thiruvasakam in symphony

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by krihoo

but again where youth will prefer IR ...99% TIS listeners and appreciaters will be 'not youth ' and matured and intellectual ....

Maybe if AR does it....... like for vandemataram ...........with all beats in thiruvasakam , then youth will try to understand saint maanickavasagar...ha ha hhaaa

---

Krihoo for that YSR need to do remix of TIS :lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by thumburu

ananth222, I beg to differ from you in this regard. A vedic chant [ For eg take the Gayathri mantra ] has few notes that is meant to create certain spiritual vibration [Like the OM chant is akin to the primordial sound] to the listener and it is not meant to showcase any musical beauty.

---

Well thats my point. We have just grown to think that way about these sounds, so we think that is spiritual. The basic factor in this case is resonance, which is the most primitive enhancement to a sound that takes it to another level (and thus "spiritual").
There are much more complicated concepts such as intervals, scales and harmony which can also take sound to another level. Depending on the context around which these evolve, the population tends to associate it with the relevent sociological concepts.

Whichever way, after hearing IR singing the "maasatra sothi" verses, its hard to think of those verses recited in any other way. To me, those verses recited in a "chant" seems even funny. Chanting those lines that way would take away so much of the meaning!

As a IR fan, I feel TIS is an average work. i am one of those fans who expected IR would rise from ashes with TIS. But in vain it goes as usual.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vysar

As a IR fan, I feel TIS is an average work. i am one of those fans who expected IR would rise from ashes with TIS. But in vain it goes as usual.

---

ENT - one stop shop for all your hearing problems

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by IsaiRasigan

If IR wanted to lure just only the happenin' youths, then he would have visited his 80's techono beats & funk and interwoven it into Thiruvasagam. :)

---

Technovasagam :D

ananth222 , maybe what u said is true ...but very difficult to imagine something against our brought up....

anyway guys ...

yesterday here in singapore i saw the movie 'a aah' .....i was very surprised .....at titles when they showed ar rehmans name there were whistles and claps....

i heard in past IR used to get lot like that .. is he still gettin that honour ?? anybody saw Oru naal oru kanavu in theatre ?? Did ppl clap for his name ??

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by krihoo

ananth222 , maybe what u said is true ...but very difficult to imagine something against our brought up....

anyway guys ...

yesterday here in singapore i saw the movie 'a aah' .....i was very surprised .....at titles when they showed ar rehmans name there were whistles and claps....

i heard in past IR used to get lot like that .. is he still gettin that honour ?? anybody saw Oru naal oru kanavu in theatre ?? Did ppl clap for his name ??

---

Ya, there were whistles and claps, read the suresh review on ONOK.
http://ursmusically.blogspot.com/200...ie-review.html

IR, ARR, YSR have much fans now a days, thus they are getting whitles, claps while screening their names at theatre. I've often watched that.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by njv

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Vysar

As a IR fan, I feel TIS is an average work. i am one of those fans who expected IR would rise from ashes with TIS. But in vain it goes as usual.

---

ENT - one stop shop for all your hearing problems

---

:rotfl:

well said njv.

I bought the CD so I have all the right to critic the music. Since ur comments are immature I would probably recommend u to visit a psychiatrist to cure ur fanatism.

vysar,

u too,maybe like many (including the players of TIS themselves) mistook thiruvasakam as something like symphony ....which is why u r dissappointed......i think if u really understand its identity maybe u will like it...this is all fault of marketing....many ppl are misleaded....even i was expecting something like symphony....
but actually these are devotinal songs with symphony oratario

maybe it takes time for u to like...i too took about one year to really understand How to name it....These musics by IR are not normal to enjoy easily, we really need to UNDERSTAND what these are ...

and also maybe if sung by a regular singer some ppl wud have like it.....

donno what exactly u dint like ...can u explain u r complaint more clearly so that we can understand why some ppl dint like....what u dint like , what u expected