ARR Vs YSR Vs HJ

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Music4Ever

A good yardstick would be who has produced more number of memorable hit music in the last five years. It will be a close call between ARR and HJ, IMO. Of course, career-wise ARR wins. The following are ARR's hits during this period

1) Kannathil Muthamittal
2) Boys
3) KangaLal Kaidhu sei
4) New
5) Kadhal virus
6) Enakku 20 unakku 18
7) Aayitha Ezhuthu

Did I leave anything out? Of the above only Boys was a memorable hit. New and Aayitha ezhuthu may have done well. KKS, although nice, was not that popular among masses, IIRC. Maybe I am wrong.

For Harris, in the same period we have

1) MinnalE
2) 12B
3) Kaaka Kaaka
4) Lesa lesa
5) Gajini
6) Anniyan
7) Chellame
8) Ullam kEtkumE
9) Saami

and may be a few more. Most of the above are big hits (If not at the same level of Boys, at least better than other ARR hits barring perhaps New.).

---

so ur point is???? :lol:

well, according to this week Kumudam, HJ is leading atleast in one area. He has his studio equipped with "DG Design D control" tech. Only two studios in Asia have this tech, one in Japan, another one in HJ's studio.

How come Vidhyasagar who gives a steady stream of melodies is left out of this rat race?

"so ur point is????"

Need I stress that? Look at the title of this thread!

"How come Vidhyasagar who gives a steady stream of melodies is left out of this rat race?"

Someone should correct the title then :) Seriously, VS makes good melodies, but so does IR even after so many decades. I think the music of the three mentioned in the title captures the imagination of youth, at least those who post here, more than VS.

Whether Dinesh likes it or not, HJ is now a serious threat to any MD.

haahahahah....music4ever...enjoy while it last... ;) ... hj songs were never quality to stick in the race.... he just can churn out hit songs which will b 4gotten after sometime... its the truth even if M4E likes it or not ... :lol: YSR songs r far more quality... listen to Theenda Theenda - TI ... a song which hj cant think of... listen to that !! its a gem!

Dinesh, you need to come out of your ARR only mindset. Look at the thread "Five best songs of Harris" to understand that there are several hits of HJ which are not forgotten as you claim. I am not the only poster there, if you understand what I mean :wink:

just checked it... couldnt help remembering its original song... :lol: ofcource it can be remembered thanks to the original... :lol: :lol: :lol: take it cool man... enjoy yr hj song...and its time for me to enjoy GF songs !!! Innisai is amazing !! this is wut i expect from ARR !! :D

"just checked it... couldnt help remembering its original song... ofcource it can be remembered thanks to the original..."

Come on, don't be such a hard person to please! Those songs listed as five best by many are indeed very memorable. Every MD imitates some song or other (In fact, I can specify a devotional song from which the Gentleman song "en veetu thottathil" was inspired, and there are many more.), so instead of nitpicking give credit when the album becomes a hit.


" take it cool man... enjoy yr hj song...and its time for me to enjoy GF songs !!! Innisai is amazing !! this is wut i expect from ARR !! "

GF songs are good too. I am enjoying all of them now. Let's wait for Vattaiyadu velayadu, its likely competition :wink:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Music4Ever

GF songs are good too. I am enjoying all of them now. Let's wait for Vattaiyadu velayadu, its likely competition :wink:

---

Not at all. KSR is not the best director to extract songs. We know about Gautham and add KH factor to it. The biggest expectation for this year is VV and if HJ meet the expectaion, it will be close to Boys (still Boys lead all the way in recent tfm years)

As per thread title ARR vs YSR vs HJ is now GF vs PP vs VV ?