Thanks for putting Uyire in the list NOV!
No prizes for guessing who my vote went to. :D
Printable View
Thanks for putting Uyire in the list NOV!
No prizes for guessing who my vote went to. :D
Voted for Minnale. Planning to vote for others too.
Will do the same. Abstained from voting.
Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
NOV,Quote:
Originally Posted by ajithfederer
Ennudaya vendugol/manakkumural
1. Kannaalane and Uyire in the same line - no way!
2. IMO Uyire shouldn't even be in the Top 10" kaiyil midhakkum kanavaa nee /mudhan murai killi paarthEn", "Pachai nirame" shouldn't be in the list
Point 2 remba over nu neraya peru feel pannuvaanga :oops:
Anyway, "Kaadhalenum Thervezhudhi" - no takers-ngala?
ellArum innEram ezhuthiruppAinga, result-um vanthirukkum :lol2:Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
Actually people who grew up in the 90s will at least have a few ARR songs which are close to their hearts, riding on some personal memories. LM-kku alaipayuthey maathiri :yessir:
naan rendu vaatti vote podalaama? :D
I agree with you on all counts. :sigh2:Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
:oops: Idhai naan eppa sonnen :roll:Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerd
:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:Quote:
Originally Posted by Nerd
firsstu kirukku vandhavale, ippo idhu
Neenga yen ippadi vilundhu vilundu precharam panreenga ?? :lol2:.
Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
enga eppO sonneengannu nyaabagam illai, aanaal matter nyaabagam irukku. naan indha maadhiri vishayathai marakka maattEn :mrgreen:Quote:
Originally Posted by littlemaster1982
I know when did I say that. Summa oru bit potten :mrgreen:
:lol2:Quote:
Originally Posted by littlemaster1982
mudhal murai is better than kadhalenum... the picturization, the song situation, and the lyrics which won national award for VM....Quote:
Originally Posted by crajkumar_be
moreover Rahman acted well than Gunal...
sorry if gunal is ur personal fav :)
Guys, this is not the end.
Somehow or other we will get the single best melody of AR Rahman; pls be patient.
:notthatway: Kaadhalenum is a great song. Actually I found it tough to choose between AP/Minnale nee/Kaadhakenum. And you mean to say Mudhal Murai's picturisation is better than Kaadhalenum :shock:Quote:
Originally Posted by SoftSword
i love to add Kadhalennu thervezhudhi in the list :(
ever green fresh song for me :P
yes lm..
u think the foreign locations and graphics is always the best...
in mudhal murai it is the fresh village backdrop... the bullock cart and the car with folk instruments and classical instruments...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SWX9-...eature=related
Foriegn location-kkaga sollala. The picturisation of Kaadhalenum fit very well with the mood of the song (Kunal mattumdhan sariyilla).
Mudhal Murai had an ordinary picturisation even if not compared with Kaadhalenum, IMO :D
adhae dhan nanum solraen...Quote:
Originally Posted by littlemaster1982
its so natural...
but it fit the song and the lyrics very well...
Song - Mudhal murai
Movie - Sangamam
Singer - Sujatha, Srinivas
Music - A R Rahman
Lyrics - Vairamuthu
Pallavi:
Female: mudhal murai kiLLippaarththEn
mudhal murai kaNNil vErththEn
endhan thaayin karppam thaandi
marumurai uyir kondEn
unnaal irumurai uyir kondEn
mudhal murai enakku
azhudhidath thOnrum...En?
kaNNeer undu sOgamillai
aamaam maRai undu mEgamillai
(mudhal murai...)
Charanam 1:
Female: KaalgaLil kidandha salangaiyaith thirudi
anbe en manasukkuL kattiyadhenna?
Male: salangaigaL aNindhum saththangaLai maraiththaay
peNNE un uLLam thannai ozhittthadhenna?
Female: vidhai onru uyir koLLa
veppam kaattru eeram vEndum
kaadhal vandhu uyir koLLa
kaalam kooda vEndum
Male: oru vidhai uyir koNdadhu
aanaal iru nenjil vEr koNdadhu
(mudhal murai...)
(Male:) salangaiyE konjam pEsu
mounamE paadal paadu
mozhiyellaam oomaiyaanaal
kaNNeer uraiyaadum
adhil kavidhai arangErum
Charanam 2:
Female: paadhaiyum dhooram naan oru baaram
ennai un ellai varai koNdu sellaayaa?
Male: udalukkuL irukkum uyir oru sumaiyaa?
peNNE unnai naanum vittuchchelvEnaa?
Female: thandhai thandha uyir thandhEn
thaai thandha udal thandhEn
uravugaL ellaam sErththu
unnidam kandEn
Male: moththaththaiyum nee koduththaay
aanaal muththaththukkO naaL kuriththaay...
(mudhal murai...)
minnalE nee vandhadennadi
- I voted for this simply because I had listened to the album recently.
I don't think it's possible to arrive at 'best'. But the list could be improved.
Two nominations because I'd listened AND watched the video quite recently:
Narumugaiye,
Poo kodiyin
The songs as such are minimalist considering the period, context and theme of the movie. That said, the choreography/video plays a part in these selections. I'm unable to isolate the imagery to these songs.
i really cannot vote for a song or two of ARR's its really hard and will not do justice. sorry
am also just wondering where the likes of Sandhana Thendral, Mellisaye, Vennilave Vennilave and Thoda Thoda are?
hehe
:D
:exactly:Quote:
Originally Posted by lancelot
Mellisaiye is another brilliant song.
It's really difficult to vote since all the songs are truly amazing numbers...maybe you should have renamed the forum as Favourite ARR's melodies instead of Best ARR's melodies. Ethu best-nu namme epedi soluradhe? :huh:
Comeon Lancy,Quote:
Originally Posted by jaaze
You can do that. Why do you think by voting a song you consecrate injustice to others? There will always be additions that pops up in every mind (Polls have been conducted even for world best songs ever). Nothing can be done now the poll is up and 21 votes have already been booked. They have expressed their views. There should be a way out. Shortlist them and listen to it sure you can rate it based upon your personal liking and understanding. No harm no regrets Have fun :)
Sure, I am going to be a loser :lol: :notworthy:
Hey ScaleQuote:
Originally Posted by Scale
Its my opinion that its not fair to vote for a single song. to me, it makes me feel bad (however twisted that sounds). i have been following the thread from the beginning and i have already short listed the songs. ever time i listen, one sounds better than the other.
may be we should include 2 options for None of the above and All of the above. :) just an idea
sorry Scale i really cannot vote. :(
hehe
:D
Lancy,
Then reserve your votes for time being and await response. Can you list me the shortlisted ones not more than 3.
Later :think:
Voted for "minnalE nee vandhadennadi"...
But I have one doubt... in certain options, we have 2 songs... even if one of them is our personal favourite, we will vote for that option only.. at the same time, song like "minnalE nee vandhadennadi" is like one man army... where the current voting % is 16.. whereas the song(s) having highest % in the list is Munbe Vaa / New York nagaram... which has two songs..
ultimately "minnalE nee vandhadennadi" is the winner at least for now ??
Adha thaan naanum sonnen. unga confusiona vote pottavargalukku padhipillamal theerkaradhukku we shall add "en mel vizhundha malai thuliye" to it given the choice of 2 songs from the same album/diff album. What do you say?
ok, added. :D
guys this is first stage only.
eventually the top five will fight individually. :lol:
:thumbsup:
Mods,
Are there any problems in discussing ARR's hindi melodies?
Ram,
Thamizh songs list pandradhukke muzhi pidhungiduchu. Hindi melodies-kku innoru thread aarambippom, after this one is over :D
Teek hai :D
Looks like the following songs are in contention:
we'll wait until the end of this week, for any further votings. :)Quote:
enmEl vizhundha mazhai thuliyE
kaiyil midhakkum kanavaa nee
kannaalanE enadhu kannai
minnalE nee vandhadennadi
mudhan murai killi paarthEn
munbE vaa en anbE vaa
new york nagaram
pachai niramE pachai niramE
snEgidhanE snEgidhanE
uyirE vandhu ennOdu
I was/am disheartened that my fav piece "engE enadhu kavidhai" is missing. I thought lemme not vote.
My heart also sank to notice "ennavaLe" song has not secured even single vote. I wanted to boycott and not vote in this poll.
Just to see "munbE vaa" leading in poll... is... :|.... fine...ppl have their choice... no issues.
Ive lost interest in this poll though, finally, I decided to give up my dissapointment and vote for "minnalE nee vanthathennadi" one of my favs definitely.
ippadi onnummillaa vishayaththukkellaam dishearted aagi, heart-sank aagi, boycott panna enna arththam? :roll:
good that you finally were heartened enough. :thumbsup:
Enna SP, ningelum ennavale-ke vote panaliya? :lol:Quote:
Originally Posted by Shakthiprabha