8-)Quote:
Originally Posted by groucho070
Printable View
8-)Quote:
Originally Posted by groucho070
I really do not know how many people here have known this. As per awards chairman (Bengali, I don't remember the name) Hey Ram was voted for best picture and best director for the national awards. Because of political compulsions they were not given to them. Here is my take on Hey Ram. Except for Kamal's controversial discussions about the God in that movie, it is easily one of the best of Kamal's if not the best of Kamal.Quote:
Originally Posted by kid-glove
Ah didn't you know that I change my choices depending on the weather.Quote:
Originally Posted by P_R
Just kidding. (better to mention explicitly :D )
i don think he went overboard in that, atleast it did not stick out of the characters dialogues.Quote:
Originally Posted by tamizharasan
Quote:
Originally Posted by tamizharasan
The chairman was Girish Kasaravalli(acclaimed Kannada director whose almost every film picks up a NA).
It's true that he is on record stating that according to him it deserved the best film and best director awards also but since the other members of the jury did not agree,it was not given.
On a side note,the awards have been devalued somewhat with Anil Kapoor winning for Pukar,Saif for Hum Tum,Priyanka Chopra and Kangna Ranaut for Fashion.There might be other such howlers which i have missed.
That year the best film was vanaprastham and best actor was Mohanlal, right ?
:? Which ones are you referring to?Quote:
Originally Posted by tamizharasan
To me one of the interesting parts of the characterization is to show that Saket Ram is still progressive (அட வாயா... மாமா தான் இல்லையே) and continues to be a skeptic (இங்க யாருமே ஸ்வயமா பேசறா மாதிரி தெரியலையே....என்ன பிசாசு பேச வைக்கறதுங்கறேள், உங்களை என் மாமா தரப்போற காசு பேச வைக்கறதுங்கறேன் நான்). Even though he subscribes to some form of Hindu cultural oneness which he feels is under attack.
He does not suddenly become an unquestioning religious fundamentalist. When his existence and future in a secular (as in irreligious, not the Indian meaning of the word :-) ) existence is challenged by a horror, he seems to plunge back to the familiarity of his roots. Here religion, caste, family, way-of-life are all one indistinguishable lump. To think of them independently is largely not possible in our context. In a way Saket returns to what he then thinks is his identity.
When he tries to sever himself off all these then the basis of his 'culture' is itself on this ice. He has to come to face to face with the antagonism that propelled him in this direction. And one show of horror, the horror that he had almost himself perpetuated, is enough to shock him back to act in accordance with his true nature. Restores his basic sense of balance - which is perhaps more fundamental to his identity than he had previously imagined.
That is what makes Hey Ram very engaging. Saket the fundamentalist is NOT caricatured. He is shown to be doing exactly what most people would turn to in such a situation, and thus we truly follow his journey.
:thumbsup: surely deserved NAs..but if it was vanaprastham..then theriyale...cos i have heardlal was mindblowing in thatQuote:
Originally Posted by P_R
I easily prefer Hey! Ram to Vanaprastham as a film. As a performance, I think Lal deserved to win. Kamal was excellent in Hey! Ram* but I suppose it'd harsh on Lal, who already should have won for his performance in Iruvar. I hope he wins one more and joins Kamal and Mammootty. :)
*-Is it just me or others too spot the tendency to underplay Kamal's performance while praising his filmmaking in a surreptitious manner.
k_g, that is oh so common. Even for Virumandi, which I thought was an outstanding performance from Kamal, although I myself went through the "his filmmaking was better than his acting in Virumandi" phase.
I agree Lal over Kamal for 2000 acting awards. But the best movie and best director - really, that was a cinch. It should have been for Hey Ram.
I think the insult to injury was that 2000 was sandwiched by 1999(Ajay Devgan) and 2001(Anil Kapoor). That just fuelled the rage even more. I am not sure Devgan for Zakhm was National Award worthy. Ofcourse, Mammookka shared it in 1999 for Ambedkar to cushion the impact.
BTW, Mitunda might surge ahead of Lal this year. Apparently, he has done an offbeat film in bengali that was well-appreciated. Whenever he has done that, he has got an award, in the past. idhukku dhAn amavaaaikkoru padam aadikkoru padam nallA nadikkaNum. Total impact irukkum. RegularA nallA nadichA, taken for granted aagidum :-)