Originally Posted by app_engine
K,
If someone listens to the song for the first time in the movie hall, however great the song may be, what they see on-screen will have a great bearing on how they like the song.
If they've listened it prior -like those of us here in this forum - then the opinion will be on musical considerations alone and the video won't have any impact even when viewed later.
Ofcourse, people may dislike a movie's songs for many reasons; but to write that vAlmIki is IR's end etc only shows that the person has a pre-planned agenda. Such "opinions" have zero credentials for "review". That too when an IR-long-timer like me enjoys at least four songs from this movie for more than a month continuously, such opinions automatically earn their place in the garbage:-)