Dear Mr. Badri and Mr. Nov
Again , I am not able to read the postings of Mr. Hari Krishnan
Please address this problem
Printable View
Dear Mr. Badri and Mr. Nov
Again , I am not able to read the postings of Mr. Hari Krishnan
Please address this problem
Viggop,Quote:
Also, i read that she was exceptionally beautiful that Hanuman initially mistook her for Sita.But,saliva was flowing from her mouth in sleep and hence he identified her as a member of rakshasha race.is this true?
Hanuman , on seeing Mandodari, was amazed by her divine looks and respectable looks and thought for a moment, whether it could be Sita. But immediately he realized his mistake when he recollected , the way Sri Ram described about their relationship and the way Sri Ram loved Sita, and the extent how Sri Ram missing his dear Sita , it is absolute madness to imagine Sita sleeping so peacefully and happily.
That’s how he clears his momentary doubts and starts searching for Sita again.
Here I also have a query… I wish Hanuman ought not to have first searched for Sita in the palace of Ravana….
Balaji,Quote:
Originally Posted by S.Balaji
To wish that way is to presuppose everything. A good, honest, diligent investigator must first eliminate all remote possibilities of the truth going otherwise.
Reliability means not giving in to personal opinions and judgements. As a reliable investigator - Hanuman was not a mere messenger - Hanuman had to do that unpleasant job as well. Then, it may be asked, 'OK, why then he had to start from Ravana - and other's - houses, first? He could have searched other places and later come here.' One has to remember that what the entire Sundara Kandam covers are the events that took place within a matter of 24 hours. The time available for Hanuman was exceedingly short. He therefore started with the negative possibility first.
That is one thing. Another aspect is that, who knew where was Sita kept imprisoned in Lanka? He might have put her in his own gynaeceum («ó¾ôÒÃõ). Or he might have placed her in some other person's house, like Kumbakarna, Indrajit, Vibishana, etc. Nothing was clear at that time. And the puzzing question is, why Ravana, who had access to all the three worlds chose the Asoka Vana for keeping her in prison. What was the reason behind this peculiar preference, when he had more secure places to keep her imprisoned. Now, if I go into that, we would be branching off into what is known as «§º¡¸ÅÉ¢¸¡ ¿¢Â¡Âõ in ¾÷ì¸ º¡Š¾¢Ãõ.
Therefore, either way, Hanuman had to search all over Lanka. He did not merely search. He practically scoured through the city. [/tscii]
Mr. Hari Krishnan,
Nice thought provoking posting … Thanks… My point is …. Hanuman was a highly intelligent thinker and with great presence of mind.. All his steps were measured and calculated :
1. While appearing before Sri Ram when he landed at Thandakarunyam, enquiring about Ram and in a very diplomatic way puts forth Sugrivaa’s plight and the bad treatment from Valee and immediately making the attention of Ram focus on Sugriva as a friend and Valee as a bad element. I would say that it was Hanuman who successfully established the relationship between Ram and Sugriva and paved way for Valee’s end. Infact Sri Ram himself will appreciate to Lakshmana that Hanuman is an ideal minister and counsel for a successful King.
2. Even after Sita , Hanuman wishes that there should be some message to Ravana and he choses the ransacking of Asoka vanam and proves his might before smartly absorbing Bramasthiram of Indrajit for few moments. He created panic on Ravana by that act
3. When he meets Sri Ram , knowing the anxiety of him, he starts with the words… Kanden Karpinukaniyay kangalaal… Probably , Hanuman thought that even that micro second of anxiety should not be given to Sri Ram and he chose Kanden as the first word
When such an intelligent person – Hanuman , could think for a moment that Mandodari may be Sita….
Dear HariKrishnan Sir
I heard the story that Rakshasha race people will have saliva flowing from their mouth from my grandmother. :-)
I thought that the "pancha kanya" in Hinduism also included Kunthi.Kunthi was granted boon to be kanya forever as she begets karnan before marriage and gets afraid.
Donno whether Sita was mentioned.Also, did Mandodari marry Vibishana after ravana is killed? is this mentioned in Valmiki Ramayana?
