiradhu ... pala samayam unai azhaikiradhu, and then
At 2.45 (on Raaga) the following threatens to remind of the said MSV-TKR song [ :wink: ]
kannAmoochi Attam azhaikka
chinna pattAm poochi kootam azahaikka .....
needhan chinna nila cholaidhan azhaikka
Maybe it is just me, I guess. That said, the resemblance is not unlike Kumari of HJ and Ennuyir thozhiyE of ARR (the former threatens to mimick the latter). The inspiration is subtle and it is often the case with clever MD's. Just my opinion.
Not sure if this is posted earlier..
heard a song from Jithan sung by Shankar Mahadevan (the hero ramesh dancing with two bar dancers kinda).. the entire charanam of the song was a complete shameless rip-off of 'Koduthadhellaam Koduthaan' (Padagotti)...!!!
Gives a feel like, an impotent guy calling some one else's kid as his own.
Is Koranghu Kayil Maalaa (MX) a rehash of Vanam Endhan Melirukka (Vetrivizha) ?
even here
vathiyium beediyum "Hey naina"
My doubts?
I heard nErukku nEr nindru paarungaL pOdhum from edhirigaL jaakkiradhai (music by veda) and the first two lines are exactly like Vaarayen thozi vaarayen thozi vaivittu seeti adi (jeans, ARR)
Just listened to "Aadhi" songs. The first 2 lines in the song "Athi athika" is a note to note rip off from a not so recent song which Iam not able to spot out exactly. I vaguely remember if the song was sung by Swarnalatha.
Indha paata correctaa identify panra adhi budhisaaligaLukku 1000 veLLi kaasugal parisaLikkapadum dum dum dum!!! :) :) :)
I dont listend to songs from VJ movies (exceptions are IR, ARR, YSR) and now I have to listen just to get 1000 velli kaasugal. Okay I will do that tonight :(Quote:
Originally Posted by thumburu
"heard a song from Jithan sung by Shankar Mahadevan (the hero ramesh dancing with two bar dancers kinda).. the entire charanam of the song was a complete shameless rip-off of 'Koduthadhellaam Koduthaan' (Padagotti)...!!!
Gives a feel like, an impotent guy calling some one else's kid as his own."
If one were to list Srikanth Deva's copied songs, one could end up listing his entire discography.He makes his father look remarkably original in comparison.
I dont remember even a single frame from that movie :banghead:. irundhalum 1000 velli kaasugal aache try panren. Yaaru nadicha padam clue pls.Quote:
Originally Posted by njv
:rotfl:Quote:
Originally Posted by vijayr
Recently I heard a remix version of "Adho Andha paravai pola" . Yaaruppa andha punniyavan :evil: :banghead:
"Thiruttu Payalae Thiruttu Payalae sethi keladaa" from Thirutty payalae (credit Bharadwaj) is sounding much like "Arayasiyal Arasiyal ethilium engum arasiyal" from the movie Arasiyal (credit Vidyasagar). A clear copy!!!!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scale
Madrasi - D.IMMAN than!
The beginning music of the PBS's song "etho manidhan piRanthuvittaan" reminds me of some song I heard in DUET.
Anybody agrees or disagrees ? :roll:
wuts PBS???
I meant the play-back singer P B Srinivas!
Please dont ask what is Srinivaas again! :D
Quote:
Originally Posted by stranger
whats srinivas??? :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: Just kidding!!!
Bloody S***. Here is one more revelation. I always thought at least Devuda Devuda in Chandramukhi was VS's own tune, although resembling koduva meesa aruva paarva at places. Today, however, I was listening to a Hindi number on Zee TV and what do I get? The song is from Pyar Kiya To Darne Kiya by Jatin Lalit and it starts like Odhli chunariya. Listen at 3:20 and 5:22 and you will agree that "endha thozhil seidhal enna seyyum thozhil deivam endru Pattukottai paattil sonnanE" is a rip off from this Hindi song. The Hindi audio would have been out in 1998.
Oh, I listened to the number again and I realized that the rip off occurs even at 0:50 itself.
This makes it three ripoffs (this one, Aththindhom, and Ra ra) in one movie itself. An impressive achievement! Pooh.
way to go man, u spent soo much time for finding a reason to critisize my idol.
interz, take it easy. Here is an example of the reverse happening, from Tamil to Hindi. IR's song "vanji kodi manja chedi kandu pidi" goes like "poova mudikka-thaan poovaaram katta-than" somewhere in the song. This exact part can be noticed in the Hindi number that goes Jaan Meri jaane jaana in Thakshak at 1:59. MD is ARR. However, fans might consider this as nitpicking of the highest order from me.
BTW, that song from Ponnumani was composed by KR,not IR.
Couldnt grasp which song and movie were you all discussing. Pls be more specific abt movie & track names. Thanks.
Isnt "Ponnumani" Karthik starrer music by IR? :shock:
eureka!!! 1000 porkaasugaL enakke enakku thaan :)
"athi athikka" from Aathi starting lines resemble an SPB-SL duet " thotta vudam thotta vudam dhaane" from a mid 90's film "karuppu roja" . Both Vidhyasagar and the unknown MD of karuppu roja might have conjured up a similar start
Scale, only that particular song was done by KR, the music for the film was by IR.
