ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

TB

---

What is TB

Now going by sales, the ranking of MDs are

ARR
YSR - with ARR not doing many films, he is really #1, but whenever ARR movie get released, he is pushed to #2
IR - was below VS, but jumped after TIS
VS - He lost his market since 2004. He was #1 in 2003
HJ -Anniyan toped the chart but its because of Shankar, not HJ

In terms of CDs, the following has the highest demand

1. Arindhum Ariyamalum
2. Orun Naal Oru Kanavu
3. Anniyan - still holding hits place

Aah Aah is no in the top chart now.

njv, although I sometimes wish that HJ loses his market, havent you mentioned in the next thread that Gajini is no. 2 in sales just behind Anniyan? So how does that explain you placing HJ fifth in the list? I think VS has to be even below HJ.

Judge, Dude, I gave u the list for movies which ran 100 days. Whether it ran in Chennai, Madurai or in kuk gramam is not the question, it ran because of sole artist called ARR. Now you say Kunjumon gave money to the theatre owners. He has no reason for that because the movie was a super hit due to songs. And name one movie from my list which did not have super hit music and which did not run 100 days.

And as far as sales is concermed ONOK is super flop. The movie is thrown out of theatres. Same thing goes to OKK. The movie is out of the theatres. By giving one good song from IR does not mean, that movie will be hit or songs will be hit. The movie is crap and so other songs from ONOK. Poor IR. Need to concentrate on his kasi yatrai since he has finished all his duties.

Slsperson, leave judge, he has a bad attitude against ARR and every other albums other than one composed by ARR is super hit for him. Poor guy was trying to promote flop albums like OKK in this forum without luck. He has brought all the copies to pump up the sales :lol:

In cinesouth Aa Aaha is No. 1 on the list.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by vijayr

njv, although I sometimes wish that HJ loses his market, havent you mentioned in the next thread that Gajini is no. 2 in sales just behind Anniyan? So how does that explain you placing HJ fifth in the list? I think VS has to be even below HJ.

---

Everyweek it changes. Gajni is now slow because the movie is postponed. Arindhum Ariyamalum still has very good response and so does ONOK.

Now anniyan is still on top from sales, but that doesnt make HJ #1. Its more of Shankar than HJ. HJ did good in 2004 though.

2003 - VS
2004 HJ
2005 YSR

If YSR is really this years number 1 and can sell as many cds just by his name on the label then why don't Rajni or Kamal hire him for their projects Sivaji and 10avatharam? Or current top stars like Vijay or Vikram? at least Tharuthalai?

Jacky, Everyone knows the stuff of YSR. All he can do is reassemble his dad's work with little ARR mix and give the product. He has long way before he can reach that status. But no one wants to accept the fact. YSR will never be No 1. I think as far as MDs are concerned, it is ARR No. 1 and there is fight for No. 2 position between IR, HJ,VS and YSR.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jacky

If YSR is really this years number 1 and can sell as many cds just by his name on the label then why don't Rajni or Kamal hire him for their projects Sivaji and 10avatharam? Or current top stars like Vijay or Vikram? at least Tharuthalai?

---

Definitely the count is increasing for YSR and decreasing for ARR. No doubt it that. YSR is still raising and can not be compared with ARR or VS. He can be compared agains Dhina and his set of MDs.

To me IR and ARR are composers

VS and Deva are senior MD

Rest of them are junior MDs

what i told before was just sales figures and nothing else.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jacky

If YSR is really this years number 1 and can sell as many cds just by his name on the label then why don't Rajni or Kamal hire him for their projects Sivaji and 10avatharam? Or current top stars like Vijay or Vikram? at least Tharuthalai?

---

I wish YSR stays out of Rajini/kamal/Vijaykanth and all those soon to be retiring directors. Definitely the chemistry will not work, he tried a few masala movies before with Vijaykanth/Vijay/KSR. None worked out, and VS is there to fill the gap for masala movies. Instead he should work with young unknown upcoming directors.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrJudge

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jacky

If YSR is really this years number 1 and can sell as many cds just by his name on the label then why don't Rajni or Kamal hire him for their projects Sivaji and 10avatharam? Or current top stars like Vijay or Vikram? at least Tharuthalai?

---

I wish YSR stays out of Rajini/kamal/Vijaykanth and all those soon to be retiring directors. Definitely the chemistry will not work, he tried a few masala movies before with Vijaykanth/Vijay/KSR. None worked out, and VS is there to fill the gap for masala movies. Instead he should work with young unknown upcoming directors.

---

ysr is considered to be best in youthful movies.....in movies with mass heroes he had done well in few movies like dheena,nandha.
he had a lot of time...he can experiment a lot...he is sure to hit the number one postion by 5 years....now he is only behind arr ...but as for as tamil nadu is considerd he is ahead of arr as arr doesnt give many films in tamil...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by nilavupriyan

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MrJudge

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jacky

If YSR is really this years number 1 and can sell as many cds just by his name on the label then why don't Rajni or Kamal hire him for their projects Sivaji and 10avatharam? Or current top stars like Vijay or Vikram? at least Tharuthalai?

---

I wish YSR stays out of Rajini/kamal/Vijaykanth and all those soon to be retiring directors. Definitely the chemistry will not work, he tried a few masala movies before with Vijaykanth/Vijay/KSR. None worked out, and VS is there to fill the gap for masala movies. Instead he should work with young unknown upcoming directors.

---

ysr is considered to be best in youthful movies.....in movies with mass heroes he had done well in few movies like dheena,nandha.
he had a lot of time...he can experiment a lot...he is sure to hit the number one postion by 5 years....now he is only behind arr ...but as for as tamil nadu is considerd he is ahead of arr as arr doesnt give many films in tamil...

---

But when considering Dheena starring mass hero Ajith, it clicked very well. Dheena is one of most successful musical hit for Ajith. Dheena songs was super hit. After that, last 5 films of Ajith were not super hits. Ajith & YSR combination will click.