I know that tara marries sugriva according to Valmiki Ramayana but kambar shows her as an ascetic.I read your explanation about this in chennaionline that times changed as well as moral values.
when you have time,tell us about the Asokavani ka nyayam.
let us keep this thread moving.
panchakanyas:-
http://www.indianest.com/hinduism/panchkanya/pk01.htm
À¡Ä¡ƒ¢,
þó¾ì §¸ûÅ¢¸¨Ç «ÛÁý ÌÈ¢ò¾ ¬öÅ¢ø ¨¸Â¡ñÊÕ츢§Èý. «ÛÁý: Å¡÷ôÒõ ÅÉôÒõ ±ýÈ ¦ÀÂâø Òò¾¸Á¡¸×õ ¸¢¨¼ì¸¢ÈÐ. «øÄРŨÄò ¾Çò¾¢ø þí§¸ À¡÷ì¸Ä¡õ:
http://www.harimozhi.com/ListArticle...ngArticleId=26
Áñ§¼¡¾Ã¢¨Âô À¡÷òÐ º£¨¾§Â¡ ±ýÚ ÁÂí¸¢Â¨¾ì ÌÈ¢ò¾ Ţš¾õ:
http://www.harimozhi.com/Article.asp?id=234
þó¾ þ¼ò¾¢ø «ÛÁÛ째¡, º£¨¾ì§¸¡ º¢ÈôÀ¢ø¨Ä. Áñ§¼¡¾Ã¢ì§¸ º¢ÈôÒ. «ÛÁ¨É§Â ´Õ¸½õ 'º£¨¾§Â¡' ±ýÚ ¿¢¨Éì¸ ¨Åò¾ «Ç×ìÌ º¢ÈôÒ.
Å¡øÁ£¸¢ þáÁ¡Â½ò¾¢ø, þó¾ À¡¾¢ô§À¡Î «§º¡¸ ÅÉò¨¾ «¨¼ó¾Ðõ, ¯ñ¨ÁÂ¡É º£¨¾¨Âì ¸ñ¼Ðõ 'þÐ º£¨¾¾¡ý' ±ýÀ¨¾ò ¾÷ì¸ Ã£¾¢Â¡¸ ¬öóÐ ÓÊ×ìÌ ÅÕ¸¢È¡ý. (1) þÅÙ¨¼Â §º¨Ä ´Õ Àì¸õ ¿£Ç š츢ø ¸¢Æ¢ÀðÊÕ츢ÈÐ. (2) ¿¨¸ô ¦À¡¾¢¨Âì ¸ðÊ¢ÕìÌõ н¢Ôõ, þó¾ §º¨ÄÔõ ´§Ã Á¡¾¢Ã¢Â¡É Ũ¸¨Âî §º÷ó¾¨Å. (3) «ó¾ò н¢ þó¾î §º¨Ä¢ĢÕ󾾡ý ¸¢Æ¢ÀðÊÕ츢ÈÐ. (4) «ó¾ô ¦À¡¾¢Â¢ø ±ó¦¾ó¾ ¬Àýí¸û þÕó¾É§Å¡ «¨Å þÅû §Áɢ¢ø ¸¡½ôÀ¼Å¢ø¨Ä. (5) «ó¾ ¬ÀÃ½í¸¨Ç «½¢ó¾¢Õó¾ «¨¼Â¡Çõ þÅû ¯¼Ä¢ø ¦¾Ã¢¸¢ÈÐ. («¾¡ÅÐ Å¡î ¸ðÎõ þ¼ò¾¢ø ¦ÅÙôÀ¡¸ò ¦¾Ã¢Ôõ þø¨Ä¡, «ôÀÊ.)
±ýÚ þùÅÇ× ¾÷ì¸í¸¨ÇÔõ ¾ÉìÌò ¾¡§É ¦ºöÐ ¿¢ÚŢ즸¡û¸¢ýÈ ºÁÂò¾¢ø þáŽý ÅÕ¸¢È¡ý. Å¡ìÌ Å¡¾õ ¿¼ì¸¢ÈÐ. þÐ º£¨¾¾¡ý ±ýÚ ÓÊ×ìÌ ÅÕ¸¢È¡ý «ÛÁý.
MY DEAR ADMINISTRATORS AND MODERATORS...
THIS IS MY THIRD POSTING ... I AM NOT ABLE TO VIEW THE POSTINGS OF MR. HARI KRISHNAN.
PROBABLY ITS COMING IN TAMIL ??
PLEASE HELP ME OUT..
I wish to read all his last 3 postings
My god! Let not the progeny of Ravana sue you for libel! :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by viggop
She dropped dead on the body of Ravana, lamenting.
People get confused between the abduction of Ruma (wife of Sugriva) by Vali, and Sugriva's marrying Tara after his death. The custom according to Valmiki's version is for the race to marry a brother's wife, after his death. (Sugriva was a king for sometime, when Vali was 'believed' to have been killed by Mayavi. At that time, it has to be noted, Sugriva and Tara had no mariltal relations.)
Balaji,
May be the reason why you are not able to read my three posts is that I have written in them in Tamil (tscii). I prefer writing in Tamil, in a Tamil group. I would also suggest that the discussions may be carried on in Tamil from hereon.