challenge is challenge.....though they are of different genres, they are releasing on the same date and have effect on each other's BO fate...my bet is on Thala-ARR combo :thumbsup:
Printable View
challenge is challenge.....though they are of different genres, they are releasing on the same date and have effect on each other's BO fate...my bet is on Thala-ARR combo :thumbsup:
YSR , HJ , VS are NO MATCH FOR ARR. If someone compares like this, IMO, he knows ZERO about music
Maddy.. I think they are not gracing the theatres at the same date.Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
Anyway.. I would rather enjoy both the movies rather than comparing them.
coz KH is a legend..
Just like how I put, IT IS UNFAIR TO COMPARE MUSIC FROM ARR (QUALITY) & ONE FROM HJ :roll:
so do with the directors.
May be.. YOu can compare BO Status..
exactly selva, all i need to see is BO success.......there is no point in just looking at quality and moreover qulality is a very subjective thing......wat mite seem gud quality for u mite look bad for me......u know it very well..... :wink:
as far as i'm concerned ARR needs a huge hit and Ajith's dream run will continue if Godfather becomes a hit.....so i wud really like to see GF outshining VV in BO.......
quality comes later, look at KKSei....it was such a beautiful composition going to dust bin...
Yes.. Quality .. Just like beauty.. differes from the eyes of the beholder. someone may like movies like kaadhal, Autograph.. But I have difference of opinion. So, do the Music too. So, comparing the actors, directors, MDs etc based on a single movie won't do justice 8-) best example is ARR vs HJ (still I think that this vs should not be made).. Some movies of HJ might have done well at the BO than ARR's movies. But at the sametime, We cannot deny the fact that ARR is a master in his own way. The same applies to the team of these movies :PQuote:
Originally Posted by Maddy
definitly.. GF will be a blockbuster. That doesn't mean that VV might not be.. BOth of them have all the ingredients of becoming blockbusters.. Let's enjoy the feast rather than putting the mere BO factor which might vary from source to source. But would be happier if AJITH PULLS THIS ONE OUT. (Everyone is 100% confident about this movie).. so do VV :P Let's hope that everything ll be fine with both ARR & Ajith.. so do VV teamQuote:
Originally Posted by Maddy
Quote:
Originally Posted by Maddy
I love to see both these movies. would never try to compare BO performace alone.. It would like comparing ARR Vs HJ movie run (temporaray thing) 8-) :)
Agree.. Even lot of good composition have gone to the dust in the past. Let's imagine a song like "Suttum Vizhi SudaRae" having been picturised in a poor way.. It will affect the movie as well as the song.. Again.. Quality takes a beating here.
Ada paravillay neenga :!: edhonu ninachen . konjam vishayam therinja manidhar dhaan neenga . very good . ivvalavu analyse panreengalay . :lol: :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by selvakumar
Yes, My bet too on Godfather! ARR & team will have a hatrick (GF,JEOK,Shivaji) this time for sure. :thumbsup: :notworthy:Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
ARR the TRUE BOSS
ARR has rocked in RANG DE BASANTHI
GF songs are mind boggling
i was just thinking abt u sundar12345......where were u all these days....welcome back neways....
i guess there is a definite change in fortunes of ARR in 2006.....he has started the year with a bang and has featured in many major ventures.....the tide seems to be in favor of this guy....let's see if our predictions come true... :D
Yesterday I was listening to Daas album from YSR. I recongnized that the song 'Nee En Viliyil' is copied from Dhoom title song. This guy (YSR) is worse than Deva. He copies the music of a famous indian song that is stupid. Incredible...
I just happened to see Ullam Kaetkumae last night (though not fully), but I happened to like the BGM
1. During the introduction scenes
2. And when Arya sees Pooja in the Cricket game.
3. For the matter of fact, i was getting into rythm with the first song, but my scratched DVD did not get me far too much.
YSR must stop copying to be next to IR and ARR
I also listened to all the songs of ULLAM KETKUMAE..
I like all those songs.
But sometimes, I caught up in a vicious circle whenever I hear HJ songs.
For eg, When I was hearing, "ENNAI PANTHAADA PIRATHAVALOO",
I was humming and suddenly I started singing
"POO POOKKUM OOSAI" from MINSAARA KANAVU
Not sure whether it is because of HJ following his GURU ARR's style or he is heavily influenced by that style
Anyway, I enjoyed the songs :)
But HJ should try to prove himself with a new style. People should feel completely different whenever they hear his songs.
Songs IN MINNALE, KK provided that experience. But what followed after that was a mere repetition.
