Printable View
Nerd, naan VA paarka kooda illai. Applying "One Pot One Strand of Rice" logic, TV-la paartha edhuvum it is not a trigger to watching it. Naan paartha ore Old Surya scene(andha kadhavai thirandhu young surya drug dance paarkaradhu) was pretty well done.
Sameera Reddy - attempt to present her as fresh, virginal heartthrob doesnt cut much ice when you have seen her cavorting dangerously with jr. NTR. Onyum theralai.
Nerd, CR, Plum
:-)
I didn't get a chance to see HR. BTW, SKV didn't make or break KH (though he did his job without much ado). And, considering solely from a "versatility" point of view, without SKV kind of films, even KH cannot be considered here IMO.
Again from the "versatility" consideration, G plays a major role in getting Surya even consideration. Agreed it's not a performance that matches upto KH-RK levels , but Surya became a saleable star after G in TN in a big way.
Without collections, versatility ellam chumma...it's a strong indicator that people from "all walks of life" enjoyed that performance. Not just some 'self-proclaimed-intelligent-critic' viewpoint.
:confused2:
"ameera Reddy - attempt to present her as fresh, virginal heartthrob doesnt cut much ice when you have seen her cavorting dangerously with jr. NTR"
:rotfl:
But a_e, collections alone does not get you awards right! We are talking about who is the *best actor (OK, versatile)* of them all. As far as collections go it's Vj/Ajith/Surya (in no particular order).
And hub-la post pannra ellArumE self-proclaimed intelligent critic dhaan :)
Yes, Nerd. idhula enna paagupaadu?Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerd
CR,
In my book - actor has to also dance, sing(if possible), fight, run , get dramatic etc apart from just "subtle" stuff, if he has to be considered "versatile".
And each of this "variety" should have been enjoyed by people of all walks of life.
Otherwise, we can definitely call some a "great actor" but not necessarily "versatile" one, IMPTO. (i.e. possibly twisted opinion)
Jegan(of Ayan fame) in his weekly movie review program KadavuL paadhi mirugam paadhi in Vijay TV:Quote:
In my book - actor has to also dance, sing(if possible), fight, run , get dramatic etc apart from just "subtle" stuff, if he has to be considered "versatile
MovieL: Aayudham I think
Comment: Indha padathula Prashant oDarar, jump pandraar, building mela thaavarar, kudhirai ottarar, neechal adikkarar - naDikkaradhu thavira ellam pandraar.
Nerd,
I didn't say collections alone decide whether one is versatile or not. It's a necessary indicator - that's all. It provides insight into what "other" people (i.e. including people other than the hubbers) think about a particular performance.
writre lyrics,wield camera,write the scriptQuote:
Originally Posted by app_engine
its one and only Versatile king Vijaya t rajender.
A_E, with due respect, what people outside hubbers think is immaterial to hubbers. If we have to go by bias, we'd rather go by hubbers' bias than non-hubbers'. This could be my own TO
Ippathaan versatilityngra vaarthaikke oru perumai kedichirukku....Quote:
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Anga suthi, inga suthi kadaisila correeetta vathuteenga...
Plum :-)
BTW, Prashanth is more versatile than his dad :-)
It could ONLY get better u know.Quote:
Originally Posted by app_engine
Viv, omega
:lol:
:-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Vivasaayi
Idhu Simbu vishayathula work out aachungareenga?(atlest his father mad some decent tunes...)
Daddy - pretty good tunes + lyrics in at least 8 films :clap: sombukku adhellAm varaadhu..
Digression -
Very true!Quote:
Originally Posted by Plum
In that area, he was definitely much more versatile than some phenomenally successful current MDs :-)
End-digression
A_E,
You are confusing and mixing up things, i'm afraid.
Firstly, this is just a time-pass discussion on who we (that is, I, as an individual) think are the versatile actors of this generation, leaving the oldies aside. If someone asks you, who is your favorite musician or who has done the broadest body of work, do you go and conduct a survey or check audio sales?
Secondly,
Versatility = doing different things successfully, as against not doing different things or doing different things but unsuccessfully. Period. Thats all there is to it. Simple
Well, if song and dance are to be included, fine, by all means. However, we fail to see what collections has anything to do with what we are discussing. Even as an indicator, your definition baffles me!
Maybe you can coin a new word to include your definition. Versatility enna paavam pannichu? :)
Quote:
Originally Posted by app_engine
Quote:
Originally Posted by app_engine
Was going through all the posts in this topic and thght naamalum kuttaya kozhapuvomnu
Surya -i believe he still has lots to learn-total masala appadinaa he cant act
Aaru,Vel-rendume sothappal
Someone said hes done a gr8 job in Ayan -honestaa niraya Vijay Saayal therinjuthu and romba fakeaavum irunthuchu
Varanam aayiram-Appa character FLOPu
Son character was strictly Ok
Ghajini -looked extremely handsome as Sanjay Ramaswamy but thats it
Mounam Pesiyadhe-was good
Khaaka Khaaka -again looked stylish but will that count as 'versatile' I dont think so!!!
