Joe, I think Kalnayak is right. I don't remember which interview it was but I do remember Kamal saying that he expressed his wish to Shivaji to produce a commercial hit as different and entertaining as Uthama Puthiran. But Shivaji reportedly laughed away his idea asking him where he got the impression that Uthama Puthiran was a hit. That was when Kamal himself knew that it was not a hit. But whatever the outcome was, I for one feel that the movie is a lesson in script writing and dialogue delivery. Even today's mass movies can't stand up to the classic entertainer that was Uthama Puthiran.