Quote:
This makes it three ripoffs (this one, Aththindhom, and Ra ra) in one movie itself. An impressive achievement! Pooh.
I think I missed that discussion. Can u pls enlighten me of what the originals are?
Raa Raa's Original - Raa Raa - ApthamitraQuote:
Originally Posted by kingvj
eventhough the tune was very diff....the arrangements r very close..not to mention the tune " Raa Raa...Sarasukku Raa Raa...Raa Raa chintaku Chera" is a direct lift from the Original Raa Raa....
some1 even said raa raa was very close to 1 song called : isaiyarasi - thaimookambikai ....
Athintom :
Athinthom [Film: Chandramukhi (2005)] <TC>
Composer: Vidyasagar
Seems to have been lifted directly from a traditional Malayalam track of the same name!
Listen to Athinthom (Chandramukhi) | Athinthom (Original)
Supposed to be an old folk song from Kerala made popular by many local bands, including one called 'Karinthalakkootam'!
http://itwofs.com/tamil-others.html
Listen to "King of Chennai" from Badri
http://www.raaga.com/channels/tamil/movie/T0000345.html
"Kannai Vittu" from Pattiyal
http://www.raaga.com/channels/tamil/movie/T0000788.html
The starting tune of the song is the same. When IR lifts from legends Beethovan, MSV etc his son is lifting from Telugu MDs.
Kannai vittu is definitely got nothing to do with that song in Badri. Its in fact a partial lift of Kevin Lyttle's 2003 chartbuster 'Turn me on' that was recently lifted far more blatantly by Anu Malik on Deewane huye paagal as 'Chakle chakle'. Check out No. 55 in the Anu Malik page in www.itwofs.com.
YSR's inspiration is not as blatant as Malik but you could easily make out the first two lines' similarity!
Yesterday i heard a song, which i think Deva got inspired by :D :
LINK: http://www.mytempdir.com/492847
What do you think?? Doesn't the tune sound like "Thundai kaanom" from Devathaya kanden???
I too dont think these one line two line tune resemblence can be called copies. I've heard many songs where the tune resembles some other songs in single line or so. Listen to 'vadu maangai' where the charanam ends 'something like 'sithadai paavadai' its the same tune as in 'sithadai paavadai' of 'thalukki minukki' from Varusham pathinaaru. Probably the current MD's derive some inspiration from a single line in a tune and builds other portions of the song around it. But these can never become copies...As its being done by all top MD's.Quote:
Originally Posted by inetk
BTW why dont you add a page on Lifted songs of Raja in hindi by anand milind, anumalik etc.,
I would love to have a complete picture to know and study what Raja missed to encapture the minds of northies.
Some songs that i can instantly rememeber are
Tu tu tu thara <> Rakkamma kaiya thattu
dhak dhak <> Ammani theeyani
Chandni raat hai[Bhagi] <> keladi kanmani[puthu puthu]
Paayalae chumme chumme <> Inji Idupazhagi
Sathiyaa [love love love] <> Ethetho aasaigal...
There should be more than 50 songs like this...it'll be helpful if you could compile them in separate page :?
rajasaranam and inetk
I also expect the same as rajasaranam. What about "Poove sempoovee" song in Hindi :roll:. Once i read an interview from Anand milind. has told that "we(?) are hardcore fan's of IR thats why we are inspired from him a lot" :lol:
Also i remembered an interview from Anu malik. He told about his copying like this
"How did IR and ARR compose that songs before me"
:rotfl:
The only reason why I didnt get into yet at itwofs is I dont have the time to compile such a long list. I've a simple text list that I have been promising myself to add with saong samples etc. but never come down to do that. Should get that done one of these days or perhaps add it to my year 2007 resolutions :P
I recently heard the song "Lealakku lealakku Leala" from Adhi, and noticed it's a copy from the song by the Desi pop singer Raghav. (www.raghav.com) Especially the underlying beats and rhythms, and of course the chorus.
The song "Aint Nobody" from Raghav's 2004 album "Storyteller" can be heard on raaga.com (go to this link http://www.raaga.com/channels/hindi/movie/HP000011.html and scroll down to the song "aint nobody" and Click to listen). The chorus is especially noticeable!
It's a great song by Raghav, and I am also enjoying the Tamil version, but I cannot believe the way it was just copied!
-Veena
Theres an other song with the same tune!
oruthanuku oruthi - Planet Galatta
hi...
how are u all?
im a new member for this forum.... :D :D :D :D :D
my first post...
yuvan thepidika song from arindum ariyamalum was inspired from jay sean.
the instruments and beat,starting stlye same.
welcome suresh....hope u enjoy ur stay here !
and guys...1 more thing...did anyone notice all these songs sound alike ?? not only they have the same singer,its for the same hero :?
1.Chanakya - Dum
2.Nibuna - Kuthu
3.Manmadhane - Manmadhan
pls give the more details. from jay sean's which song?. is there any online source?. (pls give the details always).Quote:
yuvan thepidika song from arindum ariyamalum was inspired from jay sean.
the instruments and beat,starting stlye same.
thankz.