auuuuuuuuuuuuuuuQuote:
Originally Posted by raaja_rasigan
Printable View
auuuuuuuuuuuuuuuQuote:
Originally Posted by raaja_rasigan
[Start digression.]
We object to this, my lord, we object to this. (*)
Why is being decent, "clean," etc. even considered a paradigm in appreciating humour. I wonder why such qualities are even considered to be "perfect" at first place, leave aside asserting that no contemporary comedian has been "perfect." I'd shudder to use expressions like "not mind" when it comes to bawdiness. A healthy dose of bawdiness is even precious at times. * Obscenity is obscenity, humour is humour. One doesn't have to steer clear of the other. It's funny if one finds it funny, there need be no disclaimer on top of this.
Probably, someone should start a thread for obscenely funny comedy sequences in Tamil cinema for the ethically depraved like yours truly. Vadivelu wryly noting, "but, andha dealing enakku romba pidichirundhuchu..." is the one that comes off the top of my head right now.
* -- Like S. Ve. Shekar says in mahAbArathaththil MangAththA. It's also befitting to bring in this man whose patent bawdiness is unmissable and often outrageous.
[End digression.]
Quote:
Originally Posted by equanimus
:lol: :lol: :lol:
Equanimus,Quote:
Originally Posted by equanimus
Clincher :notworthy: :notworthy: :thumbsup:
P.S: Disclaimer: Agreeing with EQ on this does not mandate me to contradict my stand on Oram Po [there's no contradiction whatsoever, actually] :razz:
P.P.S: EQ, Venniraadai Moorthi thread arambikkanum. enna solrael?
DIG ENDS// :oops:
"We" should be asking that :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Roshan
Comments like "i won't be able to take you seriously", remarking about PR's posts as "Amaam Saami posts", "Om x-aya namaha" etc etc... are reactions triggered by emotions, prejudice and blind veneration for antiquity-nu kooda sollalaam.
*IMO* Actor Nagesh > Comedian Nagesh. In fact, he was largely an unsung hero, and a phenomenal talent and i don't think anybody denied that here.
[His Thiruvilayaadal role is one of my all time fav]
Like S.Ve Sekar says in KPY-3, "yaaru maximum laughter create panraanga-ngaradhu mattum dhaan mukkiyam"
Thilak,
sila vishayangal ellam inga pesapdaadhu :notthatway: thappu, taboo :oops:
By the way, is there someone in this hub (or elsewhere) who (still) laughs for NSK jokes?? :shock: :roll:
1. Inga 'yArumE' perfect kedeyAthu Bala :)Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
2. I agree with you on this completely but that was not the point discussed or mentioned here I feel. You may not think , but I strongly felt that it was vehemently denied when Vadivelu was rated above Nagesh (no matter it is comedy or serious acting). To me it was a 'blashpemy'. Adhu Kamal Hassan'a kooda indirect'a insult paNNuRathukku samam , as I to some extent know, to what extent Kamal hails Nagesh as an actor and comedian (idhu matha Kamal fans'ku chinna vishayamA irukkalAm but not to me definitely )
3. True ! But how would you measure that when it comes to cine comedians/comedies.. KPY mAthiri oru one hour program'la ellA comediangaLaiyum orE mEdaiyikku koopittu - perform paNNa cholli - Uma Riaz sirikkiRatha vechu OraLavu judge paNNalaam. To me Nagesh and Vivek create maximum laughter but to you it can be either Vadivelu or V.Moorthi.
UNmaithAn.. "we" should be telling that. Sorry Bala :(Quote:
Thilak,
sila vishayangal ellam inga pesapdaadhu :notthatway: thappu, taboo :oops:
Bala,
I never intended to start this. En thappu thEn I'll say this even if our Nattamais, and periyorgal can't stand my viewpoint. I can't change the fact that I found Nagesh's humour more diverse, and appreciative in last two decades (and under Mr.X :lol2:) than the style he normally operates in his yesteryear films.
By the way, I don't give two hoots on cries of my "om X-aya namaha", yes, there are many Xs, one among 'em is Kamal, and maybe even Nagesh. As for their "namahas" - I don't give a damn!)
Equanimus, :thumbsup: Yes, I'm ethically depraved. The point I was stressing earlier is similar, most would secretly enjoy these vulgar or supposedly offensive humour!
It seems that this thread is full of serious discussions.. i thought that this thread was ment to discuss only about "Vivek" and him only.. why there are so many deviations from the main stream ? :roll: ..
:exactly:Quote:
Originally Posted by equanimus
:lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by equanimus
ennathu !!Quote:
Originally Posted by Roshan
Once Kamal mentioned how comedians tend to turn a comedy scene on their head. The two names he mentioned were Nagesh and VKR. Perhaps it was the only instance where he mentioned him in the same breath as Nagesh. But he did.
But it is going to take a lot of imagination to say VKR is better than Vadivelu. Or am I on my blaspheming ways again :-)
Thought experiment: would the reaction have been so strong if I had said Thangavelu > Nagesh (don't panic, I won't say that. In fact I'd have a coronary if someone does) ?
I think not. That would have been a quaint technical point of discussion. Whereas Vadivelu has with him other baggages (chief among them being his contemporaneity) that takes the comparison to a very emotional/nostalgic plane.
NSK never seems to be a comedian atleast to me......he was never ever funny....maybe informative at that bygone era!
In Mathurai veeran......
NSK:Ithu thaama vaigai nathi....
Mathuram:Ennanga aathula thanniye illa?
NSK:Ithu punniya theertham vai kai kaiyai vachu thalaiyila thelichuputtu poga vendiyath thaan!