Which MD is best suited for Rajini?

200+ is Couple of movies according to UmaRameshji
And I havent include his Malayalam,Telugu and Kannada movies

Well what can one expect from people who claim there are 1800+ movies composed by their favourite MD and when asked for a list they cant come up even with 300-400 movies
_________________
Hi Rajasaranam

OH GOD . leave alone comparison/no of movies etc. Why you guys not accepting the fact? He lost his market in the initial years after ARR entry and not able to rule as he did before? Did world able to prove that Vairamuthu/Manirathnam /Bharathiraja/Rajini/kamal gave big hits without IR? 8-)

Yes you like IR and you have every right to say HE IS BEST but when yu start writing in common forum you shuold accept the fact..
(quite open whether you are accepting or not).

ramesh

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by umaramesh

OH GOD . leave alone comparison/no of movies etc. Why you guys not accepting the fact? He lost his market in the initial years after ARR entry and not able to rule as he did before? Did world able to prove that Vairamuthu/Manirathnam /Bharathiraja/Rajini/kamal gave big hits without IR? 8-)
ramesh

---

Market pona orutharukku 300 padangal (after 1992) kodukka film producers ellam enna madaiyargala.

Again and again you are wrong

OMGoodness,could u guys stop it & just get back to the original topic.... this IRfans hatred towards ARR will never end !! its no use explaning to them the fact,its coz they know it but just dun wanna agree it..."tungereven koode yelupidhelam,aanal thungeremathiri nadikeevennu yeluppe kastham" we can only pitty them.....


back to topic.....

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by umaramesh

_________________
Hi Rajasaranam

OH GOD . leave alone comparison/no of movies etc. Why you guys not accepting the fact? He lost his market in the initial years after ARR entry and not able to rule as he did before? Did world able to prove that Vairamuthu/Manirathnam /Bharathiraja/Rajini/kamal gave big hits without IR? 8-)

Yes you like IR and you have every right to say HE IS BEST but when yu start writing in common forum you shuold accept the fact..
(quite open whether you are accepting or not).

ramesh

---

well said Umaji.....i'm happy that atleast MSV fans acknowledge ARR's contri to TFM in 90's....

well said Dinesh, u r more matured than us man :D .....keep it up...

http://www.imdb.com/user/ur0127006/comments

just go thru the comments by a Japanese author on music of Muthu.....truly, ARRahman's music has a global appeal :thumbsup:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by umaramesh

_________________
Hi Rajasaranam

OH GOD . leave alone comparison/no of movies etc. Why you guys not accepting the fact? He lost his market in the initial years after ARR entry and not able to rule as he did before? Did world able to prove that Vairamuthu/Manirathnam /Bharathiraja/Rajini/kamal gave big hits without IR? 8-)

Yes you like IR and you have every right to say HE IS BEST but when yu start writing in common forum you shuold accept the fact..
(quite open whether you are accepting or not).

ramesh

---

well said Umaji.....i'm happy that atleast MSV fans acknowledge ARR's contri to TFM in 90's....

well said Dinesh, u r more matured than us man :D .....keep it up...

http://www.imdb.com/user/ur0127006/comments

just go thru the comments by a Japanese author on music of Muthu.....truly, ARRahman's music has a global appeal :thumbsup:

---

Maddy,nakkal thaane??? :lol:

btw,my relative used to work in this Japanese firm,and itseems this Japanese bussinesman :!: seems to praise Muthu songs everytime he meets my relative...it seems Muthu songs were aired in JApanase FM's very often. :clap: and my relative happens to be HCIRF :lol: ....she told me that half-heartedly :lol:

Ok Back to the topic folks
IR leading the Poll... does that ring any bell in the ignorants ear :P

Hi
coming back to topics IR scored more movies with Rajini during peak time and stick to him only (may be one or two movies with other MD)after IR Rajini use to change MD frequently(Deva/ARR/Vidyasagar). Very difficult analyse as IR scored more number of movies than other MD's.

ramesh

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sanjeevi

Dear rajasaranam,

I too was a HC fan of ARR duing 1992-1995. Even i have cut the media news about ARR whatever it was article, Q&A, interviews, gossips, etc.

1998-kku mela IR waste-nu Nakkeeran sonnthukku than kovam.

The top 5 melodies given by IR at recent times

Ozhiyile therivathu devathaiya
Ilangathu Veesuthey
Ennakku piditha paadal
Kaatril varum geethame
Nee partha parvaikkoru

And i want to ask nakeeran. What about these songs?

---

Sorry guys for the late entry .

Sanjeevi, so you could list just 5 numbers :oops:

Indeed they are a mild reminiscent of the old IR

Dont expose IR like this :wink: Its a true & self confession ?

I compare IR with his peak period , the 80s and the % of hits in a movie . IR draws a huge blank after mid90s. very little to cheer about. Its an open fact .

Again, its hard but indigestable fact that IR music went into a decline from mid 90s ( NO RELEVANCE TO THE ARRIVAL OF ARR ) .
He must have got exhausted by that time. after all a continuous musical journey since 76 to 94.
Besides, IR needs quality directors to get the best out of him . If he associates with the likes of MR , Cheran, ( leaving aside his KOBAM ) , we may expect some old magic of his . but I am not sure still.
No need for guys like Sanjeevi to get offended as I havent wrote anything wrong on IR. All indigestable facts only.
Its a phase one has to go through in life.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rajasaranam

Ok Back to the topic folks
IR leading the Poll... does that ring any bell in the ignorants ear :P

---

Rajasaranam, it goes without saying that IR will ultimately win but the topic got digressed to a shadow boxing between IR - ARR fans which is sad. So, it seems this has been chosen as another arena for continuing the old arch rivalry ? :cry:

My only point to share with is that during rajini's peak days, it was IR only ( HE WAS THE ONLY KING ) and obviously the choice goes to him but it in no way undermines the abilities of ARR as a composer. Given 3 chances, he did really well and all songs were hits. :thumbsup: