vincent r u a very humerous person?i can see that in this thread
Printable View
vincent r u a very humerous person?i can see that in this thread
Change the topic to "Whore is as good as Wife"
how evil.... But Deva did rule certain years of 90s by copying IR style of Music.
poRumai...poRumai....Quote:
Originally Posted by vickyvichu
Upto today totally 29 votes been polled. Out of them 18 for IsaingAni and 11 for ThEnisai thenRal. So it is proved one third of hubbers accept it. But neenga solrapadi pArthaal all 29 votes must be put for IR.
So, neenga vAnathukkum boomikkum kudhikkirathu arththam illainnu AyiduchA.
Neenga solrapadi irundhaal, Deva should be disappeared within one or two years, otherwise within 5 to 10 movies. But for several years he was having more number of movies in hand, than any other MDs.
After 'EjamAn' and 'UzhaipALi' no Rajini producers approach IR. Why?. After that Deva done three for Rajini and all the three (AnnAmalai, Batcha, ArunAchalam) were big hits. How?. Kamal also used him in some, like Avvai Shanmugi, Pammal K.sambandham etc, and enjoyed the success.
I am not asking you to accept Deva as equal to IR. But some of the hubbers here not even to accept Deva knows something about music. Whether they accept or not accept, Deva is survining in market more than 15 years, without break with handful of movies.
Dont measure anybody's work with howmany National Awards they get. Infact, MSV also did not get any National Award and Shivaji also. Can anybody tell MSV does not know music and Sivaji is not an actor?.
The 11 votes are not by Deva fans or common unbiased music lovers. They are ARR fans. I cant imagine someone is so senseless and blind to open this thread.Quote:
Originally Posted by mr_karthik
"The 11 votes are not by Deva fans or common unbiased music lovers. They are ARR fans. I cant imagine someone is so senseless and blind to open this thread."
My vote goes to IR and I am an ARR fan (people who know me call me a strong ARR fan). There is NO way you can compare IR and Deva though. Indeed, as in NJV's words, the former is really the sun while the latter is the moon. It is a travesty to have only 18 say no. Now it is 19. I hope more unbiased fans vote to give the true real picture (that IR is incomparable).
That said, Deva is good in his own right. He has composed many good songs but he will never be IR.
I strongly Object this! The creator of this thread is a HC Deva fan & 1 more guy is there named sudalai who is also a Deva fan, I am sure.Quote:
Originally Posted by Music4Ever
From our side I am confident, none of the ARR fans would have stepped the poll even by mistake.
Music4ever & njv!, Do you want me to create another poll to prove this! This thread is almost dead, Why a HC IR fan has to re-activate it.
Many of them claim they are HC ARR fans :lol: Good!
Scale dude, don't misquote me. It was NJV who said what you have quoted. Apart from that I don't know what you are talking in your post. If you doubt my support for ARR all you have to do is read my other posts which should be quite easy.
Music4Eever,
Do not waste your time explaining your identity to these people because they are very busy proving their man is the hero and all other MDs are zero at any cost!(I am not particular about anyone)
I have been regular visitor for the past 4+ years (even though i do not post often) and know you well as a Rahman fan even before some of these Senior hubbers (!) started out to post. No offence to them.
vincent is a very humorus person (another Seniour hubber, if you check profile! - Moderator, should quantity of posts decide these titles?!). He was starting quite bunch of similar threads months ago(YSR > ARR, HR > ARR, Deva >= IR..i am not sure of the exact equations he started as threads) and he is too busy somewhere out there in another thread!
my two cents for this meaningless yet interesting thread: Just because funny guy vincent stated such an idiotic comparison, we should not insult Deva. Even though he lifted a lot, he did make some nice melodies("Gokulathil Seethai", "Ennasai Machan" for instance). Also he was the main competitor in the latter part of IR and early years of ARR.
M4e dude!,Quote:
Originally Posted by Music4Ever
Oops! Why do u all (shankar,u & someothers) alter the default quoting message format. It's confusing who quoted what?
I reiterate, none of the ARR fans would have voted it. Every ARR fan is a big admirer of IR and have high regards to him. We are not dim-witted to compare him to deva by voting the poll. :(
Thats my point! :D
Pls stop posting. Let this thread die 8-)