ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

"Maybe if I had just said "Rahman had a big impact" instead of saying "bigger" impact(which sounded like as if I was directly comparing impacts) it would have come across better."
This is exactly what I meant. I wouldnt contest any fan-camp sweeping statements . I only bothered to question you because I know (in about 7 years of reading this forum) that you are more committed to sensible discussions and this sort of out-oof-the-blue illogic was uncharacterstic:-)
I agree on this:
We have to state without reservations that of all TFM personalities, it is ARR who has made a dent or impact on North Indian sensibilities.

This however doesnt automatically make him a superior or even a equal of previous TFM greats like MSV, IR etc. What places him in this elite pantheon is the quality of his music, and not the adulation of North Indian music fans.To quote the latter as a reason for his greatness speaks more about the person making the statement.

and vijay, I know about you purely from posts in this forum. Atleast, in the early days, around '98-'99 , there WAS a vijay with similar views -if my assumption is that you are that same vijay, I know a little about you through this forum. Okay, lets have a recognition test - Can you recognise the term "veliayathavan"? :-)

rajdes, I was partially kidding, recognition test ellam thevai illa:-) Of course I remember your posts and most other regular DFers from that period. But still you made what I thought was a confident guess based on just my current posts. What with many DFers from that period no longer frequenting this forum it took me a while to ascertain that you are actually that same raj and not someone else.

:D Hey buddies ARR is grown with name and fame. May be it is fading now. This is a competition only between HJ and YSR. HJ is giving music to movies under big directors :lol: . Naturally it is a great hit. Yuvan's arindhum ariyamalum was hit only and only because of his Music which is extremely awesome. HJ keeps on repeating the same music. One gets bored after listening to it after quite a few times. YSR's music is completely different. :) One who listens to his music again and again will be more eager to listen to it again.

Welcome Sundar12345.
Yet another YSR fan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sundar12345

:D Hey buddies ARR is grown with name and fame. May be it is fading now. This is a competition only between HJ and YSR

---

but these 2 supposedly better-than-ARR mds came up with a blank when confronted with a average A Ah by our master.....wat do u say for this??? :lol: :lol:

Going thinking that A Ah is a big hit are faking themselves. Ghajini is the winner

yes i agree with sunder12345.ysr far better than hj..

http://www.kumudam.com/kumudam/231105/pg17.php

Bharadwaj sema kaduppil irukkAr...avaraiyum indha Attaththil sEththukkungaLEn...

aiyoo u have to be registered to read that article...Bharathwaj is not that good. looking at audio/cd sales it clearly indicates, ARR, HJ, YSR are the most popular ones, once in a while VS pops up with great songs. Even a hardcore fan of VS like me admits this. IT must be true