Malathi RangaRajan also has good respect for IR..but she would have more neutral than this guy.
But who knows..? may be IR was a relief for those who watched the movie :)
Printable View
Malathi RangaRajan also has good respect for IR..but she would have more neutral than this guy.
But who knows..? may be IR was a relief for those who watched the movie :)
AFAIK, She puts her points in a subtle manner if not in a strong way. But she has more or less become 2 * Indiaglitz nowadays. She never highlights even the obvious negatives present in the movie.Quote:
Originally Posted by raja_fan
Nowadays, it is tough to judge anything based on reviews from sites unless we hear / see a particular thing.
btw, raja_fan - Have u seen this movie ? Your opinion on this. :)
Selvakumar,
I have not watched the movie even though I was eagerly planning to do so.
Now the reviews so far are not encouraging me to go to the theatre. I will wait for Sun TV "Ulaga tholai kaatchigalil mudhan muriyaga..Thiraikku vandhu sila maadhangale aana.." :)
Saw MK songs in TV. Disappointing visuals :(
Cheran should limit him with village subjects in my humble opinion..
http://www.tamilcinema.com/CINENEWS/...yakkannadi.asp
Ithu maathiri IR pathi kevalamana vimarsanam naan padichathillai
:hammer:
Sanjeevi,
The comment was very bitter, but true :)
Yeaps mr Vignesh...i guess IR chooses the script based on BGM rather than the songs i suppose...even post-anumanaspadam he had mentioned in a interview that the film was chosen because of the great scope of re-recording...so i guess this is how IR chooses his movies....:D
Those interludes and orchestration is what made me an IR fan rather than the tune...i remember listening to anandha raagam..the tune did not impress me but when i listened to the music in the ludes i got attracted and from then on i always searched for his songs where there would be such instances....i guess i would call myself a fan of orchestration and music rather than the tunes :D
My take on ajanta and IR's current music
http://mumbairamki.wordpress.com/200...anta-md-raaja/
http://mumbairamki.wordpress.com/200...ya-rasigargal/
Hulkster and Vignesh,
IR does not choose films based on songs or BGM.
He chooses based on the producer/director's devotion towards him.
Yaaraavadhu "Ungalai pol oruvar undaa indha ulagil" endru sonnaal podhum. Namma raajaavukku uchi kulirndhu vidum. Udane harmonium petti meedhu viralgalai vaippaar. Mudhal tune vaasippaar. Director-um mandayai nandraaga aatuvaar. Adhe tune nammai vandhu adaiyum. Naam inge paithiyam pidithu adithu kolvom. :)
Then padam ready aagum..Director petti koduppaar "Raja padathai paarthu vittu ennai katti pidithu mutham koduthaar" endru.
Idhai pola evvalavu padangal kadandha 5 varudangalil..
Ippadi usuppethi usuppethiye udambai rana galamaakkittaangappa :D
I guess what raja_fan says is right.
Only when there is no gap or inhibition between the director and MD, the director can interact and get the best out of MD.
In case of Raja, considering his age and accomplishments, the new filmmakers are scared to reject the tunes he come up with.
The first tune that comes up in his mind is the chosen one.
Only directors like Bala have the guts to ask him for alternative tunes.
Remember the Haneefa's character (arrogant MD) in the movie "Mugavari"? It must have been conceived keeping IR in mind.
So,we have to wait till he works again with BR (possibly Kutraparambarai) and MR.
At this time, i want to remember one incident. For Veera, our IR gave lot of tunes (guess more than 50 tunes) and Rajni has selected what he wanted. Thats why Veera was huge hit.
Like IR said in his recent Kumudam interview, now he is in out of current world ("Naan ungala mathiri illa, naan veru oru ulagathula natha ulagathula iruken" :idontgetit: ayyo yaaravathu avara intha world kondu vangalaen :goodidea:). He don't know current trend, current fan's taste. So, film directors, you have to alert when getting music from IR and the music should satisfy people