:rotfl2: :rotfl:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Printable View
:rotfl2: :rotfl:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
Mani and ARR are like Man and money, respectively..... :wink:
apart from kamal in that list, all others are arguably mani's products only......ash no doubts - is a mani product, how many ever ":lol2: " icons we get.....
I was not questioning on that. The reason why I laughed was - Even after acting in Iruvar, she was criticised for looking like a DOLL on screen. But BW's claims are :lol: Correct me if I am wrong. Mani might have given her a debut in one of his *good* films (though we share a diff of opinion on the film :wink: ).Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
I am 100% sure that you will agree with me on this :wink: Even after Iruvar, she was criticized and I am still clueless on how she became successful in Bollywood :shaking: :rotfl:Quote:
her talent was noticed and she went places after that before things came a full circle
and In GURU, she was good :)
She looked like a "Doll" in Iruvar, and the role was structured like that, but in her other (in many ways "opposite") role (as Kalpana), she was really obscure that she ranges from being innocent to manipulative to even solicit! But I agree with Selva that this film hardly elevated her, she was always treated as a show pony, before SLB's films and "Taal". Personally, I find her more digestable in her tamil films (Iruvar and KK) than in her hindi films (exceptions like Guru, Raincoat happen) From JA's trailer, Ash looks vibrant and fresh, which is a good thing!
Also try catching her bengali film, "Antar mahal". Ghosh knows to extract a good performance..
You mean 'Chokher Bali'. I haven't seen it though. But, 'Antar Mahal' is a superb watch.Quote:
Originally Posted by thilak4life
Yeah "Chokher Bali", "Antar mahal" came later, and yeah, it has no Ash.Quote:
Originally Posted by equanimus
so, kamal and ash out of the list........next--> madhavan was pretty famous as soon as ghar jamai and Sea hawks serials came in 90's.....he was a heartthrob by then.......he was very popular........so, he just benefitted from AP a bit and cant call him a maniratnam product........also, its kamal who has given him excellent roles like A.Ars and samayakkara maama :clap: ........so madhavan is not a maniratnam product :D
preity zinta's first movie was soldier and not Dil se as ppl. think.....so she is also out of the list :D
Abhishek bachan acted in 10 odd movies b4 doing Yuva.....how can he be in the list :D
his assistant directors are so waste that - they are not fit to be considered a contribution :D ....his protegees - manoj was introduced by BR, Sidarth was famous after Rangdebasanti, and Karthi is a paruthiveeran boy - they cant be MR's credits
:D
a.r.rahman too, got a break in roja but he really became famous after Gentleman - chikku bkku rayile song.......he became a household name after muqabla song........he bcame a national favorite after rangeela......his international fame was due to ALW...... :D
Mani hasnt contributed much - let him better get back to drawing board.... :lol:
:notworthy:Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
MR kitta kaetu paarunga, Ithai thaan solluvaar, u reflect MR :lol2:
:notworthy:Quote:
Originally Posted by Thirumaran