Muthu is the biggest one, you forgot man !Quote:
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
Printable View
Muthu is the biggest one, you forgot man !Quote:
Originally Posted by Raikkonen
It Doesn't mean anything other than the pathetic situation Rajini is in.Quote:
Originally Posted by m_23_bayarea
He had Raja Score for his home production 'Ragavendra' and almost a directorial debut 'Valli'. [Rajini Wrote the Story, Screenpaly and dialogues for this movie.]. valli got released in 1993 after ARR's entry.
It is IR who started Rejecting Rajini's movies after 'Annamalai' produced by Kavithalayaa and IR was coaxed a lot to do 'Veera' for the sake of Panju Arunachalam. After that Rajini's attempts to Team up with IR had gone waste and he patched up the realtion just during 'Thiruvasagam' release.
Thats why for the Movies 'Chandramukhi' and 'sivaji' Both IR's and Rajini's fans had huge expectation of Them Working together again. Just before the team's announcement for Shivaji...Shankar was seen in IR's daughter Bava's Marriage function. (Mind it He had never attened any of IR's family functions before.) It shows how much effort Rajini is putting in to Team up with IR again.
But IR's Adamancy is well known :(
and I hope he comes out his shell and team up with all those like Manirathnam, Barathiraja, rajinikanth et all who are dying to do so
Perfetly agreed ARR maintains a good public relation :thumbsup: :clap: :clap: :clap:Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
Forgot the great musical 'Minsaara Kanavu' :?: :)Quote:
Originally Posted by narayanan
"How stupid was I explaining you the greatness of that khalbali's experimentation with a technically analysed link " -
Scale, Keep up your chauvinistic flag flying high.
We are definitely amused.
If you think I cared to even read your stupid , halfbaked
explanation for an insipid number like "kalbali",
you must be living in a fool's paradise.
"Kazhudhaikku theriyuma karpura vasana?. "- true confessions of a self realized soul . LOL!!!
MinsaaRA KaNavu.. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by narayanan
Oh yeah now remember :D Dont quite remember producers for each movie :roll:Quote:
Forgot the great musical 'Minsaara Kanavu'
Perhaps Padayappa, 'Vetrikodi Kattu' song atleast. 'Singanadai' and 'Minsara Poove' would follow.Quote:
People will hardly remember any songs from Baba or Padayappa in next 10 years
Baba is forgettable. 'Maya Maya' and 'Sakthi Kodu' were hearable not something that would remember 1/2 decades down the road.
Muthu was the first one, not the biggest. Padayappa defenitely would take the top spot, largely due to the way the movie delivered.Quote:
Muthu is the biggest one
wat's wrong with Khalbali song???it was an amazing path-breaking number :shock: :shock:Quote:
Originally Posted by thumburu
yea, I also love Khalbhali. may be it was too revolutionary or drastic for other ppl to digest!!
<dgn>
All songs in RDB are excellant..
It is an excellant album from ARR :D
RDB songs have become a way of life nowadays in many corporate environments :D
Everyday I am seeing people playing this album in the morning esp.. LOOSE CONTROL :clap:
</dgn>
Thumburu,
Not all like all genres of music right ? A song may be extraordinary in my taste does'nt need to be the same with you ? Any deal of explanation is'nt going to change either of ours' opinions on it right ?
:clap: :thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by narayanan
Likeability of a song purely depends on listeners age & mood (now he/she :roll:). How can a **+(age) old (not he) can comment about Khalbali arabic fusioned track. Lata M appreciates Vande Mataram better than her's, MSV appreciates Thottal remix. There is no necessity for them to come forward & appreciate these works which no where matches their era. These legends know the trade and what I can understand while reviewing a song/album one has to set the creator's/script mindframe and analyse personally. Have you watched RDB first & do you know how was it picturised. When you say Roobaroo & Paathshaala are ordinary that's your opinion but to term kalbali as narabali is ridiculous. :evil:
Damn, What am I doing explaining this "moonu kaalu muyalu" who is not even attempting to read what others has to say about it. Adamant!
Please don’t advice anyone here about HUB etiquette without you knowing even the fundamentals. kazhudhaikku theriyuma karpura vaasanai,Inspid, halfbaked, fool's paradise. I know you are musically sound but learn to appreciate other's work if cant leave positive, rectifying comments.
vidunga scale.....tension aagadhinga :D ......we need not prove that khalbali is great, as if it was not gr8 then y wud world-renowned Cheb Mami wud have sung in it....
Khalbali is the most popular song in my college.It is the most popular song in Bangalore.Kalbali rocks :thumbsup:
Scale,
agreed her words were'nt right. and just bcos Lata Mangeshkar appreciates it, does'nt mean I should too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramakrishna
beg to differ.. It is LOOSE CONTROL which is rocking Bangalore :thumbsup:
&
ofcourse. ROOPA ROOU.. :D
Whatever, on the whole RDB album rocks in Bangalore. :wink:Quote:
Originally Posted by selvakumar
Scale,
You are too rude in your reply to her... I can understand your situation.. But quoting that proverb and indirectly referring to them looks bad..
errrrr :twisted:Quote:
Originally Posted by Scale
Scale.. I just got the same feeling when some people who had great knowledge in music ridiculed GODFATHER ALBUM and attacked the movie indirectly
Rude Me! Where were you when said that earlier! :evil:
narayanan,
What? I do understand whats your point now. "Lata M is the nightingale of India" She & her sisters contributions towards indian/tamil music is something amazing & proud to be forever.