The same applies to YSR too.. He did provide something which is soothing and catchy.
Be it KUTHU OR MELODY he is able to come up with nice ones.
But he should try to reduce remixing old IR songs and should give more songs that will portray his style :)
:thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by nilavupriyan
YSR must stop copying to be next to IR and ARR
Nilavu
Copying in general or from whom?
IMHO if it is substantially modified to have a resounding effect, I would like that, coz not everybody knows each and every genre of music, ex Vanessa Carlton music in 7G interval scene was really cool, though i knew from what i heard that it was from somewhere, but it took sometime, coz of significant modification and feel to the same bit of theme.
stunned to see that kadhal kondaen's "kadhal kadhal" and "kangal rendum" are utter copies!..why did he copy after becoming one of the top music directors..can be get inspired but(like ir or Arr)Quote:
Originally Posted by MusicIsLife
stunned to see that kadhal kondaen's "kadhal kadhal" and "kangal rendum" are utter copies!..why did he copy after becoming one of the top music directors..can be get inspired but(like ir or Arr)
Nilavu
To which songs are these related to? may be this is a annoying probe, but would love to know.
http://www.itwofs.com/tamil-yuvan.htmlQuote:
Originally Posted by MusicIsLife
thank u so much..im searching for it!Quote:
Originally Posted by rashid2raj
:shock: Yuvan :hammer: I never knew that Yuvan copies to this extent.
Ithe maathiri IR, ARR, Harris copy adichirukkaangla
harris copies worse i think.... Anniyan theme from Passion of christ's Resurrection theme....that was real shocking thing!! and direct tooQuote:
Originally Posted by Ramakrishna
hey, but Yuvan is the worst man.After listening to those Kaadhal kondein copies i feel that he is the worst.Harris has copied Anniyan theme.Quote:
Originally Posted by dinesh2002
But i haven't found anything from ARR and IR :thumbsup: :clap:
Rendu perum thaan copy adikuraangannu sollureengalla..Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramakrishna
apuram enna best u worst..
BIT adikurathukku ethavathu prize tharaangala enna :roll:
Any song tune which Harris has copied?
All MDs has copied/inspired including IR.
ARR's copy from Dr. Alban sources is indian famous.
HJ is new copy cat, he copied many songs from ARR and international albums.
sanjeevi..ur heart knows the difference between arr ir and othersQuote:
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Nilavu I used the words copied/inspired. USe the word inspired when you take true MDs
I was a bit surpriced when i found out that IR's "Akkarai Seemai" was a DITTOCOPY.. as IR doesn't copy or even not using any loops in his songs ..
That's only beats.. TUNE is original & those loops are available for all musicians..Quote:
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
ARR vs YSR vs harris
It is clearly evident that ARR is the undisputed winner.
So, it is time to take out ARR and make it YSR vs Harris.
Neengale copy panni dhan post panreenga :lol: idhula MDs pathi comment vera :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Romba isai nyaninu ninaipo ungallukku :twisted:
Adhavadhu ARR copy panrarna ungalukku gushi . parai satruveenga. nalla double standards sami :wink:
Adhavadhu IR peyarai potta neenga oru nadunilamayana aalunu nanga nambanum :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Illa peyara podalanaa mathavanga ungala expose seivangalonu oru kalakkam :wink:
Romba smartana aalu sami neenga :wink:
One quick question
How many people have identified the song immediately just as being copied without research? I think you cant find that with IR/ARR for sure.
Sanjeevi oru medhai :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by MusicIsLife
utta avaru MSV kooda copy adicharnu solvar :lol:
IR copy adicharnu solvadhu miga miga abatham
Copy & inspiration are 2 different concepts altogether
Sanjeevi is just blaberring to avoid a mess here
Enna vambukku ilukk pakkuraQuote:
Originally Posted by Nakeeran
Athenna MSV kooda ????
It seems you are so innocent.
I never told IR/ARR/MSV copied, they inspired. It does not mean they did not copy at all.
For example
ARR : He copied 50% part of "Kathalan kaattu vazhi" song from IR's aranmanai kili song ("Ramara ninaikum anumaru" came in cassette but not in the movie)
Because they are creating music from their minds but many of others believe cassets/cds available in the markset.Quote:
Originally Posted by MusicIsLife
IMO YSR amoung young MDS leads in orginality with high percentage after IR/ARR/MSV.
:lol: nadunilai is your own property . Sorry i did mistake. :rotfl:Quote:
Originally Posted by Nakeeran
Appo enna Baradwaj kooda copy adikurara ? unga theory padi ?Quote:
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi