vaasthava maana paechu :PQuote:
Originally Posted by joe
Printable View
vaasthava maana paechu :PQuote:
Originally Posted by joe
ethana padam nadicha enna? Who is funnier dhaan pechu.. sirippu varudha illiya? matter over :)
100 padam nadichavan 1 padathula funny-a illaina Reject.Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
1 padam nadichavan antha oru padathula funny-a iruntha selected.
- For All time list.
Nalla logic :roll:
Too much hype.... yeah agree. Surely he's not the next biggest thing.
Not always funny - surely agree... many dull moments
He may prove to be a humourless dud in the years to come.
But in his two movies if I count the number of laughs I have had thanks to him it would significantly outnumber what Thangavelu managed to produce.
appadi paartha, inga mokkai vote poadapattirukkura ellaarum few movies layaavathu funny yaa irunthirupaanga :huh:Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Super star listla Kamal, Sivaji mention pannaama thukkada pasanagala ellaam mention panrappa vara maathiri kovam thaane ithuvum :)
Joe,Quote:
Originally Posted by joe
Idha thaan solla vandhen
Quote:
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
Logic appidi illai Joe.. ippidiQuote:
Originally Posted by joe
100 padam nadichavan 1 padathula kooda funny-A illai
2 padam nadichavan 1 padathula funny-A irundhaan.. ini vara ellA padathulayum mokkaiyai pOttaalum, he will beat the first guy
I have already said why in my opinion, humor is different from how we "judge", perceive or appreciate other things... PR um theliva sollirukkaaru what he thinks about humor. It all boils down to whether you laugh or you don't. If somebody says "Sam Anderson acts better than Kamal" i will be either laughing or outraged. However, if someone says "Suruli Rajan is better than Vadivel" i would be ok with it... (both are subjective, still...)Quote:
Originally Posted by Thirumaran
To explain further, i find it extremely strange that many Kounder fans here are :rotfl: to what i think as completely non-funny scenes or lines. Others may think the same if i were to :rotfl: for a seemingly mokkai line from Puyal. OTOH, you wont find too many people disagreeing with NT's performance in Gauravam, for e.g. One can even refine, revise opinions by revisiting. aana, Somehow, humor is different ...
Besides, the super star argument is a completely different ball game because there we are talking about facts - whether you or i like it or not, number of fans, hits, theatre festivities etc are not going to change. They are facts...
PR, kittathatta ethanai KAT padam paarthirupeengga. You find none funny? :shock:
Rubish ,If you are talking about Thangavelu and Premji ,IMOQuote:
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
No point in discussing further.
CR,
Just one straight question to you.
If we list All time 20 comedians in Tamil cinema,Thangaveli will be out of list and Premji will be in ..Do you agree or not?
KalyAna parisuQuote:
Originally Posted by groucho070
alibAbA-vum 40 thirudargaLum
aduththa veettu peN
thEn nilavu
pArthAl pasi theerum
thillAna mOhanAmbAL
galatta kalyAnam
right down to...
manaivi ready
I have not seen aRivALi which is supposed to be his best
As I said, sirikkakkoodaadhunnu kangaNam kattittA ukkAndhiruppAnga.... he at best manages a slight smile ("ungaLukkum mAmA-va" :D in the first confrontation scene in TM). Not once have I been beside myself laughing.
And I also offered a diagnosis that it is perhaps his style that I find unfunny - that dwelling beyond the joke with a drawl
Eg.
CK Sarswathy: dei suruLi
KAT: avan dhaan 8 maNikku suruNduttAnE (joke ends here but KAT continues).. avanappOi suruLinnA
All Time 20 for whom? Me?Quote:
Originally Posted by joe
Number ellam theriyadhu, the straight answer from me is i have laughed more for Premji than TV (i might not be exposed to most of his works, but from what ive seen only "Mannar and Co" worked) - idhu eppadinga yen kutham aagum? :twisted: sirikkumbodhu yosichu mudivedutha sirikkarom?
Naan indha thread oru samanilaikku vandhadhum innum periya guNdu oNNai pOdalaamnu paaththaa... idhuvE konja naaL pOgum pOla irukkE :lol2:
sila vishayangaLai compare panna mudiyAdhE :huh: adE mAdiri sila perai compare pannradhu correct aa match AgAdhu ... IMO :roll:
Sorry..I expected just one word answer.Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
I think i have mistaken this thread is about 'All time unfunny comedians" ,but now understand it is just based on one generation's exposure..
I don't understand why NSK ,Thangavelu etc are brought here.
Bye ..Bye.
//PR :-) idu 10000 wala ;-) neenga konjam turnukku wait pannanumQuote:
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
inga evvalavu periya ranakalam nadakuthu.. ithellaam paththi kavala padaama, konja paer oru thread la kaalaa kaalathukkum ore maathiri mokka poattu sirichuttu irukaangalae.. :confused2:
cmon joe :-) neengaLe ippadi sollalAmA .... its definitely not based on a single generation knowledge .... avar siricha instances vechu solrAru ... may be if hes exposed to more Thangavelu - he might have a different opinion or may be still he sticks to his - either way comparison doesnt work here .....Quote:
Originally Posted by joe
//makkalukkulla friction nna ;-) MOD kitta pogalaam ...Quote:
Originally Posted by Thirumaran
MOD kkullaye friction nna yAr kitta pogardhu
During my school days fanning a rumour pairing up a boy with a girl, was known by the somewhat curious English-Tamil expression : 'compare paNNuradhu'. How the hell that would that be a 'comparison' puzzled the linguist in me. Went with the flow then though. This sentence triggered the memory.Quote:
Originally Posted by bingleguy
Regarding exposure I surely wouldn't say I am underexposed to ThangavElu.Quote:
Originally Posted by Joe
As Bala said, idhukkellAm naangaLA poRuppu... sirikkiradhu sindhanaikku munnAdi nadappadhu.
btw MR Radha, Nagesh ellAm click aagurappO naanga enna generation ?
Yes, *timely* exposure/generation are the key words. adha thaane ithana nerama sollitrukkom :huh: Adutha generation, for example, might just not laugh at Vadivel, why should that be a "problem"?Quote:
Originally Posted by joe
I don't get it :roll:
:-) it was never meant to be ideally ;-) still the expression got its expected response though :P ;-) in your daysQuote:
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
:lol: "Correct panradhu", "sentiment", are also equally annoyingQuote:
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
thalaiver ippothan sonnaar, nalla padam accept pannanum, ketta padam reject pannanum enru. ithai artist ngalukkum seyyalaam.Quote:
Originally Posted by joe
IMO, premji moottina microscopic alavu kichukichu vida, innam kooda per theriyaatha aana mugam parichayamaana palappala comedians oda acting 100 times better nnu solluven...
ithula oru real comedy ennanna, premji yai directors sariyaa use pannikkalainnu avar annan director varthappaduraar. unamyil, ithu thaan enna kodumai saar ithu!!!
ch-28 la padam muzukka intha dialogai oru kazuthai vanthu sollirunthaalum athu popular aagirukkum
not only premji, innum plar, like jeyam ravi, ect oru identity illaamalye establish aairukkaanga. ithu thaan kodumai. ivangalukku sonthamaa oru sarakkum kedayaathu, not only bulding, bust basementum weakku. eppo venaalum buss aagalaam
oru vadivelu, oru vivek, ennikkaavathu director ennai sariaa use pannalainnu varutha pattruppaanglaa?!?!? avingakitta sontha sarakku ekkachakkam. avanga trend setters. premji yellaam hardcore example for mokkai.
atleast santhaanam kooda oru identty create panninaar, athuvum lollu sabaa layee..
premji selected, thangavelu rejected , what naanssense
way of speech .... unanimously spoken ;-) but outright rejection on the language front :-) ... this is a known fact when it comes to speaking this way... heheheQuote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
:lol: Sometimes sindhanaiku pinnadiyum siripu varum :PQuote:
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
PKS: kathaadi ku kooda thaa vaal irukku.. adhanaala korangu parakum'nu solluviya
IMO, premji ellam comedian alla. His characterization was funny and he has got the looks to look funny.. avlo thaan. Ya I did laugh at some of the scenes, but I think anybody could have fitted in.
Sakala,
Actually ,I made this blunder made others to compare Thangavelu with Premji ..I shouldn't have done this kodumai to Thangavelu :(
I didn't bother if this happened to somebody like Karunanithi (comedian) in his era ..But Thangavelu :lol:
Enna pannuRathu ..Naalaike oru padathula super-a nadicha Paruthiveeran Kaarthi is better actor than kamal Hassan ,who has done some duds like mangamma sapatham -nnu sonna naama kopapadama irukkanum ..I have to prepare for that . :(
Vivasayi... naan type panitu irukum podhey neenga post panniteenga :D
Santhanam and Chinni jeyanth were incredibly funny in Sagala ragala.. but when Santhanam went on to do lollu sabha.. i felt irritated very often.. especially moochu pidichu izhuthu izhuthu pesradha ketta... dialogue thamasha irundha kooda sirika thonadhu. His entry into films... adhey case :-|
karpanai varatchi??? or nammaloda over expectation and looking at short term success???Quote:
Originally Posted by joe
//digg
oru ponnu miss world aana udane, ella ponnungalum kelamburaanga, cosmetics business sales touches crores, oru ponnu tennis la vanthaa pala ponnunga kelamburaanga, oru sachin vanthaal athai paarthu evlo inspirations, cricket bat, blue t-shirt sales shoot up
aanaa oru ARR oscar win panninga, guitar sales athigamaaguthaa?? music class join pannuravanga athigamaaraangalaa??
