The Golden Era of Dr.IR and Dr.SPB

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by app_engine

:-)

அது ஒரு கருத்து (read like gunA cassette Kamal) :-)

From my music listening POV, I can enjoy the whole 'rAsAththi manasila' on repeat for days nowadays.

OTOH, my hand reaches out involuntarily for the 'skip' button immediately after the prelude for 'rAkkammA kaiyaththattu'.

The rAsAththi genre has longer lasting power than rAkkammA genre, IMHO...

---

app - It is unfair to pass judgement just using one song. ( watching too much presidential debate?!!) Yes, there were great songs from some Ramarajan movies (EOP, Karagattakkaran etc), the overall result was IR's TFM output quality was deteriorating.

Thinking aloud, the success of "urban" ARR was to some extend a revolt against this "village" trend.

Vaasalile poosanip poo - my late grand mother's favourite song. Very catchy and ramarajan of those days had lesser powder lipstick on his face compared to
what we saw later and therefore even the video was nice to watch.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by genesis

Thinking aloud, the success of "urban" ARR was to some extend an revolt against this "village" trend.

---

IR worked in Ramarajan movies from 1986 to 93. During those period and also post 93, IR continuously involved in rural/urban based films featuring Satyaraj, Vijayakanth, Murali, Karthik, Prabu, Pandiyarajan, Kamal, Rajini..etc. Post 93, big and notable projects did not go often to IR. Thats how, IR's stamp was slowly fading out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jaiganes

Vaasalile poosanip poo - my late grand mother's favourite song. Very catchy and ramarajan of those days had lesser powder lipstick on his face compared to
what we saw later and therefore even the video was nice to watch.

---

:shock: :shock: :yessir:

Quite a slow long fading out this - i must say.. his detractors must be wondering why doesnt he go kapupt just like that..

That's an interesting analysis, genesis :-)

i.e.

1. IR was working with Ramarajan / Raj Kiran / Kasthuri Raja kind of guys, driving the urban TN-ers crazy who craved for better music
2. This contributed to ARR capturing the urban TN-ers and IR's fall
3. This whole phenomenon being the worst thing to happen to TFM

:wink:

(BTW, needless to say I mostly agree on 2 & 3 ; it does not matter if I agree on 1 or not. We both agree on majority of items :lol2:)

my 2¢..credit to Swamigal to churn out gems inspite of the talents he had to contend with..on bbc tamil interview still remember him chiding the musical sensibilities of directors in TFM when asked about Thendral Vandhu Theendum Podhu from Avatharam..no offense to Nassar what possibly he would have said of the song situation/placement which could have triggered him to come up with this gem. So the end result did justify the means with respect to working with supposedly lesser talents.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by app_engine

1. IR was working with Ramarajan / Raj Kiran / Kasthuri Raja kind of guys, driving the urban TN-ers crazy who craved for better music
2. This contributed to ARR capturing the urban TN-ers and IR's fall
3. This whole phenomenon being the worst thing to happen to TFM

[/i]

---

Just like I said, you have become very good debater even though there is not much logic.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wizzy

inspite of the talents he had to contend with..

---

That was his choice. But OTOH, he has given us amazing music working with even lesser talents in the early 80s.

Vaasalile Poosanipoo is a wonderful song. IR-folk version2 has its own charm. I would take that any day over any other folk music composed by other MDs during the same time period. Keep them coming App, looking forward to more such numbers from 90s as well.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by app_engine

I have a plan to start a PS thread in IR forum to post one song per week, with the posts entirely in Thamizh.

---

Why not English Saar?

'This is a page for TAMIL music' nu yaarum solla vendaam. Tamil-la weak-a irunthaalum some of us come here because we still love to hear tamil music :smile2: