Printable View
True musical lovers of IR will definitely vouch for me . IR's BEST MUSICAL YEARS ARE OVER AND WHAT IS LEFT OUT NOW IS GLIMPSES OF HIS SILKEN TOUCH ONLY.
Rajasaranam, what you percieve is HOPE / OPTIMISM but not what you actually think that IR can achieve now
Its sad but an undeniable truth
Its better not to expect extraordinary things out of IR so that we will get some good stuff but not the innovations of 80s
Rajasaranam, I dont recollect word by word account of what Kumudham wrote but this is a fact. The comments were so severe on him ( forget the fact that he appeared in brief etc )Quote:
Originally Posted by rajasaranam
This is not the ideal way to welcome a newcomer.
Rajasaranam , comments by a magazine comprises a limited set of editorial team ( Madhan from Vikatan those days ) and its just a sample which doesnt constitute population.
Rajinikanth should really be a gifted man to have had 50 + movies with Ilayaraja's music.
He is the only person to have given songs extremely appropriate for various moods in a Rajinikanth movie. I do not need to explain this more as I would be stating the obvious.
For those claiming Raja is below his best, adopt the following steps:
Level 1: Listen to Madhu songs (Nilavai chutti, and Ketkavillaya)
Level 2: Listen to all songs in Rasathanthtram
Level 3: Go back to your 2003 collections and listen to July Ganapathy and Pithamagan
Level 4: Wait for Naan Kadavul.
If the claim is that Raja hasn't given his bets for rajini.. his last hit Veera was actually a musical hit.. which was accepted by Rajini himself in the 100th day celebrations.
Well, may be Rajini wanted to come out of the Raja spell... to bring out his individual brilliance, which was over-ridden by Raja's music those days.
Rajinikanth should really be a gifted man to have had 50 + movies with Ilayaraja's music.
He is the only person to have given songs extremely appropriate for various moods in a Rajinikanth movie. I do not need to explain this more as I would be stating the obvious.
For those claiming Raja is below his best, adopt the following steps:
Level 1: Listen to Madhu songs (Nilavai chutti, and Ketkavillaya)
Level 2: Listen to all songs in Rasathanthtram
Level 3: Go back to your 2003 collections and listen to July Ganapathy and Pithamagan
Level 4: Wait for Naan Kadavul.
If the claim is that Raja hasn't given his best for rajini.. his last hit Veera was actually a musical hit.. which was accepted by Rajini himself in the 100th day celebrations.
Well, may be Rajini wanted to come out of the Raja spell... to bring out his individual brilliance, which was over-ridden by Raja's music those days.
I dont understand why you are beating around the bush :huh:Quote:
Originally Posted by Nakeeran
IR's best period is over :arrow: accepted already
IR didnt have too many great hits from mid 90's onwards :arrow: accepted already
Its better not to expect extraordinary things out of IR so that we will get some good stuff but not the innovations of 80s :arrow: accepted already
All these things are arising from the situation when we compare IR against IR. I dont want to do that and Iam comparing IR with current crop of MD's and say he is the best over here. Understood :hammer: If you got anything against this point Lets discuss, If not go to hell Iam tired :twisted:
[quote="rajasaranam Understood :hammer: If you got anything against this point Lets discuss, If not go to hell Iam tired :twisted:[/quote]
Rajasaranam, I didnt expect this from you. DFers should have some etiquette. GO TO HELL is something which my Karma will decide :cry: :cry:
Pls stick to the issue. I have to highlight the current plight of IR to your type of OPTIMISTS to be more realistic so that you will not have further disappointments about IR.
Your set of guys resemble the MSV followers of the 80s :oops:
Nakeeran,
Just because renault brought in 'Madhu' songs Iam saying this:
He said about 'Ketkavillaya' This is a situation where a hero is singing in 'Yekkam' towards the heroine and heroine joins in the second stanza giving hopes for his love.
A similar situation can be said for 'Paadu nilavae' from 'udhayageetham' in which hero and heroine are juxtaposed from this song. [This is the song that comes immtly to my mind there may be other songs too]
If we compare both songs i would rate 'Paadu nilavae' as IR's best but given the situation 'Ketkavillaya' is a good song filled full of emotions. Now come up with a similar situational song from any other MD and I can vouch Raja is better than the best even when he is worst compared to himself. Only 'Uyirae Uyirae' can come close to IR in this analogy.
[quote="rajasaranam
All these things are arising from the situation when we compare IR against IR. I dont want to do that and Iam comparing IR with current crop of MD's and say he is the best over here. [/quote]
Pls dont for heaven's sake compare IR with current crop of guys around. You are only insulting IR in the process. IR IS A TRUE GENIUS WHO CANNOT BE COMPARED WITH ANYONE.
Dont voluntarily downgrade IR by comparing with current generation of copycats from latest musical software :wink:
Great. rajasaranam. let me add more spice to Padu nilavay.Quote:
Originally Posted by rajasaranam
I am sure you will be aware . It was IR who suggested to the lyrics writer to make it as PAADUM NILAVAY ( from padu nilavay ) when SPB sings for Mike M.
THIS SUMS UP WHAT KIND OF SUBTLE CHANGES THAT HE MADE TO CHANGE THE COLOUR OF THE SONG.
HE HAS MADE MANY SUCH MINDBLOWING CHANGES IN THE LAST MINUTE WHICH HAD STUNNED MANY LYRICISTS !