Chinna -was really good
So Surya versatilaa appadinaa i would say no
On a relative scale i can accept Vikram except that he cant act in a comic role
Current generationla versatile appadinu yaarume illa but everyones trying their bit
:exactly: sariyA sonneenga.Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerd
inimE yAradhu pandithar bAgavathar 'neenga.... irukku :x
Current generation as applies to anything that is "current" is still evolving though! :PQuote:
Originally Posted by cuty2sweety
CR,
Actually there's no confusion. :-)
I've just added an "additional clause" to concretise your definition.
i.e.Quote:
Originally Posted by CR
Commercial success of a particular role is an indication of doing something "SUCCESSfully". மொத்தத்தில் நீங்க சொன்னதே தான் :-)
Thats right :) Unarchi vasapattutein!!!Quote:
Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
:shock: 42 pages and we are still stuck with Madhavan and Surya. Better retitle the thread as Madhavan vs Surya.
So, is Dhanush rejetted Plum?
groucho, looks so - he is a good actor, and has a bright future but versatility - inime dhaan kaamikkaNum. I havent felt any evidence to the contrary.
(Both the rejeeted candidates, Vikram and Dhanush - are among my "ok, I'll watch his movie even without knowing anything concrete about it" candidates - bias gas-nu ellam aarambikkadheengappa)
Avlo dhaana? Edhavadhu araminga illa continue pannungappa.. "Aatha manasu sangadappadumla?"
(Read like kaLLappArt natarajan) Indha thread-Oda abrupt mudivu dhaan-yA indha TFI-la uLLa vesatility-kku oru udhAraNam. nallA thread-aiyum aarambichchu, hubbergaLaiyum kootti..idhaiyum solla vachchupputteenga
LOL!Quote:
Originally Posted by Prabhu Ram
joke'aa :?
Ok, with Dhanush rejected
Let's take Bharath and Jeeva.
Aarmbikkalama?
(aatha manasu sangaDa pada vida maatomla)
Maddhavan : indha panjaayaththula enakku mariyaadhayE illa :xQuote:
Originally Posted by Plum
Surya : aamaanga, podi pasangalOda ellaam koottu sEththu nammala asingapaduththuraanga :evil:
Dhanush : yEyaa varuththappadureenga, ungalayaavudhu aattaila sEththukkittaanga... enna :cry3:
Prasanna : enna consider kooda pannala :hammer: :hammer:
Sarna, enna mariyadhai illa. Avarai dhaan adutha roundku pass pannittomla. nalladhukke kaalamillaippa...
Vikram : enna paaththu sollu
Plum : u r rejeeted
Vikram : en moonjiya paaththu sollu
Plum : u r rejeeted
Vikram : en kanna paaththu sollu
Plum : u r rejeeted
Vikram : en mookka paaththu sollu
Plum : u r rejeeted
Vikram : en palla paaththu sollu
Plum : u r rejeeted
Vikram : en naakka paaththu sollu
Plum : :roll:
Anniyan : mokkaadirambam'na ennanu theriyumaa :evil:
Plum : theriyaadhE :roll:
Anniyan : idhukku munnaadi sarna'vOda 2 mokka post padichchiyaa ?
Plum : aaamaa thaangala :sigh2:
Anniyan : adhu verum sample dhaan , enna nee aattaila sEththukkala, adhu maadhiri 20 latcham mokkaadirambam pOsts'a padikkavappEn :evil:
Plum : :frightened: u r selected :shaking:
now Ambi walks Vairamuthu walk :boo:
evLo mukkinAlum naDakkAdhu. Rules-na rules dhaan...Quote:
Originally Posted by Sarna
was watching bhuvana oru kelvikuri last night
inda padatha remake panna yaarai podalaam?
i think prithiviraj might suit sivakumar role but i dont know who might suit rajni's..
@ Sarna
unga avataarle... yaar sir anda ladies
dig//Subramanyapuram paaththirukkeengalaa ??? andha padaththOda heroine + USP 8-) her name is Swathy :cool2:Quote:
Originally Posted by mexicomeat
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f4Qe-...eature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dKbe5PX8F9s
she is dhaavani dhEvadhai :boo: I love her :redjump: :bluejump: //end
ipdilaam edagoodama love panniNA "The End" dhaan gadhi-ngareengala?Quote:
I love her //end