Printable View
Nakeeran, the dynamics of kodambakkam are too complex for u and me , as outsiders to even comprehend. So let us leave filmi folk's personal equations aside and judge them only based on their output and nothing else.
svasin,for your info Suhasini remarked whatever RS mentioned during the "IR show" telecast.
Thumburu, I have been following the divine music of IR and its a big loss to music lovers if MR-IR , KB-IR, BR-IR doesnt materialise as these are the type of guys who get the best out of IR.Quote:
Originally Posted by thumburu
when the other side is willing to shed his ego and looking forward to IR combo again, why not IR move one inch forward .
MARAPOM MANIPOM ENBADHU IRAIVUDAMAI.
Idhai oru Ramanamaharishi Bakthar IR ukku naam sollithara venduma ?
during Pongal 2006 there was a show titled 'Isaignyaniyudan' and it contained interviews from various personalities who worked with Raja. SPB and Suhasini were one among them. Suhasini elaborated on her experiences with IR and also how IR made her sing in a TeleSerial directed by her.... I think the serial was titled 'PEN' which was telecasted in DD. More she added on how much she liked the combo of MR-IR and she wants them to work again together. And she added the sentence i mentioned in the earlier post.
And this programme was not an exclusive to my home alone and it was telecasted to the whole of TN :P
Nakeeran,
I've been following news regarding IR from 1997 and for the other information regarding the 80's and early 90's I unearth from my own memories. I know i had been an ardent reader of many magazines and watching TV's and I say watever I know is true.
Regarding the MR-IR split i know the main culprit was GV. There was a programme in early 90's in which the then CM JJ was to participate. IR was also an invitee and when he was entering the hall his car was stopped and he was asked to walk down till the entrance as the CM was arriving any minute. He exclaimed 'Naan Yaarkaagavum Erangi nadanthu poga mudiyaathu' and asked his driver to drive till the entrance of the hall. During the function GV said ' sila perukku vetri kedaicha thaan entha thesathukko raajannu nenappu vanthuduthu' in order to please JJ. this hurt IR verymuch and moreover GV persuaded MR to go in for a new MD for his next venture in order to defame IR. they asked Mahesh[ 'Sottu neelam doi' and 'Nammavar' fame] to compose for Roja He rejected in lieu of his cancer condition. Then ARR was introduced to MR in another function and they coaxed him to compose for Roja... for which ARR was reluctant at first. Rest is history.
Moreover we all know how much JJ wanted to crush IR and his family during her tenure and supported ARR by making him to compose for SAF games and her own Adopted son's marriage reception. IR was literally made to a pauper by JJ's atrocious regime. Gangai Amaran's Paiyanoor bunglow was seized at low rated involving Rowdies and State police. IR's home was raided by IT dept. and he was made to suffer a Lot.
I think all these could have made IR to decide not to work with MR anymore.
My personal opinion is IR should forget the past and work with them again as he has made a truce with Jaya TV. And my gut feeling is IR is coming out his shell slowly and have become more free with the press and channels after Thiruvaasagam. He has accepted to work with BR is what i hear. slowly i think he will also accept working with MR. Lets hope for the best :thumbsup:
rajasaranam
thanks. Me too , well aware of this GV - IR incident but is it not just a spark ?
in what way MR is to be blamed ?
are we not the losers in the process ?
MR-IR would have been a dream combination
Wonder whether MR repents for this disassociation now as he is getting everything from ARR .
All the movies of MR-ARR were splendid hits
IR's fans can take steps to happen again the evergreen combos (like IR & MR, IR & BR and IR & BC). I am telling this based on IR's respect and interest on his great fans :D.
I participated the recent two concerts successfully done by IR at Chennai. It was very happy to see IR conversation with his fans during the concerts. He much respect his fans. Definitely he will valuate fans' wishes.
This is my view only.
Thx RS for the detais.
One point i like to add....IR did met JJ in person to donate for the Tsunami victims and probably after that only Jaya TV came in for the "Andrum Indrm Endrum" show...any comments?
Dont tell that to me./... PleaseeeeeeQuote:
Originally Posted by thumburu
I have the Entire show recorded esp the suhashini's speech....
I have nothing against IR... infact i am a great fan of him
but never say that MR went begging
I will also be moreeee happy if IR and MR do a film.......
This was said by SPB too in one ARR concert in an interview b4 the show. The show was "unity of light" and SPB was talking abt MD mahesh. He said, mahesh was one among the two names considered for composing Roja. That time i cudnt beleive it and i was also dissappointed that its not ARRs talents that made MR look beyond IR, but rather there was an initiative :( . but now thinking abt it, it doesnt matter!Quote:
Originally Posted by rajasaranam
I also hope IR and MR wud work again. But thinking abt it, ARR-MR is too precious a combination to be lost even on IR-MR. One director I would absolutely wish IR to work with is Bharathiraja. All of his films with IR had out of the world music. I guess there was a special rapport between them or IR like BR's style of film making very much that it inspired him to compose awesome numbers. Tamil film industry needs BR back bcoz village oriented films have vanished out of the scene. No one to backup BR more than IR and his music. I seriously wish this combination works again :thumbsup:
very gud write-up RS.......but few things are not clear...
1. what MR has to do with this??? i dunt think MR let GV interfere in his creative life.....and that too for a K.Balachander produced movie.....it seems far-fetched......
2. Amma tried to ruin IR's life just for a car parking issue :shock: ??? she let MR go even when his spat with jaya was blown up to a nation-wide issue
3. Why GV was so intent on ruining IR???
4. why did other biggies rite from Bharathiraja to Subash ghai line up to ARR??? dont tell me they were all involved in this....
its hard to believe now cos jayatv promotes so much of YSR,IR,KR and tries to put down ARR whereas dinakaran appreciates ARR and shred IR into pieces with symphony issue....
Ayyo, IR's days are over long long ago. There is no juice at all in his music now a days.
Something is wrong with IR fans if they expect some miracle out of him. the only exception was TIS .
IR should follow the ARR route. just concentrate on a movie and get the best tunes.
IR is no longer the 80s IR to create records.
Just be happy with his old gems . keep on listening to them.