That was not IR's wish, Bharthi raja arranged for that function. Neverthless i am not searching for an excuse of IR's absent here.But i wish/expect him to participate and should talk bit more than usual.Quote:
Originally Posted by raja_fan
Printable View
That was not IR's wish, Bharthi raja arranged for that function. Neverthless i am not searching for an excuse of IR's absent here.But i wish/expect him to participate and should talk bit more than usual.Quote:
Originally Posted by raja_fan
Exactly !! If he participates he will echo these words or along the same line.Quote:
Originally Posted by Plum
Do you think Raaja likes his scores or his way of music making? ithu eppadi irukuunnA ethO oorukkAga seira mAthiri irukku. Why would we expect a classically inclined music composer should come on stage and appreciate Britney spears? I don't understand. intha kooththu ellAm namma nAttula thAn nadakkum. I don't have problems if Yuvan/HJ attends, but Raaja... I will never accept.Quote:
Originally Posted by irir123
Raaja should not have accepted BR's request to have all those MDs for his thiruvAsagam release function also. It should've been released just like any other album, why he approved BR's request and had all those people? I didn't understand and I was mad at that time also.
Judge,
Seriously, yen ungalukku Rahman melayum avar isai meedhum ithana kovam? I'm really curious to know...
The globe is becoming one big village now. Talents here will work with other parts of the world will be a norm in a few years down the line. It is not a big deal. Nobody needs to learn from anybody. It is bound to happen soon.Quote:
Originally Posted by thumburu
ethO Madras-ngra vArththaikku Mozart-nnu porunthippOga kadaisila ellOrum solla ArambichchAchu. Webberkku thAn paNam paNNa vEndiya kattAyam, ethO sonnAr....nAmalumA?..
MrJudge,Quote:
Originally Posted by MrJudge
firstly, i dont understand tamil, so i might miss some point which you wrote in tamil.
coming to other point,i agree that IR is classically inclined. But that alone is not IR's forte right. same applies to even ARR. The degrees of 'classicalism' and 'peppy-ism' vary fr both, but ultimately, they both are in same field and did many common things. I am not saying each did exactly what the other did, but if we draw a venn diagram, we will see an overlap of their circles (irrespective of quality etc). if i understood it right, you drew an analogy of classical inclined vs pop inclined. but IR too did works which are pop inclined and ARR too did works which are classical inclined (plz dont compare the degrees or levels, thats not my point). and as long as they (or any composer) are in same field/business - film music, they can compliment each other, instead of blaming each other right.
when Far more pure classically inclined composers such as Pt.Ravi Shankar, Ustad Amjad Ali Khan, Ustad Bismillah Khan etc could appreciate ARR, then we neednt completely rule out the possibility of IR appreciating ARR. I am not saying that IR SHOULD do it. I am only saying that he CAN, if at all he has such a heart. When MSV could appreciate IR back then, why cant IR do that? please think about this without looking at qualitative terms such as musical-richness, since that is relative.. i am talking merely on the lines of who is at the side of winning laurels. When IR was winning them, MSV clapped. Now if ARR is winning, reasons whatsoever, IR can also clap.and personally, i think it is fair enough if he does it, because even he is in same business and it is not as though IR did not compose 'Britney Spears' or 'Pop Corn' kind of music.
also how do we draw a line for classical-inclined?
IR is classically inclined, but not ONLY classically inclined. when his own sons give the kind music that you think IR doesnt like in ARR's style and when he can endorse that, why not this. i often wondered about this.
(opinions expressed abt IR's sons' music are purely personal, because i never liked their music that much, barring few exceptions.)
Raaagas, you cant club YSR and KR together as IR's sons doign same type of music - they are a world apart in their musical philosophies. Yuvan belongs to the Rahman school - Karthik's headmaster is IR :-)
Firstly i dont want to spoil the party, but still as you are pulling IR's leg again and again, i have to do this.Quote:
when Far more pure classically inclined composers such as Pt.Ravi Shankar, Ustad Amjad Ali Khan, Ustad Bismillah Khan etc could appreciate ARR, then we neednt completely rule out the possibility of IR appreciating ARR. I am not saying that IR SHOULD do it. I am only saying that he CAN, if at all he has such a heart. When MSV could appreciate IR back then, why cant IR do that?
First thing first, from the beginning of his career IR has been appreciating and acknowledging MSV's role in tfm history and also MSV's influence in his life, MSV has been reciprocating it. And IR went to some extend to request MSV to work along with him in an AVM production movie, after came to know that MSV was not doing good financially.
Where as ARR never revealed that he worked for IR couple of years until recently, on top of it he said that he never listened to any of IR's work. On the other hand IR never opened his mouth about ARR. But the things changed post 2000 as ARR started to appereciate IR and now IR is reciprocating it.
So, please dont assume things if you dont have history on ur side.
And also dont forget that we are talking about a man who refused to score music for legendary Director Sridhar just 'coz Sridhar ditched MSV and came to him. When this happened (1978), he was not even a well established MD.
Then Sridhar had to go back to MSV and aked him to request IR to score music for his film.
nanchil_guy ,
what arr said was that he stopped listening to illayraaja's music , to avoid his influence !