Khan Saheb Kamal Haasan's Jamaat/Jeba Koottam/Devasthaanam - Part 8

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by app_engine

Accordingly, Kamal values him. While HCKHF's don't care for him, may be because they feel KH should get 100% credit for what they consider as two of his best-ever films and that this SB fellow has "robbed" him of that.

Unfortunately, KH himself doesn't think so and there ends the story.

---

Ithellaam eppdinga sirikkaama post panna mudiyuhtu?!? Great, nga!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar

Naan solrathai kekkura levella app_engine illai! So let me put it this way! After some point, whatever movies SB and Singheetham made without kamal, most of them actually had some influences fromthe kamal ones! Though not strictly limited to the movies where they did combo, but non-combo movies too! Egampul for SB already given. For Singheetham, that Jyothika movie where hero will become miniature!

---

Another proof is in Panneer Pushpangal all the characters wore cotton based dresses. And based on that cotton they formed the discussion between kamal and doctor in Guna where Kamal tries to blow the cotton up and proved that he is different and normal gravity does not work to him. These kind of deep thoughts only SB possible.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar

Ithellaam eppdinga sirikkaama post panna mudiyuhtu?!? Great, nga!

---

Now you are getting personal with app.

Hub ukku regular aa varavendiyavanga athigamaa varrathillai
Thideernu varra silar(and those with agenda(note pannittu thaan irukkom saar :lol2: )

shabbaa!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by sakaLAKALAKAlaa Vallavar

Hub ukku regular aa varavendiyavanga athigamaa varrathillai
Thideernu varra silar(and those with agenda(note pannittu thaan irukkom saar :lol2: )

shabbaa!

---

We can discuss ever on this topic and we will never come to conclusion on who directed those movies. So we should give benefit of doubt to what was shown on the title card. Agree?

TA - frabu
App - Annan
Me - Thambi

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DXFtTTT4c2M

SKV and others - my take on this: Kamal's inputs prior to 1987 were mostly in the form making a director's job totally easy, by giving far more than what they wanted from him as an actor

He evolved gradually until 1987 and rapidly after Nayagan, with his inputs technically, script-wise increasing manifold times thereafter - thats why his films with Singeetham or SB took a different light thereafter - Singeetham made 'Aditya 369' in 1991-92 in telugu - a fantasy film, which was nowhere near any of the films he did with Kamal! Kamal did make a huge difference!

Kamal simply meruketrufied / enhances the natural abilities of Singeetham or SB, post 1987 - the same goes for Suresh Krishna (Sathya, Indran Chandran, Abhay - all of which had kamal penning either the screenplay, or, giving inputs in other departments such as music etc) - there was one more guy GB Vijay who directed 'Kalaignan' - obvious it was kamal's film all the way with GBV doing maybe some 'edubidi' work!

i think in case of SB, or, SK, or, Singeetham, or Bharathan - Kamal's scripting plus Kamal either directing them to direct - "listen, this is how i want it to be; how can we add to the aesthetic of the final product ? i leave it to you to handle that - just make sure that it meets my vision" - and persuading them to get what he wanted

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by irir123

SKV and others - my take on this: Kamal's inputs prior to 1987 were mostly in the form making a director's job totally easy, by giving far more than what they wanted from him as an actor

He evolved gradually until 1987 and rapidly after Nayagan, with his inputs technically, script-wise increasing manifold times thereafter - thats why his films with Singeetham or SB took a different light thereafter - Singeetham made 'Aditya 369' in 1991-92 in telugu - a fantasy film, which was nowhere near any of the films he did with Kamal! Kamal did make a huge difference!

Kamal simply meruketrufied / enhances the natural abilities of Singeetham or SB, post 1987 - the same goes for Suresh Krishna (Sathya, Indran Chandran, Abhay - all of which had kamal penning either the screenplay, or, giving inputs in other departments such as music etc) - there was one more guy GB Vijay who directed 'Kalaignan' - obvious it was kamal's film all the way with GBV doing maybe some 'edubidi' work!

i think in case of SB, or, SK, or, Singeetham, or Bharathan - Kamal's scripting plus Kamal either directing them to direct - "listen, this is how i want it to be; how can we add to the aesthetic of the final product ? i leave it to you to handle that - just make sure that it meets my vision" - and persuading them to get what he wanted

---

GB Vijay's first movie "NaaLaiya Seithi" was better than Kalaignan.. I think Kamal had given free hand to GB Vijay..

Kalaignan doesn't feel like a Kamal movie at all.Even his acting is quite shoddy.
Vijay's movie naaLaiya seidhi is quite underrated.

A song Raja composed for Marudhanayagam! Audio quality is sumaar

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=avvPijSTehs