http://tamil.oneindia.in/movies/spec...or-156963.htmlQuote:
Originally Posted by VTV
கமல் என்ற 'ஆச்சர்ய'த்திடம் வாழ்த்துப் பெற்ற புது இயக்குநர்!
http://tamil.oneindia.in/movies/spec...or-156963.htmlQuote:
Originally Posted by VTV
கமல் என்ற 'ஆச்சர்ய'த்திடம் வாழ்த்துப் பெற்ற புது இயக்குநர்!
ennadhu maNikkutty-yA :rotfl2:
Tenali tune-la aNNan "dhA pOi mAththi konduvA"-nu sonnAraamE :lol2:
Regarding Indian, Tunes kekkanum nu MD kitta kettrukkaaru, thassaal. But MD "naan director kitta thaan report panren" nu sollirukkaaru. Weekly Report ellaam anuppuvaar pola :lol:
Thenaali, AFAIK, totally Ravikumar thaan handle pannaarnnu keLvippatten, nothing more. Specifically, didn't hear any 'clash' news
Jayaram konjam koovinaaru. And the way he said that was funny.
"pO idhai mAththi koNdu vaa" :lol:
Well guess what remains between the two is just mutual respect and admiration towards each other...Quite a bummer that the two haven't worked together that often...Thenali and Indian were nowhere near the best for both of them....Quote:
Originally Posted by sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar
something tells me Kamal will never go to ARR - def not for his home production / banner! adhuvum ippa Hollywood range ponadhukkappuram, avingale super composers recommend panna vaaippirukku - Desplat is just one such example - there are 'n' no of upcoming composers in hollywood who might get roped in - unless his hollywood producer / financier insists i dont think Kamal will opt for ARR - however, if he does opt for him, ARR would most definitely ododi vandhu work pannuvaar - with or without Hollywood! 'Viswa' i thought was one helluva subject matter, which ARR wud have easily composed for esp with its afghan/middle-eastern theme - dont know why SEL were opted for instead!
Guess there is still a window of opportunity for Kamal to return back to Marudhanayagam or Marmayogi after the completion of the Hollywood project. In the case of the latter, the MD was ARR, who had already composed 4 tunes at the beginning...Again these are all just mere speculations....
Raja, Rahman, Rajini, Kamal, all 4 are diamonds who sparkle on their own. Even without combining, they are big powers. If any combo happens, pattaasu thaan!
Sakala,
AFAIK, the difference of opinion regarding 'Indian' song was because the choice of singer for 'Pachaikkiligal'. Shankar and KH wanted KH to sing that number while ARR wanted KJY. That caused the rift was what I was told. There was a discussion in ARRYG reg this long back.
Any big hero has access to the film's songs and why should Kamal go and ask ARR to play the songs?
They both were like Oil & Water, from beggining itself. Before Indian also, Kamal was voicing strongly in support of IR, from the time Gentleman made ARR Popular. (Yes, roja & puthiyamugam only brought fans to ARR, its only Gentleman which brought producers in quee)
It shud be mostly that ARR composing for Indian and Thenaali wud be mostly director's choice, than kamal's. Like Harris composong for VV.
Yeah. True. But of late the situation has changed slightly I believe. Still Kamal is an IR fanatic but no hatred towards ARR like before.
And KH was supposed to be the director of Marmayogi/Thalaivan Irukkiraan, right?
Yes, situation is much better now. But same time, i guess there was nothing hatred against ARR, instead, too much IR support. (which most of us IR fans feel deserving)
Yes. Which is why I am still hopeful that the collaboration will take place...Quote:
Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
With due respect to Singer KamalQuote:
Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
chinna chinna anbil dhaane jeevan innum irukkuu
..penne narai ezhudhum suya saridham
....adhil anbe aanandham aanandham ....
All these lines Only KJY fossible :bow: :bow:
படத்தின் பாடல்கள் வெளிவந்த நேரத்தில் கல்லூரி விடுதியில் இப்படியும் ஒரு கருத்து சென்றது "கமல் படத்தில் கமல் குரலில் ஒரு பாடல் கூட இல்லை.. டூயட் "டெலிபோன் மணி போல" பாடல் கூட ஹரிக்கு சென்றிருக்கிறது. வாவ்.. நிச்சயம் ரஹ்மான் வேறுபட்டவர்தான்"Quote:
Originally Posted by ajaybaskar
Indian is ok.. its shankar choice.. bt Tenali, i think it might be kamal's choice than KSR..Quote:
Originally Posted by sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar
Otherwise KSR would think ARR would be suit for biggies...
KSR joined wit ARR in which Rajini,Kamal & Ajith was star..
He dint even think of ARR musical for Sarathkumar movie.. :lol:
KSR nd Sarathkumar worked together almost above 10 films..
And also, during the release of Tenali, People dint lik the album 'Tenali' in first listen .. They felt sumthing missing in it..
When ARR is composing for a maas-hero project, he is restricted to sum limit for composing, IMO...:(
so he is nt able to delivering gud songs in some time..
Same case happeded for 'Padayappa'.. People dint lik 'Padayappa' album in first listen...
If ARR did the music for Viswaroobam, this film would have been more popular than now. Rahman would have done wonders for these kind of movie.Quote:
Originally Posted by sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar
i dont know when this combination will happen.
+1... Same applied for Dasavatharam..BGM la pinni iruppaaru...:smokesmirk:Quote:
Originally Posted by Srimannarayanan
ARR was the first choice for Dasa. Due to time constraints, ARR had to select between Sivaji and Dasa. He went with the former.
Aishwarya rai heroine-aa irunthaa kooda thaan extra popularity irukkum.. when will we ever stop this nonsense..Quote:
Originally Posted by Srimannarayanan
vishwaroopam theme and the two songs heard minorly thus far was very very good.. if rahman was the MD, every one wud have praised this toooo much .... lets stop being hypocrites..
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anban
Anban
you know what would be the impact if ARR is MD. But still you dont want to accept. SEL doesnt SELL in Tamilnadu. Any way it is my opinion. Let us leave this topic.
KSR is the producer of Tenaali. That was his 1st and last film. So it no wonder KSR wanted ARR for a kamal film which he produces for 1st time.
Later, KSR asked calsheet for a kamal film, for his 2nd home production but it didn't realize. In lieu of which kamal gave KSR directorial offersQuote:
Originally Posted by VTV
Srimannarayanan - i think kamal is banking on the fact that without anyone known in TN, he cud manage a blockbuster DASA using Himesh !! am sure TN ppl know more abt SEL than Himesh! plus it only shows his confidence in his product! he must be thinking "i dont need any big name as a prop for my film" - and no wonder he is sharing Osborne's watching the film 3-4 times with everyone!
bang on!! end of discussionQuote:
Originally Posted by irir123
Athu!Quote:
Originally Posted by irir123
SakalaQuote:
Originally Posted by sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar
Serioulsly i dont understand whether u understand what i am trying to say. When is the last musical hit of thaliavar movie ? VV right. What happened to 10 A Casset sales?
If you say, audio sales cannot be big nowadays, think about Endhiran audio sales. Can we expect the same for Viswaroobam. ? No way.
Main reason for choosing Himesh in 10 A is for bollywood. 10 A was disaster there. Viswaroobam will be a blockbuster in South.No doubt in that. How about Audio sales in south? Will it break any record?
If ARR was part of this movie , we can still have hope on Bollywood market
P.S : I will be happiest person if the movie clicks in BW. He doesnt deserve any failure in BO.
Is it because Kamal no more believes in "songs"? Even then background score is an integral part of the movie.Quote:
Originally Posted by Srimannarayanan
He should have gone for ARR from a commercial point of view (and quality). If Kamal is not interested in the marketing aspects of music (songs and/or background) he should have gone to Ilayaraja.
Something tells me, KH will prefer DSP,SEL and etc than IR in future.Quote:
Originally Posted by irir123
My question is y kamal is nt preferring ARR for his films...
150 cr la padam edukkiringa.. 5 cr sambalam koduthu ARR ai serkka koodatha...
ARR wont avoid if he gets kamal project...
onnum puriyala...
According the Haasar, Viswaroopam's storyline is something universal, and he wants the Background score to be of good quality and having confidence on SEL in that matter. The music we heard in the trailers are fantastic.. If songs are good then it will be a Bonus.. Probably KH is not interested in waiting for anyone's music and having confidence that he can make any MD to work to the level he wants.
5 Cr SambaLam is not the matter here... he wants the MD's to be accessible / available whenever he wants, probably ARR may not be that much flexible..Quote:
Originally Posted by VTV
[QUOTE=Cinemarasigan;893503]According the Haasar, Viswaroopam's storyline is something universal, and he wants the Background score to be of good quality and having confidence on SEL in that matter. The music we heard in the trailers are fantastic.. If songs are good then it will be a Bonus.. Probably KH is not interested in waiting for anyone's music and having confidence that he can make any MD to work to the level he wants.[/QUOTE
Then why not Raaja ????? No waiting etc as they both are great friends...
Nammavar connects the best with maestro...
This makes us think commercial aspects are considered. Then, as someone said, such big budget movies, why not ARR !
CR, I think SEL generally don't do the BGM for many of their indhi films. adhukkellaam 'specialists' vechchirkkaanga anga (even aalavandhan BGM was done by 'nammavar' Mahesh).
[QUOTE=pushpak;893508]Raaja's case is different.. puriyadha pudhir...Quote:
Originally Posted by Cinemarasigan
Yeah.. then who is doing BGM for Viswaroopam?Quote:
Originally Posted by KV
dont do bgm va? they were superb in DCH/KHNH/my name is khan..I guess Alavandan was outsourced because they were still new at that timeQuote:
Originally Posted by KV
Before Indian, there were some strong IR supportive comments from kamal, when ARR was on heavy rise. Then, in Indian and Thenali, few minor clashes were supposed to have happened. That itself kinda created some distance. They both were Appadiyum Ippadiyum.... Then, I guess due to the loooong gap, those minor differences vanished both sides and Kamal went to Dasavatharam(?) for which ARR was unable to give time and he himself suggested himesh(?) and then that nasal phellow refused to do BGM, so that went to DSP. Then UPO went to debut shruti. MMA went to DSP mainly becos of some vaakkuruthi kamal wud have given to DSP for scoring Dasa BGM. (Same way he cud have give vaakku to trisa for Marmayogi and as it dropped, she got MMA)Quote:
Originally Posted by VTV
now coming to Marmayogi, I guess, kamal went to ARR well before itself to make sure ARR won't have any time issues etc but that movie dropped. ARR reportedly composed and recorded(?) 2 songs. Going by the usual kamal logic, ARR shud have got another kamal movie, instead of the dropped Marmayogi but that didn't happen. I guess kamal could not have like ARR's working style (time/other factors). After Marma dropped, later, when ARR got Oscars, Kamal, probably on his own(?) gave interviews to media, praising ARR for his talent. At that time, kamal mentioned a thing, "During Marmayogi, ARR and me discussed the song situation, he understood it fast and kinda stopped me, from me telling more explanation" Kamal said something like this. On the skin of it, it may mean ARR is fast grasping situations but in kamal's mind, may be he always wanted the MD to listen the full, complete explanation he gives with no interruption. Again don't jump on me I am guessing. Also we know, kamal always may want to digress while discussing. He talks about unrelated thing when he meets Raja, during work, as said by him recently. Same with DSP, he discussed about other MD that is Raja. So, it seems there is always out-of-topic discussions along with Song situations. May be ARR didn't encourage this too much.
Kamal-50, ARR came and wished kamal on stage, as he is VVIP, he was alotted a seat on stage, along with other VVIPs but he was there only short time and left without giving speech. nothing wrong, but just saying...
Since kamal attempted ARR for his own directorial Marmayogi, i strongly guess its some working-style related differences that keep them away and nothing more. The reason for the difference to rise at very 1st place - unknown! Only they both knows!
Reg SEL for Vishwroop, I guess, its not only the hope he probably has on them, also that he chose most of the artists from bollywood only. So may be he choose someone he feels fit for the film and him and also the market. This time he seem to have a strong bet in North.
There are many MDs he tries out for first time, Chachi 420, Anbe Sivam, Nala Damayanti all were first timers for kamal film. Rarely he goes to such an MD for 2nd time. So SEL shud have high rank in kamal's choices. I guess, inspite of the frienliness he has with DSP, there mostly wont be a repeat for that guy!
I didn't mean to say that they don't do BGM at all; but often it gets outsourced to other guys. Wiki/IMDB should have details.
Fisherroof I'm not sure yet, but that we haven't heard any other names associated with the music dept. of the film so far, it's likely to be SEL for BGM too.