:rotfl:Quote:
Originally Posted by P_R
Printable View
:rotfl:Quote:
Originally Posted by P_R
yEn...Acid oothiruvEnnu mirattureengaLA ?Quote:
Originally Posted by Scale
Plagiarism on detail and the list of your movies shall be discussed later.
che.. che... antha effecta sonnen.
Okay fine.
Actually I was not sure what are the movies I listed and went back and checked :oops:
For those of you who are - for some reason dicated by your best judgement- closely following this discussion:
Quote:
Originally Posted by [url=http://www.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic.php?p=2094843#2094843
Quote:
Originally Posted by [url=http://www.mayyam.com/hub/viewtopic.php?p=2094851#2094851
PR,
Humble request :wink:
ellorukkum therinja vishayam thaan I will add some more. For now I would like to be a viewer and safeguard this thread.
indha dakaaltilaam enga kitta vendaam..Quote:
Originally Posted by Scale
tell us the movies that u mention as plagiarised!..or else let the moderators close the thread..
Frankly, it's quite stunning to see someone consider an inconsequential song like "kalyANam pAru" a serious flaw in 'uthirip pUkkaL.' This is a classic case of what's one of my pet peeves about how superficially many "serious" film-watching audience access Tamil/Indian films. The near-obsession with a "seamless" narrative devoid of "interruptions." (I'm borrowing the expression from a famous book on Indian Cinema called 'Cinema of Interruptions,' for obvious reasons.) On the surface, it might appear rather reasonable, but it is anything but that. One only has to examine the immediacy with which the 'lapse' is pointed out to realise that the very idea originates from the whole Hollywood project, i.e. wanting to see/make films like the Hollywood. No "unnecessary" songs, comedy or fight sequences, and the film automatically sublimates (so to say).
I don't even mean to argue along the lines of how they could be put to good use in a film; or how good filmmakers have to use the popular mainstream idioms to make the kind of films they want to make and so on. My question is much simpler. Yes, it is there, interrupting the flow of the narrative. What now? What's that "ideal" film that one looks forward to see, that makes one place a criticism of this sort on a film like 'uthirip pUkkaL?'
No its not inconsequential, outlandishly silly! The sibling (whose sister just passed away) and you sing, sing, sing a song as "pee pee pee....kalyaanam paaru appaavoda kalyaanam paaru" to a 3-5 year old neices. Now vijayan is hurried to get married is understandable will you be too. One more perusus songs was there which doesnt annoy me. Quiet prevailing, when you have such occassions. If MM has heroism UP has Mahendran/Raaja's slipover in this song.
Oh, Equa Thats a Classic jump just for the sake of defending anything fret out downright silly! Didnt expect from you.
Why would Jai or app_e remain unsounded ?
Hollywood is a ketta vaarthai to use to diss but let me dare anyway.Quote:
Originally Posted by equanimus
Lipsynching is almost always compromises 'reality' - illaiyA ?
Sure peygaLai nambAdhE did in four minutes what would have taken twenty minutes without it. But I'd've preferred some other workaround.
I am petulantly bothered by these questions. naan sirithaal is just fine for me, but nila adhu vaanathu mElE - is not fine for me. And so on...