I can expect such things from thumburu.. But not from you.. Anyhow Leave it..Quote:
Originally Posted by Scale
<dgn>
Many people (whom u respect for music knowledge) ridiculed GODFATHER Album to the core.. and ofcourse the movie and their expectations.. Where were u at that time? Just curious. NO offense meant.. I am seeing this from many people.. who ridicule the album and compare it with parasuraam, etc
</dgn>
Selva,
Trust me, He is the most dignified hubber here. Most of his posts are eyeopener. Read his GF review again... He defended a lift-claim & genuinely points IR's song similarity. I have seen him several times, different topics postings solely. But he never crossed his limit like narabali, calling nick names against hubbers. He is the one who technically analysed every MD in the industry mostly neutrally.
END. :wave:
ramakrishna :evil: .....idhu theavaya......ellam nee start panna topicnaladhan.....unna paarka varuvenla appa paarthukkuran..... :lol:
:lol: :lol: :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
How about Thai Veedu? SG stole all the Hindi tunes from Bappilahari.
* What pathetic situation are you talkin abt ? I thought he got himself into a bad situation only after the flop of BABA ... Before that, he was still havin a great time ... Otherwise, the expectations for that movie wouldnt have skyrocketed that much !! :DQuote:
Originally Posted by rajasaranam
* I think you've put it exactly the other way round ... Rajini doesnt have to coax anybody to score music for his movies ... Even if VS does it, the album will still be a best seller for his own brand and image !! :notworthy:
* "IR's adamancy is well known" .. You said it !! :thumbsup:
* Again, BR, MR, and all who once used to team up with IR have found an equivalent if not a better subsitue in ARR !!! :clap:
In my opinion, any first movie for RK would be phenomenol for the any MD, coz I guess every director has a story line for RK and way they want to portray it, So expecting Muthu to be good is seriously no-brainer or Chandramukhi by VS for the matter of fact. If I can see consistency ( cannot talk about VS ), IR seems to have the edge. after churning out so many movies he always had the niche of differentiating RK's movie songs (poetic justice). In my opinion, ARR's first was good, padayappa ( i did not like it), baba (a couple of songs were good). Deva was consistently good for the 3 movies.
My vote will go to IR, followed by Deva, and ARR (with regards to consistency), but Sivaji could prove different for ARR as it is shankars movie. Wait and see would be a good thing. most suited-IR has the crown and the edge.
Iam one of the big fan of IR's music. I hv. a collection of almost all of his songs.
My views are that IR is a natural born genius. Not the one, who puts lot of brains into work like ARR. He does not do anything special for composing. It does come naturally from him and thats why he is gifted.
At the same time, he is not so good in dealing with people. and is very difficult person to move along. If he had used his brains, with his natural born talent, he would hv definitely conquered the world with his enchanting music.(unfortunately, he is foolish).
still, if IR joins hands with the likes of manirathnam, bharathiraja, rajinikant, we will be gifted with everlasting musicals.
Ennatha sollavaruringa.. ??Quote:
Originally Posted by Aravind_06
Rahid, Iam talking about Ilaiyaraja's adamancy in working with People like balachander, manirathnam, bharathiraja, rajinikant etc. If he can shed away this, we will get back his music treasure.
ada paavigala......neengalam thirundhave maatingala :lol: ....Quote:
Originally Posted by Aravind_06
no offence dude, i made that statement cos ARR's era is comin to an end, and u r talking abt IR's comeback.....dude, though IR is genius of genius he cant make half the number of songs hit that his son is making now,......times have changed drastically.....
well said MIL, i guess shivaji can break all this......i think this album should be the Best Ever Musical Album for Rajinikanth
That should be some album as the best ever musical album for rajinikanth happens to be rajathi raja and thalapathy....although im sure of ARR churning out excellent numbers for shivaji and give us another modern melody...to beat albums like thalapathy you need to have something out of the extraordinary in the orchestration and instrumentation of the songs.....well let us all await another musical from ARR with great pleasure...:D
U mean to say he doesn't use his brains while composing music??? Then he uses his kidney or what?Quote:
Originally Posted by Aravind_06
I dont understand one thing. Till ARR's entry he had gud character and had no problems with any directors and maintained gud relationship with them. After ARR became popular he completely transformed himself is it? U ppl say its only because of IR's character that the directors went for ARR. :?
As a fan of IR u should be happy that he is still composing music at this age. U have to accept that his happy days are gone and have to be satisfied with some gud music he gives now & then rather than dreaming for a comeback.
ansa that is true to a large extent......ppl. came to ARR bcos of IR's ill-treatment but they never left ARR bcos of his music/humility......BR,Shankar,KB all changed their MDs due to date/time issues and never bcos of ARR's arrogance/ bad music......got to say one thing, IR has a very witty tongue, he criticised his own son in his one-man show.......i really pity YSR from a son's point of view :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by ansa400
Hulk, be ready for a surprise, Shivaji is gonna be better than the best :wink: ....and u very well know ARR can spring earth-shattering surprises :D .....
Maddy are you getting ready for a defense by admitting that ARR err is coming to an end ? ARR can still dominate for 3 to 5 years .age is on his side
yes nakeeran, i really thought ARR was gone in TFM but now i think with shivaji,JOK,Godfather,sakkarakatti he will stay......dunno for how long :D .....he needs a hit like RDBasanti in Tamil...
quality wise,originality wise, ARR WILL NEVER BE GONE!!! unless bad luck strikes him and make all his movie & songs go flop,then only yes....but i will never say ARR is goin to an end,infact ARR is getting better now only....
Guys think positive.ARR after all will be working with top producers & directors who will be cautious in thier plans. no way the movie will fail .IMO ARR's funda are strong to sustain for another 5 years unless the tfm fraternity create a cou like what they did to IR
besides ARR is still a craze in Bollywood
ARR is at his peak in terms of creativity.......just look at RDB, he has played with almost all conceivable genres of music.....but he needs a HUGE hit in Tamil which will really shut all his detractors mouth (include mine as well here :wink: )