Printable View
Scale, IMO the thunderous BGM when RK meets Ramyakrishnan in the second half strikes me immediately when it comes to BGM of ARRQuote:
Originally Posted by Scale
The one I distinctly remember in Dalapathy is the death bells ( SANGU ) whenever Amreshpuri is shown ! thats IR special :D
MIL, wat Nakkeeran wanted was true unbiased prasie for ARR.......i guess no one is giving that......even ur praise for ARR seems to be "uppukku chappan" praises
Maddy!
neengalumma? enakku en manasil pattadai sonnaen, ungalakku engae puriya pogiradhu. and also neenga sonnathukku udane disagreement koduthathu naan thaan!!
If you feel that "uppukku chappan" that is sad, coz we have been in this forum right from old times and you should know my posts by now, I dont need to praise just coz I have to do it.
I am a Music-Fan first who grew up with IR raising himself in the TFM (so I will surely have more to remember and associate myself with it). Other than that, I dont have anything to say.
Btw you should not expect forced opinions out of anyone, we are grown enough to respect others opinions.
You praising IR or not praising IR surely does not affect me. I just see if there is a value in the post and reply to them.
MIL,Quote:
Originally Posted by MusicIsLife
whether you will be responding to my post or not, what I observe here is that BY BRINGING IN DEVA & APPRECIATING HIS WORK, SOMEWHERE DOWN THE LINE, KNOWINGLY OR UNKNOWINGLY, YOU ARE ONLY TRYING TO PROVE A POINT THAT EVEN DEVA DID BETTER WHEN COMPARED TO ARR ,
WHICH IRKS ME.
Whether you guys believe me or not, I am neutral in appreciating ARR's music as well though I am a IR fan ( not just by keeping his image as avatar )
BUT I AM NOT SEEING THE SAME PARAMETER BEING APPLIED WHEN IT COMES TO IDENTIFYING ARR'S TALENTS.
At one point of time, YOU ARE GOING TO CONCLUDE THAT DEVA IS THE BEST EVER MD FOR RAJINI.
I WILL NOT BE SURPRISED :?
Nakeeran
Thanks for all your imagination!! I dont want to reply to you or argue with you. You have the right to say your opinion and I have my right to justify what I say, sometimes question to a post just to see what was the basis.
Probably a good forum person will read through the post.
It is my right to bring in anybody I want as a matter of discussion, let us stay with answering the facts than scampering away from what is in hand. if you see LOGICALLY Deva did 3 movies (i guess) and ARR did 3 movies they had thier share of giving RK movies the feel the director wanted. Whether it is greater appeal to the audience or not is totally different aspects.
I have never said Deva is best suited, but somebody might feel otherwise, my opinion is not an yardstick with which the decision is made, it is just a consensus.
"YOU ARE GOING TO CONCLUDE THAT DEVA IS THE BEST EVER MD FOR RAJINI": Does it matter?
If you dont see the same parameter in identifying ARR talents, well I am sorry that is not my problem,then you expect forum people to say what you want to hear, that is a significant issue.
Maddy and I have been associated in this forum for quite sometime, our frequencies match quite well.
btw I accepted ARR is the gr8est and you are neutral, so why are you so bent upon bothering to get a reply from me.
I feel sorry that I am replying to your post!! while i could be listening to my Alathur Brothers, MKT and classical giants of carnatic vocal.
Scale,
Though this is not related to the topic
<dgn>
Since you mentioned Mudhalvan, i wanted to tell you about En Veetu Thottathil song,the vocals is based on raaga senjurutti, but the music is not (i guess it was shankarabharanam or kamboji, can ne body rectify that). that was really innovative
FYI famous song in raaga Senjurutti is: Nada vindhu kaladhi namo namo
</dgn>
Stars with great screen presence (like MGR/Shivaji/Rajini/Kamal) really do not need a SPECIFIC MD to score for their projects...especially after they obtained their biggie status...any above-average (or below average with good copying skills) MD will do...even though they were definitely aided by great compositions of hardworking / brilliant kavingar-MD combo during their upcoming years...(it's easily possible to list mega hits of these stars with multiple MDs...it's just a question of who was available, suitable to the script / budget / producer etc and may be who was at the top at the point of time...)
OTOH, extremely talented MD's like MSV-IR-ARR do not need stars to piggy back...they can make mega musicals with start-up actors, directors, production houses etc.
At present, any average MD can score for a Rajini movie (even ctrl-c/ctrl-v from a decent source) and make a big hit album...no big deal...Proof? CM...
hey MIL, i know u r one neutral man from our old association......thats y it irks me more when u have continously heaped praise on IR and really ignored ARR here......if RS or sanjeevi do this, we wud understand but not u sir.....Quote:
Originally Posted by MusicIsLife
adhe eppadi naan pudicha muyalukku moonu kaala?? MIL sir, heart in heart u know who this statement shuld be directed to, u think i deserve this statement ??? :lol: vidunga sir, i saw ur post on RDB BGM in the other thread, felt better...... :wink:
app_engine, i guess urs was the most relevant post in this thread for the past 7 days or so :lol: ........very very gud point......then y do ppl. like MGR,RK always go for the best in music too.....i heard MGR used to sit in tune discussions as well.......is it that they want everything best in their movies???
Good post from APP. It is fact that both kamal and rajini film songs became super hit without IR/ARR. No need to give list as everyone knows it. point is IR scored most number movies and gave mega hits and Rajini film songs able to maintain same trend before and after IR. Sameway even MGR/Shivaji gave most number of films to MSV even though other MD's able to give super hits for their movies.
Net net they prefered best out of the lot because they want super hit plus quality music. Anyone can give hit songs(as told by APP just cut and paste) but they cannot create trend and projection which extremely talented MD able to do for particular star.
Giving some example where qualtiy MD able to create waves with their imagaination and become trend set for particular star.
POOTHUVAGA EAA MANASU THANGAM-Trend set for Rajini.
ILLAMAI ETHU ETHU- for kamal.
POONAL POOGATTUM POODA/ENGAE NIMMADHI- for Shivaji
NAAN ANNAI ITTAL/ATHU ANTHA PARAVAI- for MGR
URVASI URVASI/ MOOKALA- for Prabhu deva
Prabhu deva got star image after these songs .
I would like to repeat again I am not degrading or commenting anything against other music directors but just telling that these songs able to stand over the years while compare to others.
regards
ramesh
At last I could see someone with a very clear thinking , came with an neutral opinion. You have brought sanity to this thread :clap:Quote:
Originally Posted by app_engine
true. :thumbsup:
The vocals ofcourse is SenjurutiQuote:
Originally Posted by MusicIsLife
the music obviously is not kamboji . You can hear kamboji through Kuzaloodhi manamellam kollai konda pinbum from Oothukadu VS