Printable View
Hulkster,
this link says the music is by VS
http://www.hindu.com/2006/06/04/stor...0407000200.htm
if its by IR then we can sure rejoice :) but lets wait till an official announcement :?
and moreover He is also scoring for the movie on 'Karunanidhi' titled 'Kalaignar' and it has been officialy announced :thumbsup:
Yeaps....i sincerely hope IR does the music for the periyar movie too...he and that director are a very good combination from what i heard in bharathy..:D
Hulks they have done Mogamul and mugam earlier to bharathy together :) Hope they dont split :cry:
I feel VS would give better melodies than IR as IR should be already drained of melodies by now. [No disrespect meant to the greatest IR here. But IR is human too. But I would be more than happy if miracles happen :) ]
Well according to this IR is scoring for Periyaar
http://www.indiaglitz.com/channels/t...cle/23045.html
Not sure if IR would accept composing music on a subject that calls for atheism!!
Thumburu,
Just curious what melody by IR was pale in comparision to VS melody in recent times or what VS melody was extraordinary (No disrespect to talented VS here, VS does give more melodies and has been giving melodies more often than others if not consistantly)but IMO VS success and recognition from masses unfortunately has come more for his kuthu songs Like Dhool, Gilli, Run than his melodies.
I don't know if IR's melodies are drained they still stand distinct from others ex. Madhu, Rasathanthram.
What melodies do we need for a movie on " Periyar" anyways, even with single soul stirring song with some amazing BGM for " Kamaraj" IR did a terrific job which might not have been the case with other MDs. IMO only ARR has estblished in providing better scores for period movies and Biographical movies ( multiple examples), may be he should be given ( but that's a dream knowing time and money involved with ARR, they could make several movies on many other leaders on that budget and time )
I am not against VS, who knows he might do good too, but I am not sure if he is capable of doing some thing distinct for movies like this.
On the BGM aspect, somehow I have always felt, IR should try something new in his forthcoming movies, being a HC fan of his BGMs despite being predictable in some sequences and repitative some how they are never boring or unsuitable in any of the movies till now, but somehow I felt Adoor Gopal's "Nizhalkuthu" had some totally different BGM score by IR (very subtle yet so good) may be the movie narration had some thing different
sudhakarg
I'd hope not!!! I wouldn't want to see such a great talent using his musical capabilities to promote atheism.Quote:
Not sure if IR would accept composing music on a subject that calls for atheism!!
Only a couple of weeks back i was able to get the Rasathanthiram CD. i was very impressed with the " Poo Kungkuma Poo " , " Aathinkarayorathu " and "Ponnavani.."..
Manjari seems to be good find.. KJY's Poo Kungumapoo version - he sounds tired..but the Chitra version was Excellent.
The CD had some bonus mallu songs as well .. pretty decent..Worth the money i spent for the CD.
Incidentally i was talking to a co-worker ( from kerala ) and he said the movie's director Sathyan is considered top notch in Kerala and has given quite a few decent flicks.
I also bought Pachakuthira but have not listened to it yet..
Cheers
MSK
I sincerely hope IR works with Gnana sekaran for Periyar.