intha karpanai varatchi kooda, premji maathiri oru lumpen arstist per vaanga dam tharuthu(to certain extent)
//end digg
oru diff btw a lots of comedians whose name not known but face familiar is, ivar per premji nnu namakku theriyum, avanga per theriyaathu. avlothaan
Quote:
Originally Posted by joe
Quote:
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
I think i have mistaken this thread is about 'All time unfunny comedians" ,but now understand it is just based on one generation's exposure..
"
Not fair Joe. Thangavelu orutharai dhaane sonnom - Karunas, Ganja Karuppu-nu current generation is well represented in accused list here. Andha kaalathu aalu orutharai kooda solla koodadhunna epdi?
Neengale order pannunga - Nagesh, Chandrababu, MRR(part time), Baliah(Part time), Thangavelu.
Baliah sirikka vecha alavukku kooda Thangavelu pannadhilliye enakku - is it any different for you?
Reserved 1 - 4 vote
Reserved 2 - 1 vote
:roll:
yaaru ivanga? :huh:
Joe,
By the by, have to mention this: Generation nu solreengale, even though i have the generation "handicap" or gap or whatever, yerkanave sonna madhiri, i find Charlie Chaplin and Nadigavel funny... So?
Joe, I think I would reject Premji as a contestant for this list for the same reason we reject Muthukalai, Bailvan Ranganathan, Pandu etc. What do people think? That this is a kaamasoma list that any comedian can walk into? Indha list-la varave oru thagudhi venum - Premji-ellam limited sample size - we cant definitely include him any list - funny or unfunny - yet.
Indha comparison-ai vuttuttu, why shouldnt Thangavelu be in this list ahead of Vivek, Vadivelu, Goundamani-nu sollunga? Isnt that the right comparison to make?
I think modhalla we should create a short list of contestants; In my opinion, following is the list of main comedians in TF history who can be considered:
NSK, Thangavelu, Nagesh, Chandrababu, Thengai, Suruli, YGM, SSC, Janagaraj, Koundamani, Senthil, Vivek, Vadivelu. Santhanam, Ganja Karuppu, Karunas ellam have created a significant body of mokkai work-ngaradhala avangalai include pannalam.
VA moorthy, VKR, charlie pondravanga even though no history as mainstream comedian, make it through longevity.
Idhula, Nagesh, CB, GM, Thengai, Vivek, Vadivelu can be surely unconsidered given their record. We excuse NSK as not in the comedians category. VKR was removed due to popular request here.
That leaves
Modhalla, indha listla add panna koodiya competitors yaaru? Adhai decide pannuvom.
Thangavelu, Suruli, YGM, SSC, Janagaraj, Senthil, Santhanam, Ganja Karuppu, Karunas
Idhula Suruli, YGM, SSC, Santhanam, GK, Karunas are popular candidates for unfunny.
That leaves Thangavelu, Janagaraj and Senthil . Idhula Senthil surely will get Hubber's support to be removed from this list.
Meedhi rendu perum en indha list-la vara koodadhunu case file pannunga respective supporters:
I think we should have a guest nomination for Prashanth here. If not for anything else, for his mindblowingly unfunny ferfarmance in Winner. Ouch, all that coolness.
vaiyapuri aatathukku sethiya illaya?
eq, pls to fill in the nomination form
Here's the format
Candidate Name:
Age:
No. of Films as main comedian/ No. of years as side-mokkai comedian:
Significant mokkai achivements: atleast 3 instances of singularly unfunny attempt at comedy
Strike rate: rough estimate of the ratio of actual funny instances vs total no. of films as comedian (rough estimate will do). Poor strike rate will only be considered
For people wishing to remove anyone from list, here's un-nomination list:
name:
age:
significant funny pieces: atleast 3 instances where said comedian made YOU laugh uncontrollably. Subjectivity accepted.
strike rate: rough estimate of the ratio of actual funny instances vs total no. of films as comedian (rough estimate will do). If strike rate here is accepted widely to be too good, then we can remove this person from the list
(Innum oru sombu, aala maram kediaca nattamai character-ave maaridalam!)