No use ripping them apart....either they have not heard of the term orchestration or they are just plain ignorant :lol2:Quote:
Originally Posted by inetk
Printable View
No use ripping them apart....either they have not heard of the term orchestration or they are just plain ignorant :lol2:Quote:
Originally Posted by inetk
I wanted to write a flithy reply to Sonia, who has done the review in rediff, but finally ended up writing a more diluted version. Who the hell are these guys to comment on such a wonderful master piece. What pisses me off is the fact that these idiots who are completely void of any music knowledge, passing judegements on musical genius like IR. God save the world. Somebody please ban rediff, please
Enna Kodumai Sir Idhu :banghead:Quote:
the last two are melodies without lyrics, and have been curiously named Veg and Non-Veg melodies
Sonthamaga review panna mattangala :lol:
I think the rediff review is correct ..
"Of the other five, two songs have been repeated with minor variations. So you can imagine how repetitive this album sounds."
She has said that songs are nice but as an album ,one may not buy it as the number of songs are less - Fair enough !
'Baaten Hawa' has Amitabh dialogs and this song only will come in the movie. I guess Balki wanted to give the entire song without Amitabh disturbance (but hindiwalas is telling the dialog is interesting part, hmmm i don't know hindi) and hence the same song comes again
Regarding "Cheeni Kum" and "Sooni Sooni" song
Though it has same tune, i would say they are two differenet songs because different music (rthym, ludes, etc), different modulation, different mood
For the first time, I was happy to read the replies for a rediff review in their discussion board.
I guess she wanted Himesh Reshamaiyya to sing two songs instead of Shreya Ghoshal. Never read such an idiotic review. :banghead: :banghead:
Sonia in the rediff review wrote:
"The former is soothing to the ear and has an 'operatic' feel while the latter has got jazz influences with an interesting play of instruments, predominantly the trumpet."
OPERATIC..?????????Im sure you meant symphonic! right?
TRUMPET???????????? Oh You mean Saxophone madam?
This itself speaks volumes about Sonia's musical knowledge. Rediff is such a useless website
The best thing and the positive thing about that review are the feedbacks for the same :)
Good to see those feedbacks
Yet another positive review
http://indiafm.com/movies/musicreview/12845/index.html