Black Friday's docu feel might be because of strict adherence to the investigative process involved and lack of filmsy elements at any level, especially in character development.Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
Printable View
Black Friday's docu feel might be because of strict adherence to the investigative process involved and lack of filmsy elements at any level, especially in character development.Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
HKA is in English (Indianized and easily understood), and very less of Hindi dialogues (even so, they are easily understood).
ipdi pArkka Arambichu naduvula puriyalannA Shift+Del Ayirum.. pala muRai apdi Ayirukku.. adhAn bayappaduREnQuote:
Originally Posted by kid-glove
Luck by Chance
Liked all performances
Rishi Kapoor, Farhan Akthar, Konkona and Hrithik.
Even Dimple and Isha Shravani were good.
Juhi ellAm pOna thadavai close-A gavanikka vittuttEn. :clap:
On Hirani vs Chetan Bhagat
I dont admire Sudesa kaamugan(tip:Feeyaar) much but he has taken the pains(presumably) of re-reading FPS, and a detailed analysis on FPS vs 3I.
I agree with him when he says these:
Quote:
The ‘Work for Hire’ is a generic clause that negates all contribution from the writer and transfers ownership of the idea to the producer and the work is treated as commissioned. Bhagat unwittingly signed a contract with this deadly clause that now leaves him helpless.
Thats snazzily put. Bravo, mOnE Sudesaa!Quote:
There’s what you can do legally and what you have to do morally. Especially, when you teach us moral science lessons film after film.
And this:Quote:
Hirani has fallen in my eyes. If this can happen to one of the most popular writers in the country, then imagine the plight of the lesser known.
Well said!Quote:
Hirani and Co ought to learn from Vishal Bhardwaj who credited a rather unknown Cajetan Boy for just the idea of Kaminey right at the beginning of the film and even named a character after the screenwriter he met at a seminar.
I remember Udhiri PookkaL having credit to Pudhumaipithan much before anything else in the titles just after the acting cast. Now, I havent read it but I have read that "sitrannai" is just one small strand of udhiripookkaL.Quote:
I find it hard to believe that a guy like Aamir Khan who spends hours researching his look for every film and goes to insane levels chasing perfection hadn’t read Five Point Someone before he agreed to do the film, much before the script was ready.
Introspection point for Hirani, Chopra and Khan:
"avan manusan. nI manusanA?"
all these controversies were part of contract to hype up the sales of that book........in press meets, Hirani was repeatedly saying "if you have doubts, read the book and come back" :lol2: .......its a publicity for the film as well, the way VVChopra slammed journalists reg this and how there was coverage for this item in news channels for 2 days - it all sounded so phony and unbelievable........
how many of us, who liked 3Idiots, are going to read the book and spit on Hirani's lie?? this "controversy drama" is worth a risk for hirani-bhagat......sudish kamat has done his part by playing into the hands of their "deal to create controversy" :lol: ...thanks Plum, for keeping interest on this film alive here :thumbsup:
Arnab Goswami once came on tv about some issue screaming as usual. He said "why is this issue being publicized ??"
ngoyyAla, ippo nee enna paNNikittu irukka ?
avan onnu pesa aarambippaan - naduvulaye adha marandhuduvaan :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by P_R
ippa dhaan slumdaak millionare credits paathen - Vikas Swarup is credited right after simon beaufoy and producers........"based on novel "Q&A" by Vikas Swarup"........hmmm, sevappa irukkravan nallavana dhaan iruppaanda
PR, have u watched SDM??
Maddy, the issue is not about 3I or Hirani . It is about credit to writer. The pertinent point is how do you credit the writer? To suggest that Khan and co engineered this controversy in collusion with Bhagat is laughable.
1) If that is true, it shows they didn't have confidence in their film, then? Well, well, well.
2) This does nothing much for the movie or the book. Just like Vikas Swarup's Q&A got republished with "now an oscar winning movie", that got the necessary publicity. If you are saying Aaamir Khan and co engineered this controversy, you are really saying he indulged in a cheap trick. I think you'd not want to say that - no?
Anyway, Hirani and VVC have previous in this and for once, Sudesan has done his research and put forth his allegations logically.
Funny thing is Khan fans have a lose-lose. Support him, and you are really supporting the lack of credit to writer; try to wash it as publcity stunt, then your hero comes across as a cheap trick chupramani.
Chetan Bhagat may not be a great writer, and FPS may not be a great book but what Hirani etc did here was reprehensible and shows their attitude towards writers. Point is if a popular author can meet this fate, what about lesser known ones?
Few years back, a composer sued the Roshans and kiruthigai compromised his case by presenting in the court that "Rakeshji is heart patient so he should not be punished/penalised". In effect he admitted guilt but was just pleading for reduction in punishment on compassionate grounds The composer whose work they had stolen got compensation. That was a good beginning to expose plagiarism in Bollywood but unfortunately, that is a 1 in a million case.
The quality of bollywood films should not blind us to their personal faults.
We wish Thalaivar himself does better in these aspects! :(
Hiranandani muzhiye seriyilla :x
:rotfl: Lage raho-kke neraya accusations vandhudhungaQuote:
Originally Posted by Bala (Karthik)
Plum, i found it all very phony - why did chetan raise issue after 1 week or so etc.......Aamir khan mela ellam enakku onnum perusa idhu illa - he had sidetracked amol and i felt sorry for amol..........
i do cringe at 'chupramani' type of name calling but i will even if its directed at surya.....
http://www.bollywoodhungama.com/news/2010/01/23/13692/
happy that finally Arjun Rampal is getting recognised :clap:
:clap:Quote:
award for the Best Popular Film has gone to Dibakar Banerjee's Oye Lucky! Lucky Oye!
who is best MD?? 2008 - rahman was the best, aana kudukka maattanga, he has exceeded his quota :D or Amit for Aamir? :bluejump:
Arjun Rampal-A? Maddy, he in your list? :roll:
yes, i liked his performances in Moksh, om shanti om, rock on and i see you - he has a good screen presence........i donno if he deserves a NA and all for that...... :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Plum
Yes. But puk ellAm padichchadhillai. Essentially Indian writing in English oru allergy. adhulaiyum best seller double allergy. PodhuvA dead authors book mattum dhaan padikkiradhu.Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
indhiyAvulEyE indha padam naan mattum dhaan pArthEn nu ninaichEn :lol2:Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
இந்த மதுரை பந்தல்காரன் படத்துக்கு தொடர்ந்து அவார்ட் எனக்கு சுத்தமா பிடிக்கலை :x
Btw appo Priyangavukku 2008, 2009 back to back awards-A ?
Bollywood-ku ivvaLo award-A ? Plum seekiram ban aayiruvaar-nu edhirpaakkuREn.
:lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by P_R
:lol2: Adoor, Aravindan range 'kku ivar officially oru National Award director AyittArunnu nenaikkumpOdhu en nenju padhaRudhu...Quote:
Originally Posted by P_R
:lol: Avarta solli, "Jury" nu oru padam edukka solli ellaaraiyum kizhi kizhi nu kizhikka sollanum.Quote:
Originally Posted by equanimus
:rotfl:Quote:
Originally Posted by AravindMano
Vadivelu: kambeni ragasiyam ellam veliya solladhaaadaa (in a pleading tone) :lol:
Fashion ellam - shabba :( ......now she wont get it for kaminey :x
Mahi Gill next year
adibumbai udaichudhukku oru award urudhi
kadhavu?? total area damage :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by P_R
if i were jury i would let DevD sweep all awards except for best screenplay to kaminey
adhAn moderator-ku envelope koduthA thappichuralAmAmE?Quote:
Originally Posted by P_R
(andha cheque anuppichanE, cash AchA kanfaarm paNNunga :lol:)
Madhurai Pandhalkaaran yaaru nu velanga konjam neramaachu :lol:
enakkU innum doubt - dhAdikaaran dhAnE?Quote:
Originally Posted by Bala (Karthik)
Madhur Bhandarkar thaadi vechiruppara :roll:
Ennamo thappu nadandhurukku. Thaadikkaarar nahi.
i thot it was straight forward*
மதுரை = Madhur
பந்தல்காரன் = Bhandarkar
:roll:
*if i find it straight forward, then vera edhavadhu dhaan irukkum :P
oh modhalla Feeyaar avarukku madurai pandaaragannu pEru vechAru so I got confused.Quote:
Originally Posted by MADDY
idhula sasikumar subramanyapurathula Edho pandhal adhu idhunnu konja nEram OttuvApla. So, madurai +pandhal sErthu Sasikumar-Onu nenaichuttEn :-)
கலைப்படைப்பு என்றாலும் கலைச்சொல் என்றாலும் அர்த்தப்படுத்திக்கொள்வது வாசகர்கள் பருப்பு.
அடப்பாவிகளா தமிழிலும் இந்த விளையாட்டை ஆரம்பிச்சுட்டீங்களா :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by P_R
pulikutty senthil: idhu enga section, naanga englees-la vilayaduvom, tamil-la vilayaduvom, french-la vilayaduvom - adha ketka neenga yaaru - naanga periya edam :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by Sanjeevi
[url=http://www.desipundit.com/baradwajrangan/2010/01/23/review-veer/Baradwaj cant get himself to trash even Veer[/url]
Well, indhi-la enna kuppai vENA pAppAr pOlirukku...
avaroda top10 favorite movies of the decade-la "Devdas" (not Devd) irundhudhu paathela?? :lol:
the fact that he found some creative vision and something essentially vintage in Ajabpremkigazabkahani has really punctured his credibility in my eyes :(
thitti dhaanE ezhudhi irukaapla
"Unadulterated tripe" -ai vida oru nEsanal neespaper-la eppidi ezhudha mudiyum ?
Ajay Atul enna kulam,gothram? Marathi nu theriyeen but DevD, Dilli 6-a vida nallava music pottaaru?
Yeah, these NA are strictly N.A but irundhaalum oru GK ku ketten
Oi DevD, Dilli 6 ellAm 2009-nA.
indha awards 2008-ku aakum.
Ajay Atul sEmbil: http://www.dhingana.com/search/ajay-atul/songs-music
neengallAm kEttuttu sollunga.
Naan Kadavul is a 2009 release. Ennappa kuzhappureenga :confused2: If this is based on date of Censor certificate, then when did Delhi 6 got it?
appadiye irundhalum 2008-la
Amit:
Aamir - andha grunge rock number, sufi number ellam :(
A.R.Rahman:
Ada
JTYJN
Jodha Akbar
Yuvraaj