dinesh2002
thank you for posting jokes here. I really enjoyed with the songs and your post.
Please understand this is forum .not for making jokes. And don't make fun on padmashre ARR songs.
Printable View
dinesh2002
thank you for posting jokes here. I really enjoyed with the songs and your post.
Please understand this is forum .not for making jokes. And don't make fun on padmashre ARR songs.
u sure the 'thunder' didint affect u man??? :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by Thunderbird
nice try arr fan.. expected frm u :)
bye
hey i almost forgot the 3rd name in the topic......Harris Jeyaraj........y dunt ppl. compare him with YSR??? actually they can be better compared as they are from same generation....
guys...listen to the audio of Katril & Deepavail of the videos which released online...they r quite diff from the cd's version!!
bad > average :rotfl:
FYI
Kismat se Pukar song is inspired from the IR's oldies "Karaiyai kadakkum thamaraiye".
Still no one answered for my post.Let me remind again
Listern to YSR Dheena's oru nenjam illa naalil and ARR's smiyai from Kandu kondein.Kunnooru poochatti from YSR's velai and Dolna from Parasuram.These are 6 year old songs.YSR was an inspiration for ARR long time ago.
xml,
you will not get a reply from any of those targets. They are totally devoted to only attempt to make allegations after allegations that every other composers' songs are inspired or copied or lifted from some ARR song, no matter how ridiculous the link is they will have to still say something by default: I think it is built in every ARR fans agenda as they can't face the fact that ARR is facing a slow death in TMF with a string of sappa albums and such continous hits from people like YSR and Harris.
And yes, since Harris is so easily making hits by just lifting ARR's songs, someone please advise ARR to do the same and perhaps at least then he may come with better albums himself.
xml, ezy, i dunno from which planet u guyz are from, but ARR fans are not replying, bcoz some ppl just dont deserve even that little bit damn!!! may be i will stop posting also. I try to stop myself from ridiculing other ppls intellect, but for some ppl it is so obvious. Its like it is written on their forehead - "Cr*p, dont give a damn"
http://sify.com/movies/tamil/fullstory.php?id=14192507
says HJ & YSR neck-to-neck for top spot in audio sales...
interesting....... :DQuote:
Remember that Yuvan has not been able to match Harris’ Ghajini audio sales
if it is true (i don't think so), yuvan will be the real Ghajini :thumbsup:. I mean he will get the cup finally (after so many tries)Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
Xml
I am not quite sure about this, but in my opinion, what Deva did to IR is just getting repeated for ARR by Harris. HJ might be a really good composer and lot of people might like it, except the first album (and KK) and some songs here and there (ex anniyan), i dont believe HJ is that good (this is my opinion). YSR seems to be a little class apart from HJ having some good catchy tunes and listenable melodies. But both HJ and YSR have a long way to go, for now i might think, YSR is taking the lead.
ARR is a class apart no matter whatever people might say. whether he loses ground or not is something I care, his style was unique, he created a genre and he stuck to it for people to follow, duplicate and inspire. This is what IR did with his amazing melodies complex but yet simple interludes, the purity and nativity of music transitions, not to forget the great background scores.
i surely like the Arinthum Ariyamalum, Pattiyal, Kanda naal mudhal songs. I surely liked a couple of songs from Kadhal, i guess the MD was Joshua...
hey MIL, welcome back......how are u??? long time no see.... :D .....
MIL, i guess YSR fans think ARR is gone for sure......cant help much either unless Godfather and JOK come up with trumps......
According to me Ah..Aah was a great album.. A R R has tried a lot of new things in that album
Imagine the duet thazuvudu duet with SPB and Sadna..it was out of the world ..
And the hariharan chithra duet of varugirai was excellent. I think the film bombed and hence audio did not receive the proper recognition. Personally i feel its one of the best albums of A R R..
MADDY,
yes it has been a while I visited the forum, and that I did not listen to any recent songs or watch tamil movies (almost 3 years) it gives me no right to opine anything. Now that I have been catching so to say the past 3 years of movies/music, I felt that my opinion could be stated.
Thanks anyways, by the way, i liked some of the background scores in Ah Aah, the movie was a drag, but ARR had done his part.
Digression
It might be old news, but Azhagi had really amazing songs and BG by IR
End
YSR is doing his job very well, do you agree, I guess he has come up with more catchy numbers and melodies than HJ did in recent times.
Maddy, ARR Fans (not you atleast) did the same thing with IR, posted some worse stuff here, so I think we should ignore them and just take opinions that make sense.
When they say ARR is gone: I dont understand, Tell me if I am wrong, he has the following right
GodFather, JOK, Sivaji, Dasavatharam, Guru and whatelse?
GF, JOK, Shivaji for sure.Quote:
Originally Posted by MusicIsLife
10A - not sure now, since there are rumours abt 5 MDs (hope its false)
Guru - ignore this totally. MR is going to spoil his career and also ARR with this.
why everyone is pessimistic abt Guru, I remember jaiganes also saying something similar :(
The previous Mani-ARR combo suffered a lot from the hype surrounded to it, generated by the media and later the music by ARR. So this time ARR's wellwishers are trying to remove that hype by creating a pessimistic feeling :)Quote:
why everyone is pessimistic abt Guru, I remember jaiganes also saying something similar
MR copied so much from hollywood and now every one of his movie is getting criticized.Quote:
Originally Posted by thamizhvaanan
Media doesnt like MR at all. Dont know why. May be he was rude to media. This still continues.
MR is not real. He got lucky with Nayagan and Thalapathi and thats it.
nayagan and thalapthy lucky?? :roll: i liked his other films also :roll:
HYPE has killed lot of Rahman movies.....its gud that Guru,JOK,Godfather will come with very low expectations....shivaji is the only movie hyped zillion times than normal.....
true MR got luck with Nayakan & Thalapathy...but i think he really got his TALENT noticed with his post 1992s movies...though some were inspired by eng novels/serials/movies....it has good screenplay and down to earth perfomance by artists like shalini,madhavan,arvind samy,mohan lal,aishu...etc etc...duncha think so??? and hey...tell me 1 dir who hasnt got INSPIRED in his life???? the latest hyped Ghajini was a MAJOR ripp of from eng movie and u guys go WOOHOOO over him...and complaning bout MR??? weirdosz....
yes Maddy.... i dunno wut they see in this Shivaji...the latest stills look so bad...like as if a cartoon movie with fancy colour cloths by Rajini and a plump Sherya.... even 1 of the scene was explained in rajinifans website and that was nothing but a ripp off of Anniyan's scene [the part how rajini will approache sherya's parents to let them know his love on thier daughter].also ARR-Shankar might not have that scope to bring out the MUSIC coz there is a FACT blocking thier freedom.ive already set my mind that its ARR-Rajini songs & not ARR-Shankars.wut more to look foward??ofcource im looking foward for the movie...just to see whether its a REMAKE of malayalam film or not :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
:lol: :rotfl: :thumbsup: :notworthy: (thirutha mudiyadhu)Quote:
Originally Posted by njv
MR and ex-MD comba-va? kandippa poduvaanga ivarukku avaram, avarukku ivarum :)
mr.njv,unggaluku maniratnam mela appadi enna sir kovam???
ethavathu ass.dir chance kettu poi ninnu,avaru unngala veratti vittutara???hahaha......
:lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by dinesh2002
Why compare him with ARM who is not even a name worth to mention. MR post 92 movies are disasters. Tell me one movie which has everything in it like Nayagan, Dalapathi, Agni Natchatram, Idhayathai Thirudathae and even Pagal Nilavu.
Anand
I just hated his recent movies, since they were absolute copies and how someone who did Nayagan and Dalapathi can go down to this level. Thats it. Even if I want to ask for ass.dir, i wont go to mani. To me his days are over back in 91.
btw instead of hahaha you can post :lol: :lol: :lol:
njv, i guess even u have changed after YSR's entry :D .....i can see a lot of strength in IR camp after YSR started to make a mark.......u guys are attacking ARR camp with renewed vigour.... :lol:
roja was the movie that gave him national recgnition......Bombay was the movie that put mani in elite list of directors in India.......Kannathil Muthamittal made him the "film festival" guy........infact b4 1992 he was just a local director.......after ARR's entry only his movies have a national appeal.....
