Which MD is best suited for Rajini?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nakeeran

Sanjeevi, so you could list just 5 numbers :oops:
Indeed they are a mild reminiscent of the old IR
Dont expose IR like this :wink: Its a true & self confession ?

---

He clearly said TOP 5 melodies from IR and you mistook it for just 5

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nakeeran

Again, its hard but indigestable fact that IR music went into a decline from mid 90s ( NO RELEVANCE TO THE ARRIVAL OF ARR ) .
He must have got exhausted by that time. after all a continuous musical journey since 76 to 94.

---

Decline after 94 :!: huh cant reason with you anymore :huh:
Check out the list i gave already for the movies from 1994 till now you can really find many super hit songs aswelas quality songs from him.

Quote:

---

My only point to share with is that during rajini's peak days, it was IR only ( HE WAS THE ONLY KING ) and obviously the choice goes to him but it in no way undermines the abilities of ARR as a composer. Given 3 chances, he did really well and all songs were hits.

---

I wouldn't include BABA it was a miserable failure. Anantha vikatan ridiculed ARR like never before 'Londonla irunthuttu padathukku tune potta eppadi irukkum - ippadithaan irukkum' :lol:
Morevoer how are you able to overlook hit songs from IR after 1994 and without any hesitation say that BABA was a hit? hmmm... :notworthy:

Rajasaranam

Anandha vikatan's remarks cant be a benchmark for assessing Baba's music

By decline after 94, I mean the volumes of hits when compared to the 80s. Its an established fact RS. the strike rate was definitely lower during this period

Dear Scale,
I wish to tell that the quote from IR you took upon is out of context and misquoted and made fun of, which could irritate some df-ers and fans, nothing more, there were other contexts when IR's ego overshadowed his musical genius. In my opinion a musical genius like IR or for any artist should have that kind of ego and pride as long as it is not reflected in the media. (we can argue again and again, Mike Tyson said he is the world best fighter, even though it is true, i thought that was a good motivation, Rasheed Wallace told we will kick bu$$ 2 days back. I like that pride as long as they respect something, Mike T boxing, Rasheed the game of basketball, now the media is having a heck of time). Nobody can diminish the other person by just saying things. We are the ones who are feeling hurt externally, reality might be different.

Media could project things either ways as we know it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nakeeran

Rajasaranam

Anandha vikatan's remarks cant be a benchmark for assessing Baba's music

By decline after 94, I mean the volumes of hits when compared to the 80s. Its an established fact RS. the strike rate was definitely lower during this period

---

Sure AV can't be a benchmark but dont you know that BABA's music was a failure :?: if you dont you are good in acting or just ignorant :huh:

That was agreed earlier itself. But there is a subtle difference in the way you and me are portraying that period. I say there were reasonable no. of hits aswels quality songs post 94 but you portray as though that period was a waste in total and its very hard to digest and all.
you are trying to emphasise on the point that IR's period is well and over from mid 90's.
while we are trying to say 'Vaanavil vaithu vannangalai thooviyum' 'Elangathaai veesi' kondum irunkaar Raja Atha purinjikitta 'unnai vida intha ulagathil usanthathu onnum illa' nnu sandhoshama irukalaam :)

Rajasaranam,have u ever thought of getting a physiatrist's appointment??? ur taking things too seriously,when u can actually accept Anantha Vikathan's comment!!! all they will do is comment on anything as long thier cheap magazine gets sold....ASAIC,Baba audio was just suitable for its story & screenplay.this AV is just burning to know that ARR composes songs true online,no offence,but try giving that task to any MD at that point,they will come up with a worse album than Baba,and that includes ur IR too!!....infact,i never got a news that AV treats all MD's in same level,they will alwiz crown IR eventhough that album was a dud!!

Sorry Maddy,i take back my words,these guys need people like us to keep on reminding them about facts....!!!! :lol:

Since when BABA's audio was a flop???!!! just coz it wasnt as popular as Padaiyappa or Muthu doesnt mean its a flop,infact if im not mistaken, it was the HIGHEST selling album that year!!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rajasaranam

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nakeeran

Rajasaranam

Anandha vikatan's remarks cant be a benchmark for assessing Baba's music

By decline after 94, I mean the volumes of hits when compared to the 80s. Its an established fact RS. the strike rate was definitely lower during this period

---

Sure AV can't be a benchmark but dont you know that BABA's music was a failure :?: if you dont you are good in acting or just ignorant :huh:

That was agreed earlier itself. But there is a subtle difference in the way you and me are portraying that period. I say there were reasonable no. of hits aswels quality songs post 94 but you portray as though that period was a waste in total and its very hard to digest and all.
you are trying to emphasise on the point that IR's period is well and over from mid 90's.
while we are trying to say 'Vaanavil vaithu vannangalai thooviyum' 'Elangathaai veesi' kondum irunkaar Raja Atha purinjikitta 'unnai vida intha ulagathil usanthathu onnum illa' nnu sandhoshama irukalaam :)

---

Rajasaranam

ETERNAL OPTIMISM is the only phrase that comes to my mind now about IR's music from now. Raja's decline from the mid90s is history and Raja himself knows this but why you guys keep on harping a dead subject !?
Once in a blue moon, IR may come out with classy numbers but even other MDs have done this .
Indha vishayathil, oru paanai sotrukku oru soru padhamaagadhu RS.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rajasaranam

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nakeeran

Rajasaranam

Anandha vikatan's remarks cant be a benchmark for assessing Baba's music

By decline after 94, I mean the volumes of hits when compared to the 80s. Its an established fact RS. the strike rate was definitely lower during this period

---

Sure AV can't be a benchmark but dont you know that BABA's music was a failure :?: if you dont you are good in acting or just ignorant :huh:

That was agreed earlier itself. But there is a subtle difference in the way you and me are portraying that period. I say there were reasonable no. of hits aswels quality songs post 94 but you portray as though that period was a waste in total and its very hard to digest and all.
you are trying to emphasise on the point that IR's period is well and over from mid 90's.
while we are trying to say 'Vaanavil vaithu vannangalai thooviyum' 'Elangathaai veesi' kondum irunkaar Raja Atha purinjikitta 'unnai vida intha ulagathil usanthathu onnum illa' nnu sandhoshama irukalaam :)

---

Rajasaranam,

As you got swayed by Vikatan's remarks, let me tell you something about Kumutham's comments when Apoorva ragangal was released. They made such a scathy comment on Rajini that he didnt forget that till date ! :oops:
Magazine comments are not a true representation of what music lovers have in their minds. :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nakeeran

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by rajasaranam

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nakeeran

Rajasaranam

Anandha vikatan's remarks cant be a benchmark for assessing Baba's music

By decline after 94, I mean the volumes of hits when compared to the 80s. Its an established fact RS. the strike rate was definitely lower during this period

---

Sure AV can't be a benchmark but dont you know that BABA's music was a failure :?: if you dont you are good in acting or just ignorant :huh:

That was agreed earlier itself. But there is a subtle difference in the way you and me are portraying that period. I say there were reasonable no. of hits aswels quality songs post 94 but you portray as though that period was a waste in total and its very hard to digest and all.
you are trying to emphasise on the point that IR's period is well and over from mid 90's.
while we are trying to say 'Vaanavil vaithu vannangalai thooviyum' 'Elangathaai veesi' kondum irunkaar Raja Atha purinjikitta 'unnai vida intha ulagathil usanthathu onnum illa' nnu sandhoshama irukalaam :)

---

Rajasaranam,

As you got swayed by Vikatan's remarks, let me tell you something about Kumutham's comments when Apoorva ragangal was released. They made such a scathy comment on Rajini that he didnt forget that till date ! :oops:
Magazine comments are not a true representation of what music lovers have in their minds. :D

---

:clap: :clap: :clap:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nakeeran

Rajasaranam,

As you got swayed by Vikatan's remarks, let me tell you something about Kumutham's comments when Apoorva ragangal was released. They made such a scathy comment on Rajini that he didnt forget that till date ! :oops:
Magazine comments are not a true representation of what music lovers have in their minds. :D

---

There was no such incident and its just your's or anybody else's wild imagination running free.
Think about this :arrow: Rajini was a nobody in 'Apoorva Ragangal' he just opens up a gate in one scene and stands alone listening to Srividya singing in the climax .What will a magazine comment about this :lol:
Well then if the magazines start commenting about every side actor who just flashes by in few frames :huh: they will need to publish a separate issue for writing movie criticism :notworthy:

Anf If magazine comments are not true representation of music lovers who else is a true representative :?: Only you, dinesh, scale and maddy :wink:
On whose comments you people are praising ARR?. There cant be a true representation anywhere any representation is a biased one. We would say the same for ARR that ALW, TLOS, Bollywood, Chinese, filmfare, National awards all cant be true representation.
You people always come up with filmfare or time magazine links to prove yourself right. and when a local Thamizh magazine says something you cant accept it because Magazine comments are not a true representation of what music lovers have in their minds Enna Double standards Keep it up :clap: :thumbsup:

Dinesh you are in Iggy mode :poke: