Printable View
yeah, may be for us ARR fans its hard to digest initally, but other ppl dont have a clue as to what this album has in store...I mean they dont know if the song is re-used or not cos the songs aren't popular ones... come on Dinesh, how often we fans used to be disappointed when brilliant compositions like these ones get unnoticed... so here's an opportunity for them to be heard among the mass....so keep cool and look forward to the album...
i just have no comments man... nothing right now seems right to me... just need to put this aside.... it totally spoilt my mood of the day, which initially was going on fantastically.... :(... as u said, im the in 1st stage of unable to digest this news... was having roaring expectations like another Boys... and this reused matter just brought me back to this horrible experience in 2001....
hope ARR has done some changes in the song, and not just reuse the song as it is... coz ive never heard ARR doing changes to his reused Hindi songs in Tamil ... its alwis the exact copy back... except maybe Oone Oone - Alli Arjuna having some minor changes here and there.....
i see ARR has arranged people to guide Madhushree and Reena on their numbers... hoping to see perfect pronunciations from them....
hey bro....chill man...
Doli Saja Ke Rkahna was not marketed well..hence we had Jodi...
Meenaxi songs were marvelous...but didn't reach out widely due to MF Hussain's ego to pull out the entire movie when there were protest against Noo-un-Allah song alone....
Hence ARR is re-marketing these 2 songs. I always felt, Chinnama Chilakka will be better lapped by south indians due to its andra flavour....
Yeh rishta...is a stunning melody..... i don't mind tamil lyrics to it.....
if Manburu Mangaye can sound good in tamil....i'm sure Yeh Rishta will too...
Cheers....
Whats happening? 2 years arr can give time to only 4 songs. But this time i hav only 1 satisfaction, the 2 reused tracks are excellent songs. Ana everu kitta irukura oru ketta palakam ethuthan...
It is actually not like that. Few minutes back i saw his interview on NDTV Good Times channel and in that they asked him this particular question as to why he reuses his tracks from other language. Rahman clearly specified that it is purely director's choice and he never likes doing it. He told that he even tries to convince the directors sometimes.Quote:
Originally Posted by prasana84
So, based on his interview, we can assume that the director Kalaprabhu and Kalaipuli Dhanu must have forced him to do this.
i think when the movie started and arr was committed they fixed that there will be 4 songs. But later on they wanted 2 more songs for which they chose those of meenaxi.
Dinesh, who knows maybe the director wanted the 2 songs badly...If not, why suddenly arr reused meenaxi of all albums which was released a few years ago??...Doesnt make sense...Probably its just like how Ashutosh insisted on having the baba song in swadesQuote:
Originally Posted by dinesh2002
If i were the director i would have asked ARR to reuse 2 songs from ada, 2 from JTYJN, 1 from earth and 2 from water :D There you go a perfect rocking album...
:cry: Entha directors en epadi panranga... they should have the attitude of getting a better one than the existing one which they want.Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramakrishna
Nalla velu nenga directora agala :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
They made some changes (baba song) in swades hope the same would happen for sk. making some refinement would be betterQuote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
athane.... enna director'ro..... :roll: we should praise dir krishna in this matter [sok] for getting awesome songs from ARR... atleast he didnt ask ARR to reuse his songs.... :roll:Quote:
Originally Posted by prasana84
Mahen, this shows the director is just weak in extracting tunes from ARR......
ade paavi Mahen, u want another Alli Arjuna and Star?????? if u didnt realize, the songs in Alli Arjuna and Star were excellent songs by itself in Hindi. Look what happen when u compile it to a Tamil album....
NOT A GOOD IDEA!!!!
What started with a Telegu original song being reused in an original Hindi movie back in 1995 as continued to occur and will happen again in the future. If ARR could come up with new songs for ATM (except for the remix which was wanted by the director/producer), why not for this movie? Probably due to the director/producer. I agree that it's up to the director/producer to get what they want from ARR. For example, when the Baba song was reused in Swades, ARR did not have to use that song, Swades had excellent new tunes and yet he had to bring in an old tune but why?
I want to think that it's due to the director/producer but ARR at this point in his career should be able to dictate the terms and the conditions. Nowadays, I believe Hindi ARR is better than Tamil ARR even though it was Tamil ARR that started his fame and fortune in the eyes of the film industry - so I think ARR should start to give something back to the Tamil Film Industry maybe by producing a film with all new tunes from him.
There is an interesting development about Sakkarakatti. Gops, in his latest message, reveals something.
I am sure it will warm the hearts of the 'Tamil fans" here to know that ARR was pencilled into this project without his knowledge or consent and then emotionally blackmailed into doing it. He had the choice of kicking up a fuss, saying No and walking away. He did not. Instead, he chose the path of dignity.
Hmmm. What does this mean?
I think the director was adamant in getting ARR for this. So he might have used his father's influence rather than the director impressing ARR with his story telling.
If this news is true, this shows how much they are dependent on ARR for the outcome of the film...lets hope the director has done his part to compliment the good work of ARR ( as a music director as well as a human being)...Quote:
Originally Posted by Guess_Me
Yeah there's a huge difference between a new movie with ARR's name and a new movie without ARR's name but I don't find any reason as to why ARR wouldn't accept the project if the project hadn't excited him..... may be he refused to do it cos of the dates and later on the producer would've pressurized him to go for it... Just to think of it even if any of us were to direct a film in the future, we would surely want to have ARR in it somehow, so I reckon this guy is one of the many fans of ARR and was so adamant to have ARR in his film...Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramakrishna
if anyone had a good memory. they would remember that when the movie was first announced that they said there was going to be 4 songs. Thus 4 new songs and 2 old songs because later the director or producer asked for 2 more songs. So old ones were given or they requested the old ones.
yeah man i remember but 4 songsoda vituduntha oru complete album ayirukum but anyway let see...Quote:
Originally Posted by slperson1
Hope is doesn't go E20U18 way...
when then film bombed...the director blamed ARR for delaying it and spoiling the market of the movie...
Yennamo periya Nayagan padam yeduthuthe mathiri pesinaru...
If this is true, I hope ARR does not work for Kalaipuli S. Thanu again. I hope it is not true though.Quote:
Originally Posted by Guess_Me
2 hindi song re-used pannarathu enna periya kuttama??ithukku yen eppadi kovappadrannga innu onnum puriyala :banghead: athan 4 original songs irukke sir! :cool2:
actually its a bit disappointing to hear that two of the songs are not fresh....
but still.... after the album releases, we ll start lovin it... its just the people here are pourin their disappointment as they were expectin a complete album as fresh as boys or kadhalan....
yes.... couldnt have said it better bro. Well, lets just see how this tracks sounds in Tamil.....Quote:
Originally Posted by SoftSword
important Sridhars sir's name is missing!!
Hey who konws maybe it will turnout something like Jodi did, it was a big hit compared to its hindi counterpart :wink:
yea...rayan....i'm with you on this...
who can forget lyrics such as "kaadhal kaditham theetatve, maegam yellam kaagitham. Vaanil neelam konduva, pena maiyo theerntidum"...
right on brother, the flute & the voices is like magicQuote:
Originally Posted by united07
"Velli malare" was even more apt in Tamizh, the lyrics gelled well with the music and was top notch....Quote:
Originally Posted by rayan36
I dunno 'bout the hindi lyrics, but VM had done a superb job for the translation, & yeah the tamil lyrics match wellQuote:
Originally Posted by ansa400
I have not listened to Meenaxi Songs a lot except Do Kadam. So Sakkarakatti is still a fresh album for me :P
sakkarakatti track listing
Taxi Taxi
Benny Dayal, Blaaze, Viviane, Chaix, Javed Ali
Marudaani
Madhushree, A R Rahman, Hentry
I Miss You Da
Chinmayi, Indai Haza
Chinnamma
Benny Dayal, Chinmayi
Elay
Krish, Naresh Iyer
Naan Epoudhu
Reena Bharadwaj
if this chinnamma track is the same tune as of Meenaxi's track chinnamma very happy :)
i love that meenaxi song.... a different compostition... :)
can anyone confirm this
yaa it is that meenaxi track for sure.Quote:
Originally Posted by viraajan
good then :thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramakrishna
HI friends,
It gives me great pleasure to announce the SonyBmg -Score magazine Chakarakatti contest .Just log on to www.highonscore.com and participate in the contest . You could win invitations for the audio launch to be held on July 11th.
so the stage is set atlast for the launch of Sakkarakatti..........
July 11th....... come sooner :D
5 more days...... [including today] ...........
there is a question - who was choroegrapher of Smitha album - yaarakkuavadhu theriyuma???? :roll: ......i desperately want to attend a music launch featuring GOD in it :)Quote:
Originally Posted by arsaregama