Thanks captain :notworthy:
Ur list is also good :P , yeah u missed those legendary singers :(
Printable View
Thanks captain :notworthy:
Ur list is also good :P , yeah u missed those legendary singers :(
That is interesting, kb! :DQuote:
Originally Posted by kb
Till now, I am confused with this thread title.
If I have to list my TOP TEN CINE-PERSONALITIES, then I can't do justice to all those who contributed in serveral things like music, direction etc.
coz in most of our list, our favorite actor/actresses will swallow up considerable no. of positions.
so, till now I am unable to come to a conclusion reg this thread :(
Alien,
First of all my general opnion didn't target any particular hubber,especially you.I admit you win the arguement..I have no more arguements on this ..I realise my total misunderstanding on this topic and I admit people have a right to claim "Ajith is better actor than sivaji ganesan" or "Vaiyapuri is beter than Nagesh"..I am flattered..
Sorry guys for my mistake and I take my words back.
Caption,
No comments ..You rock!
It's not about top ten actors and we didn't comment Kamal is better than Sivaji. Please do READ the topic. It says top ten personalities, not best actor or best singer or whatever. Your hatred towards certain actors and people made you post it like the way you did. Please do tell me if anyone said Ajith is better than Sivaji? :evil: . Kamal is better than Sivaji :D .
That's good for you 8-) You don't need to comment about others. I think you did NOT read the title. Plz read it again. Thanks :notworthy: for admitting your mistake. I respect when people admit their mistakes 8-). It's a pity that some people act innocent in order to prove that they are smart.
Captain,
No comments again.
Pls continue to discuss on the topic.
Captain,
YOu could have made your post in a polite way. I think that was a bit rude.
Anyhow, let's stick to the topic.. plz. Sorry :D
Thirumaran,
Yours is an excellent post! :D
1.Ilaiyaraja
2.Ilaiyaraja
3.Ilaiyaraja
4.Ilaiyaraja
5.Ilaiyaraja
6.Kamalji
7. Kamalji
8.Kamalji
9.Kamalji
6.Bala (Director)
My list:
-------
I would prefer to avoid ranking the cine-personalities. So, I am just describing about them, things that I admire most in them
MGR
This person is one whom I rate a bit high interms of achievements. To my surprise, even now I can see many people in the village side workshipping him. That is the kind of influence and charisma he had. People believed as if they are getting their food only coz of MGR.
His approach to the challenges thrown at him and the way he handled them all are truly amazing. IMO, He was not only a REEL Hero but also a REAL Hero.. I have seen so many politicians, actors etc following his path / using his name just to get decent no. of seats in the elections.
I like this person for his
- BOLDNESS
- leadership qualities
- executive ability
- self-confidence
He never cheated atleast those who followed him. "இவரை நம்பி கெட்டு போனவங்கன்னு யாரும் கிடையாது. நம்பினவங்களை எந்த சூழ்நிலையிலும் இவர் கைவிட்டது கிடையாது."
eVEN at his worst times, He made a positive apporach and emerged as a clear winner.
Many songs in his movies not only cater to the masses but also have links to the social awarness themes. :thumbsup:
I am VERY surprised to see the likes of Dr.SPB and Dr.IR being missed out in the top 3 slots, Dr.IR the one who gave life to melodies, when Tamil listeners were listening to Hindi songs, he is PHENOMINAL in the MUSIC industry, ARR is also like this.
Dr.SPB having sung the MOST number of SONGS in the world, having the BEST evergreen VOICE of the ERA being missed again, he is NOT just the GREATEST SINGER THAT INFIA HAD EVER PRODUCED, he is also a
1) Producer
2) MD
3) Film Director
4) Dubbing Artist
5) Actor
Can some one tell me any OTHER personality who has done all of this??
raghu,
top 10 cine personalities ACC TO EACH OF THEM.
:roll:
some ppl feel SOME ACTORS have performed v. well which has outbeated all these :roll:
Nadigar Thilagam Shivaji Ganesan
---------------------------------------
Enna selva vukku shivaji pidikkumaa? (ipdai neraya per kekalaam).
He is one person who set the benchmarks for all aspects of acting. I also heard that he helped many actors / actresses on how they can show their unique style. A person who is beyong the horizon in acting in tamil cinema. If we like a person then there must be a reason for it or we must have the environment for that. I had the environment.
My elder brother(30+) is a SHIVAJI VERIYAR. It was he who gave me enough information about shivaji in the past. After that, I used to watch all his movies with him. when NADIGAR THILAGAM departed, he was crying for the whole day. :(
Ennaada.. MGR kku apuram shivaji sir ah poduraannu sila per puruvathai uyarthalaam.
IMHO, I rate these two people equally.
MGR Ruled the society and remained as the undisputed king
SHIVAJI sir Ruled the film world till the end. :thumbsup:
Apart from that, I like his
* Committment towards his profession (I heard that he will be in the sets even before the usual time)
* sincerity
* Straightfarword approach
"யாரை நம்பி நான் பொறந்தேன் போங்கடா போங்கன்னு மார்தட்டி சொன்னவருங்க இவர்"
"வீரபாண்டிய கட்டபொம்மன் நிஜத்தில் அப்படி இருந்தாரான்னு எனக்கு தெரியாது. ஆனா சிவாஜி சார்தான் வீரபாண்டிய கட்டபொம்மன் என்று சிறுவயதில் நினைத்ததுண்டு. நாங்கள் கட்டபொம்மனை பார்த்தில்லை ஆனால் எங்கள் நடிகர் திலகத்தை பார்த்ததுண்டு"
Sorry joe :oops: :cry: ..... I'm glad that u took ur words back :) ... but I'm really sorry , that I felt u was ridiculing me, bcos of Bhagyaraj's name or Vivek's name in my top 10 ... But I sincerely love these guys ... what to do ?? ..... I have huuuuuge respect towards Sivaji ganeshan or MGR or Rajni , but to be brutally honest I was a fan of these guys(K.bhagyaraj & vivek) the very day I started inclining towards tamil cinema ... (Actually they were reasons I grew my interest in tamil cinema)Quote:
Originally Posted by joe
We never said or never would say "------(fill in anyone's name) is a better actor than Sivaji" , but v enjoyed that person more .... Itz the generation gap .....
sorry if we had hurt ur feelings .....
thats why I had that prologue b4 my list !!!!
Jana machi !!
Nothing to get more serious on this. Joe brother will appreciate us for having given our opinions. :D
T. RajendarQuote:
Originally Posted by Raghu
K. Bhagyaraj
(very soon - Perarasu)
Yeah, we believe so :notworthy: .... I hope no grudge on captain or me :) 8-) ... V were just forced to tell our opinions ..... :)Quote:
Originally Posted by selvakumar
Kamal Haasan too has done almost all of these except MD ... And moreover he had done some excellent job as a writer ,Quote:
Originally Posted by Raghu
* Screenplay(Raaja paarvai, Dhevar Magan, Mahanadhi, Hey raam ,.....)
* Dialogues(Dhevar magan, hey raam, virumaandi,......)
too ...............
He had produced more films , more meaningful films :notworthy: (raaja paarvai, guna, dhevar magan, virumaandi, hey raam,........)
actually my point is that doing everything under the sun doesnt make one a top personalty. I see no one has nominated T Rajendar altho he has done all those and more.
Better to be master of one than jack of all......
Exactly my point .... :) ...... Actually SPB is a faint choice to be considered for that saying , .... I used KH , just to enforce him that there r people leaps and bounds ahead of SPB if considering multifaceted'ness alone ....Quote:
Originally Posted by NOV
My List:
1. Nadhiya
2. Rajini
3. Balachander
4. Ajith
5. ARR
6. Chitra
7. Vairamuthu
8. SBP
9. Shanker Mahadevan
10 Vivek
Even I like M.G.R for his positive approach, Nagesh ... & so many PPl but 10 per dhanaE solla mudiyum :cry:
Absolutely. I dont understans still what is the confusion with the thread title.Quote:
Originally Posted by NOV
I think i clearly said top 10 pesonalities of a particular individual's choice. But still people are worried abt certain names in several people's list. The title does not talk abt the Top 10 personalities of Tamil Cinema. A person's taste differ from others and it never remains the same all over your lifetime. It tends to change.
Who knows, after few years, I may put Vijay among my Top 10 personality. Either my taste could be changed to like the movies of his type or he may give movies of my taste. And there so much other factors will come into picture for making your choice.
Please avoid pointing other's choices as not a good one. :)
Kamal Hassan
I hope no one will be surprised with this choice (from selva's side :wink: )
---------
This person I love him more. I admire his activities. Even at this age, he can put a challenge to the young guys in doing LOVER BOY ROLES and Personality.
A sure ALL ROUNDER.. Ivarukku theriyaatha Cinema visayam irunda athu aacharyamthaan.
I like his:
-------
1. Acting :D
2. Dance
3. Direction
4. BOLDNESS >>>>>>> SANDIYAR will be a better term.. Summa oorla Ulla Arasiyal vaathigal ellarum vandu ethirthaalum KAMBA NIRPAAR avaroda decision la :thumbsup: :notworthy:
5. Open-minded approach
6. The way he helps others... >> Never let his friends down
"விழுவதேன்றாலும் விழுவேன் என் எதிரிகள் சுகம் காண"
"எழுவதென்றாலும் எழுவேன் என் நண்பர்கள் நலம் காண்"
7. Ivarudaya Rasigargala Kayyalum vidam vitthiyaasam.
"இவர்தான் ரசிகர் மன்றங்களை நற்பணி இயக்கங்களா மாற்றியவர்"
"இன்னும் இவர் முன்னால் போய தலைவான்னு சொல்லி பாருங்க, வருமே கோபம்"
8. One more Important Thing:
We never waste our money to the profession that we use to earn it. But this person will do..
"இவர் சினிமாவில் சம்பாதித்தை எல்லாம் சேர்த்து வச்சிருந்தா, இவர் பெரிய பணக்காரராக மாறி இருக்கலாம்" But he never did like that. He investes whatever he earned in cinema there itself. I am earning now.. I know the value of money. But not sure whether I will invest it back into my profession itself. Only kamal will do it. :thumbsup:
9. The kind of fans he has
"சமுத்திரம் பெரிதா, தேன் துளி பெரிதா"
"ஏன் தான் அது இவ்ர் தான்" :thumbsup:
"காசு, அரசியல் இப்படி எத்தனையோ ஆதாயத்துக்காக ரசிகன் மாறலாம்.. ஆனா இவர் ரசிகர்களை பெரிதாக எடுத்துக்கொள்ளா விடினும் இவருக்காக இருப்பவர்கள் இன்றும் உண்டு"
10. his respect towards arts:
He does ViruMaandi and Anbe sivam kind of films.. Anbe sivam kind of films cannot be done by a hero at this level. He acted like a middle aged person along with Maddy. Only he can do that :thumbsup:
Kamalhassan - தமிழ் சினிமாவுக்கு கிடைத்த இன்னொரு பொக்கிஷம் !
P.S: Ennaada ipadi ellam MGR, shivaji ah vida ezhuthurannu paarkaatheenga. My whole family is a KH family. Two of my uncles are in KAMAL NARPANI IYAKKAM, VIRUDHUNAGAR. Sinna vayasula avanga kooda paartha KH films neraya. Athaan !
Definetly not for atleast some people. For me too, there are so many left. You are free to put more names of your liking. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Arthi
Selva
Nice post :thumbsup:
No, thiru ....Quote:
Originally Posted by Thirumaran
NOV's was a righteous one .... He just wanted to say that SPB having tried all of those film making aspects doesn't make him a better one by any mean (If u look at raghu-ji's post, misinterpreting .....)...Hez indeed a better one in his singing , where he's an unparalleled master :thumbsup:
Hey,Quote:
Originally Posted by Alien
In my post only "Absolutely" was the reply to NOV. The rest of the point are common. Not for NOV :P
Of course I dont have any doubt regarding SPB's talent. You can see him in my list :D
:notworthy: :notworthy: :clap: .... wonderful post selva !! :P :PQuote:
Originally Posted by selvakumar
Thanks Joe. :notworthy:Quote:
Originally Posted by joe
Ok, ok... :P ... I don't have any doubt either , regarding SPB's talents(hez in my list too), just that I am an adimai to KJY's voice .....Quote:
Originally Posted by Thirumaran
But SPB having tried all film making techniques (unsuccessfully ) doesn't make him great, only his voice :notworthy: ... (This reply is to raghu-ji)
Nice Posts Selva on MGR, Shivaji and Kamal.
:thumbsup:
Thanks a lot Rajkumar, :D
Jana machi :D
Thiru anna > Your post was excellant.. Infact, I thot of making this thread in my current way.
Thanks a lot for opening such a thread to share our favoritsm. :D
Exactly, in that case KAMALHASAN should not be on the TOP list, it should be Dr. Shivaji GaneshanQuote:
Originally Posted by Alien
So if we are talking about just TALENTWISE not to do with politics, can some one EXPLAIN how MGR go into the list???
Can he act, can he speak properly? Oh Plsssssssss
Nov anNe,
T.Rajender is dubbing artists, I did not know that, : Shock:
If MGR doesn't deserve a place, then Rajini won't :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Raghu
I would like you to get back that particular comment. If you do not know any history please keep quiet.Quote:
Originally Posted by Raghu
This list talks abt people's interest towards cine personalities. That is it.
Captain,
MGR cant act cant speak properly, cant walk, he was really funny infront of Camera,
Rajni is FAR FAR FAR better actor than M.G.Ramachandran, many will agree with me on this
Raghu, I acutally would like to replace MGR with Rajini.Quote:
Originally Posted by Raghu
Rajini can't act, speak properly, can't walk and is funny infront of a camera.
Except Rajini fans no one will agree with you.
Thirumaran,
I am entitled to my view JUST like yours, MGR was a PATHETIC actor, he MAY HAVE BEEN A GREAT POLITICIAN, v r talking about CINE INDUSTRY , NOT POLITICS!!!
Thank you sir
I take my leave now,