Printable View
Yes. Definetly i am new in the forum. Other than that i was not interested in searching on what you said. I have other works too. But you are a king in that. Waiting for the time to point some mistakes comparing one post with other though you fails. So better get those posts and give me the link. I will try to go through that.Quote:
Originally Posted by stranger
I know definetly u will do as you were somehow wanted to pull my leg at any cost.
Anyway see you after some time...
Bye for now.
Thiru... Let me take only two points here.Quote:
I am leaving other technical areas. Is not dance, fight are part of acting department. If we need to take Raja movies where sword fight may come, can shivaji excel in that?
If we need to take a movie on a dancer with dance also coming, can shivaji do that?
Firstly, today's dances and sword fights or any other fights in Tamil or all other movies are being choreographed by seasoned and qualified specialists these days than older days. Have you ever thought of the evolution of direction, scrip-writing, and choreography from the past to the present? Also, singing. I just cant digest how you could compare Shivaji and Kamal, both lived in totally different periods in time and totally different lifestyles as well my dear forget about the technical advancements.
Secondly, Shivaji is not with us to prove any of our arguments right or wrong by acting or fighting or dancing once again. So, I think all our arguments against him would be completely futile similar to that of talking to the winds. Dronacharya in acting of Tamil cinema is Shivaji Ganesan. Cheers!
VK Narayanan,
There is no need for Shivaji to prove he is a good dancer/fighter now. He could have done in his days itself.Quote:
Secondly, Shivaji is not with us to prove any of our arguments right or wrong by acting or fighting or dancing once again.
Of course the technical advancements is much higher nowadays.Quote:
Thiru... Let me take only two points here.
Firstly, today's dances and sword fights or any other fights in Tamil or all other movies are being choreographed by seasoned and qualified specialists these days than older days. Have you ever thought of the evolution of direction, scrip-writing, and choreography from the past to the present? Also, singing. I just cant digest how you could compare Shivaji and Kamal, both lived in totally different periods in time and totally different lifestyles as well my dear forget about the technical advancements.
Do you think the dances he performed in SKV, Salangai Oli, etc and the fight sequences he did in Kakki Chattai, TTT, Enakkul oruvan etc were good only because of technical advancements?
Definetly we cannot compare two persons from different generation due to life different life styles. I was also origininally not interested in that. But certain basic things remain same in different generations.
Well said. No doubts. I also was saying similiar things only. That Kamal is the follower of Shivaji.Quote:
Dronacharya in acting of Tamil cinema is Shivaji Ganesan. Cheers!
If shivaji is Dronacharya then Kamal is like Karnan/ Arjuna.
I initially said only one thing. Kamal followed the foot steps of Shivaji and achieved more heights than Shivaji. I still dont understand what was wrong in that statement. Did karnan/ Arjuna did not reach more heights than Dronacharya. Did you not reach more heights than your father. Always there is a possiblity of next generation to achive more things than the previous generation.
That is what i meant with my statement. Then people started bashing me for that statement.
I definetly feel more prouder for Shivaji since he is the one among the responsible person for Kamal's greater achivements.
:thumbsup:
deleted as it is irrelevant here. :)
Thanks Stranger,
As expected you have posted something for me. However i have given some points on the inspiration stuff already in my post. However for the sake of yours, I will definetly post more on this stuff some other day. I am really tired of posting big replies today.
Take care,
Have a nice week end.
I see some desperate RK fans here, trying to pull Kamal down by comparing him with Shivaji in comedy and action roles :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: .........Sorry Shivaji HC fans(Joe, tacinema, VKNarayanan) if I hurt ur sentiments !Quote:
Originally Posted by Thirumaran
I very well accept Shivaji is best in acting ! But as a complete personality Kamal is the best !
8-)
Stranger,
Just browsed through some of the pages in that thread. In that thread itself there are lots of apt reply.
So why are you concerned in a reply from me.
Thanks for understanding.
bye
That thread was taken over by closed-minded KH fanatics and tried to change the "color".
But I dont give a damn about anybody's jdgment because I have a brain of my own.
Views change over the time but NOT THE FACTS.
One thing I can never stand is Taking credit for someone else creation> That is me :)
Then why the hell you like Rajini. He was very much inspired by MGR type movies. Also he was was much inspired or a copy of amitabh. Why not he keep in the credits of his several older movies as Rajini(Copy of Amitabh)Quote:
Originally Posted by stranger
:lol:
I think you like vijay too. No need to say that he copies Rajini.
:lol:
Chalo. Signing out for the day.
Bye....
Even in Chandramukhi, RK & P.vasu had such a hard-time in accepting that it was a lift/copy of MC :lol: :lol: ....I don't think it was yet credited in the movie , same goes to a lot of RK's 80's movies.....What do u say for that? :roll: