The way the discussion going now, I can understand one thing: Nobody wants to discuss "IR - The Singer".
As a singer he is just worth that much!!
Printable View
The way the discussion going now, I can understand one thing: Nobody wants to discuss "IR - The Singer".
As a singer he is just worth that much!!
Lets try dissecting Mother Songs First. What you are trying to say is the following songs can be interchanged 'AS IS' in to any other song situation:Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Naanaga naan illai thaaye
Amma Endrealaikaatha
Amma nee sumantha pillai
Ammanna summa illada
petha manasu pithathilum
Pethu eduthavathaan
en thayenum kovilai
sontham endru sonnavale aatha
Madavilake Magarasi
Amma Thaye thayamma
Amamamma unnai pole oru theivam
If we see on a larger perspective we may think these songs can be interchanged or plugged in to the other situation. But when you listen to orchestration and the minute details in these songs. They cannot be done so will be the understanding. you cannot Replace any other song with 'Amma Endralaikaatha'(It has a bit of Sophistication compared to the rawness in a Ramarajan song) or 'Naanaga naanillai'. ('Antha Keezhvaanile oli vanthathu'va arthapaduthra mathiri orchestrationa vera enga kondu poi plugin pannuveenga?)
But Yes few Ramarajan songs can be plugged in 'AS IS' into any other movie, For all the 30 movies he has acted, whoever may be the director, there was literally no change in the storyline, characterisation, narrative style...Ada Dress kooda maathala avaru. Then it is pretty much obvious that Raaja too will not change his music.
I think the confusion starts only from here. Ada ithellam 'Generic' Songsthaane. Raaja has done so many songs like this, then he is a generic composer too is the conclusion we try to arrive at. Apdi ellam simplify panna mudiyaathu avar musica. His music will always try to convey for a situation in sync with all other factors (Dir, Actor, Story Etc.) put together.
Thanks. You are a Loser :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by genesis
RS, another case study could be:
1) Oru sudar iru sudar - Rajavin Parvayile
2) Malai kovil vaasalil - Veera
1st tune was given by IR for Veera and got rejected by the Director. It was for a Rajini movie. He used the tune for a Vijay song (Rajavin Parvayile).
I was always wondering why these two songs sound very similar :)Quote:
Originally Posted by crvenky
Generally whenever Raja sings a version of a song, I end up liking his version a lot even if the other singer is a veteran singer. One song where I was really surprised by the singer sing the same version of the song Raja sang and sang it as well is Mahathi in 'Kadha Jathi'. The song be "Enna Marandalum'. Superb song and Plum had earlier written about Mahathi's raw vocals adding charm to this song. An excellent effort by her. Not sure why she did not sing too much under Raja.
அனைவருக்கும் வணக்கம் :)
இசைஞானி பாடிய முதல் இணைந்திசைப் பாடல் எதுவெனத் தெரியவேண்டும்.
1. தென்னமரத்துல தென்றலடிக்குது [பி.சுசீலா] - லக்ஷ்மி
2. சாமக்கோழி ஏன் கூவுதம்மா [எஸ்.பி.ஷைலஜா] - பொண்ணு ஊருக்கு புதுசு
( இவை இரண்டில் ஒன்றாக இல்லாமல் வேறொன்றாகவும் இருக்கலாம்.) உதவுங்கள்
நன்றி :)
Disk: ippadInnA 'duet' song-A?Quote:
Originally Posted by disk.box
ஆம் மதிப்பிற்குரிய ப்ரியா அவர்களே!
Quote:
Originally Posted by disk.box
Mudhal duet padal - Thenna marathula thendral