Just bcoz we r in the topic for MR, i dont what is there to find fault with AE. I loved it. Personal opinions dont matter, but it still was good (tamil version had the vigor, Hindi Yuva did not make any mark with me). May be I understood the tamil dialogues much better with the overtones of locale.
I think ARR gives genuinely his style of Music, and people who are inspired sometimes go to the extend of duplication, that is a cheap trick.
According to the topic, i guess YSR is doing a fantastic job, i just watched Pattiyal, man-o-man this YSR is rocking in it, i did not want to forward the songs, and the background was one notch classy. Hopefully the Pudhupettai movie would be very good (7G also had a great score).
Even I loved it until I realized that its an "exact" copy of a spanish movie. I lost my impression on him after that.Quote:
Originally Posted by MusicIsLife
MR was popular from Nayagan not after Roja. Roja and bombay are national theme and more over had new sound altogether (ARR ofcourse) and the reason why it got attention.
KM is definitely worth mentioning as a good movie, but has to see which movie he copied from.
MADDY,
again you have started your nonsense.
Naayagan was sent for Oscar nominations representing India. Don't just talk crap as if MR only learnt how to direct movies well becuase ARR was there!!!???
we all know IR is a "no-body" in Bollywood......so it is ARR who was the trumpcard for mani's movies in Bollywood.......As much as ARR owes MR , at the same time MR owes ARR his national recognition......there is no denying it....
ezy--> btw Nayagan is the all time fav of mine......
njv, Kannathil Muthamittal pathi solave iliyae..... That is a real class movie, excellent picturisation, semma natural scenes and dialogues (infact MR even used some of the simran-maddy love scenes for Ayitha ezhuthu between Surya and Esha)
and the bgm was simply outstanding, esp in the climax
btw i didnt like AE that much
maddy,
while IR is a king of tamil music, ARR is a King in giving music that breaks language barriers IMHO ...
maddy,
while IR is a king of south indian music, ARR is a King in giving music that breaks language barriers IMHO ...
Athathaan munnaadiyae sollitane ("KM is definitely worth mentioning as a good movie, but has to see which movie he copied from")Quote:
Originally Posted by rsubras
appadi paartha Kamal sir ku evvalavo sollalame ;)
ada en pa namooru aalunga oruthar superah panniruntha athai udane paarata pidikkama ivlo superah panrare, enga irunthu suttirupparo ninaikareenga ;)
oru chinna question njv, if MR wud have really copied AE or KM or any of his previous movies, hwo cud he have screened those on international film festivals and still won acclaim for it?
oru 1 or 2 para copy adichathukke Kavya va avlo insult panranga ithellam summa vittirupanga??
Ayudha ezhuthu is not even a copy, dont believe anyone who says that. The only thing that is similar between AE and Amoros Perros is the concept of a central accident and three stories branching from it. The three stories of the three characters themselves are Mani's own. Both movies deal with entirely different issues. If this is a "copy" then every other Kamal film can be branded as a "copy". MagaLir mattum is almost a scene by scene lift. Avvai ShaNmughi, anbe sivam,Virumandi etc., are all "copies" using the same standards.
Selvaraghavan's kaadhal Konden had characters/storyline lifted from a German film("Klassenfahrt" if I remember right) as the news floated around at that time. Plus the movie itself was reminiscent of the many anti-hero films we had seen earlier in Hindi and Tamil including Baazigar, GuNa etc.. Selvaraghavan gets inspired by a lot of european films/Hollywood flicks he sees at festivals.
I will tell you whose movies are completely original- Perarasu's :-) If that is the only hallmark of a great director, likes of Perarasu, Vikraman, KS Ravikumar, DharaNi etc. would be the greatest directors we have seen.
Bottomline is, every great artiste has his or own inpsirations. The extent of inspiration and the extent of their own imagination/creativity put into their films is to be considered before branding anyone as a copycat director. Many Bollywood directors like Sanjay Gupta (who was recently caught red-handed flicking from a Korean film) are examples of copycat directors. Not someone of Mani Ratnam's stature.
(recently, Pattiyal is more of a lift in Tamil, in the style of Sanjay Gupta's films.Ghajni seems to be an inspiration)
Even Kamal, with his countless inspirations, still adds his own to a movie.