ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

In my opinion there is no question about ARR being better than HJ. ARR is definitely better. And I think YSR too is better than HJ though HJ is reported to receive higher payment than YSR. I just loved all the songs in Minnalae. He showed absolute mastery and control in that movie. But after that, honestly, "Gulmohar Malarae" is the only song I feel to be in the same calibre of the songs of Minnalae. I havent heard all of his songs after Minnalae. But the songs I heard are not very good... for example 12B, other songs of Majnu, Anniyan etc. It looks like he is trying hard to make good different music. He uses a lot of techno sounds and effects. He really makes them sound perfect but the songs as a whole dont sound great. He just doesnt seem to have the free flow he had in Minnalae. Sorry, if there are other great songs of him which I havent heard.

x-ml to j-ml?

haha 'ml' stands for music lover

My 1st post here..


Its completly rude to compare ARR-HJ-YSR

comon..its like comparing Sachin with dhoni,pathan,sehwag

Diffrent era--diffrent times..

comon..when arr entered it was out and out compltly illayraja domination in tamil film music..and he ended it..with roja--Revoulanised indian film music.... and other hit albums.

He is the one who has got amazing success rate of 85%....

Hj-YSR are good...but are not best or great.

ARR and IR are great...dont compare..

ARR is like a sunshine to me...he may rise and set down in evening...but remeber sun always rises and when sun rises it gives enough light to all...to the peace..to the enjoyment of all..


wat ever..these new breed compasers have lot to learn..they can leanr from those 2 legends...

i think YSR is good..he improves but awk..this harris jayraj..leave it..no comments on him..


now those who are ready to pounce on me...let me tell..

Dont agree with the fact that "rahman revolutionised indian film music with roja?" dont say me or dont tell me its wrong..i didnt say this...its somewhere some group of persons told this and all over the indians accept this as a fact..its true..



IR is great...but i still go for Rahman..comon..melodies..ok good..but just to enjoy urself..u need these type of songs..

"pettai rap","Mukkabula", "Girlfriend", "Anbe Aaruyire","telephone manipol" and hell lots more...

These type of songs r pulse of youth..


and one more thing..todays dapankuthu mass songs and fast food type of songs..



always remember....





Music with Class is always better than Mass



ARR rocks..and rocks in big time..


and if i rank my fav 5 composers it wud be..

1.ARR
2.IR
3.YSR
4.Mani sharma
5.Vidyasagar

rest have long way to go..

said lot more here..thanks if u wud have read it fully..

Guys,only today i watched Totti Jeya,and i knew 2 things :

1.Yuvan Shankar Raja's song in that movie is not Samba Samba but its Intha Oore which was sung by gals when they were in Kolkatta.I noticed the typical YSR touch there,and Samba Samba clearly had Harris's touch with the base.Shockingly i didint see any part where they credited YSR for Samba Samba.

2.Sonnalum - Kadhal Virus tune was used as BGM.The line "Nathiyaena naan nadanthaen,Nanai thadutthum kadanthaen, Kadaisiyil kalanthaen, kadalae " was used as the BGM when Gopika will be sleeping n the train after missing the train & Simbhu wanted to wake her up,the same music comes up again when Gopika reaches her home back.

TJ that uppu karuvadu song, his choice for singer SM :banghead:, the way he sings :twisted: , exact BG ripoff :hammer:.

Ranjith is another singer rite? :lol:

forthcoming movies:
yuvan's pudhupettai, arr's godfather, hj's vettaiyadu vilayadu
who win?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by coucou

forthcoming movies:
yuvan's pudhupettai, arr's godfather, hj's vettaiyadu vilayadu
who win?

---

machan,all r releasing in diff dates/months...im not sure bout puttupetai,but GF movie on feb,VV probably on June only...how to compare machan?

WILL VV RELEASE IN JUNE? R U SURE?so what's the forthcoming album of hj?

No one knows about forthcoming albums of HJ? :huh: