Comments on Outlook article & other TiS criticisms

Folks,
http://www.charuonline.com/kp143.html

This fellow has a personal grudge against Raja ! Statements like , "TiS sounds like BG Score for a movie like jurrasic park" speaks volumes of his "isai gnAnam" :-)

Shankar,
This guy doesnt stop with earning the wrath of IR Fans. Now, he has decided that he hasnt had enough of the brickbats so what's the next level? Why, bash ARR, ofcourse. Apparently, Manirathnam movies are nothing but a young chap wooing young girls with "music lifted from Sufi or Arabic sources by ARR" in the background. (words in quote charu's)

Now, Maddy & co,. there is a worthy for you to direct your bile upon.
(Tamizh padikka varuma?).

why do you guys bang your head over Charu's opinions? I would be more upset if I read reviews like that from someone who has atleast a smattering of music. There are better reviews from bloggers online.

vijayr, absolutely. I dont care a hoot what Charu, or even a discerning blogger says about music I like.
But this guy is fun to read.It's like watching those vijayakanth movies - and the viewer making comedy scenes out of intended action scenes :-)

vijayr,
As raj has mentioned, i had a big laugh after reading it and thot I will share this with dfers...You guys might want to read another piece called "yAsikkirEn" where he compares his "poverty" with Barathi's !!! Soooper comedy !

poor charu!!! aiyoo paavam, he could not even distinguish his intellectual, musical poverty to the material kind which Barathi suffered.

I have read excerpts of his novel "zero degree", he's a pervert !! If you have doubts, you can check his website, there's a chapter, and you decide yourself what kind of a person this guy is.

Thiruvasagam & Brahmins
---------------------------------

A dialog between me and a audio shop owner (before 40 days)

i: How was sales of Thiruvasagam sir
o: Super sales, even after one month of release it is selling
i: It is a huge success
o: But we can't listen this in temple, Ayyars did not like this
i: i didn't know but it is very nice to hear and it give a sprit experience while listening without any disturbance
o: May be, but Ayyars blames this album


Thuklak Q & A section by Cho Ramaswamy

q: How is thiruvasagam.
a: There is no interest on this album. I feel it looks like a chiristian song.


A dialog between me and my friend (when i listening Thiruvasagam)

f: what is this
i: Thiruvasagam
f: IR is doing often like this and he is earning lot of money
i: He is not a money minded people. Tell if you know Raja otherwise not
f: But brahmins will ignore this.
i: who care about brahmins (with little angry)



Dear friends,

What do you think about this. Some of you could be a brahmine.

Sanjeevi,
I think it's baseless to generalize like this.Anything out-of-the-box will have resistance.Let's say,if IR reworks christian songs in the kanda Shasti kavacham or any other Hindu religious tune,will it will be welcomed with open arms?

Can anyone dream of meddling with quranic verses?

Those three brahmins were just expressing their opinion,no one has started any agitation against IR right?

So why crib&most importantly bring in their caste into it.Are you saying there are no Hindu's(belonging to diff caste)who have not liked it.

What about Kamal hassan,Sujatha,Bala Murali Krishna who have expressed their admiration for it?

Assuming the above mentioned ppl were saying good words for effect,

In this hub too myself,Shankar,tmrrmt,A_A,Jaiganesh are some of the brahmins who have liked TiO&we have no need to please IR :D

Stop this Brahmin bashing plz.

Sorry Cinefan

I like brahmins and I have gr8 respect to them. But some of them especially older generations don't like to come out their circles, IMHO. However, also it is common to all caste, all religion communities. BTW the last person is not a brahmin.

And another matters with tamil christian songs. I've listend many songs (veru vazhi illamal - a friendly comment don't take serious christian friends) during my college hostel life. I think, tamil christian songs has 80+% IRish always (heavily inspired by IR). So, some people may think TiO as like christian songs. It is not IR fault.