allov ellOrum nallavare politeness personified MSV advocate, as I hail from the metric stream, ingrained in my bloodstream, the more in house memory capacity and reproducing ability, the more the chances of qualifying the candidate with flying colors whether it is exam or appointment . So is it any surprise Raja scores over copy book reference seeking MSV ?Quote:
Originally Posted by jaiganes
Ayyayyoo!
After reading GVM comments in Hindu about 'NEPV release date shifted to September', NEPV should not ultimately become like Nandhalalaa (OR) Mayilu!
From this context, I feel GVM has 'cleverly' planned the release of his bigger films before NEPV as a mitigation for retaining his own market (just in case the NEPV bubble bursts). I am sorry! this thought is coming to my mind for the past few days....
Anyway let us hope for the best!
Does this mean, the audio release will also be postponed?
V_S,
From what I heard, No. The music release must happen in July. The film release is postponed not the music release.
baroque, as the guy who brought in Bharathi, I feel obliged to respond.
Compare paNNadhukkE kOchuguneengaLE :lol2:
I think Suresh put the point across more succinctly than I managed to - that had he been around now and there was a bulletin board like this, he'd be discussed like this too.
As you may know, he was criticized during his time for not sticking to poetic conventions (both in form and content). Indeed there are very critical studies of Bharathi now that question even the veracity of his social outlook. (I am not saying it isw right, but the very existence of contrary opinion means something, right?).
And where the people he arrogantly dismissed all contemptible? Definitely no. His நடிப்பு சுதேசிகள் is a indictment of the moderates in the Congress. Just because they didn't share his sense of urgency and methods- which we can't even say was well founded -he chooses to roundly poetically diss them. We enjoy the poetry because it rises above the particular nature of the context.
We can perhaps discuss in the bharathi thread. silapala vedigundugaL veesa vasadhiyA irukkum :lol2:
PR, plis to do the honours.
Senthil sir,Quote:
Originally Posted by senthilv.com
Me definitely have no insider connection :-)
ellAmE veRum kEttaRivu (of TFM for > 4 decades) maRRum padiththaRivu (mostly in the tfmpage / hub & TN tabloids / kumudam / vikatan) mattum dhAn :-)
nanRi thumburu & Sureshji for substantiating my hypothesis :-)
Now, a small caveat (to this "IR-is-greatest-IFM-composer" thingy) :
He often needed "catalysts" to bring out the best in him. While there had been great songs / scores for some kuppai movies & directors too, it is irrefutable that he was consistently better when working with talents like BR-MR who had good ears for music or otherwise & could trigger the creative fountains inside IR.
That way, this Gautam association is very keenly anticipated!
Personal-ஆ நீங்க அப்படி நினைச்சா போதுமா? இதை நீங்க தகுந்த தரவுகள் தந்து நிறுவணும். ஒரு rigourous ஆய்வு முன்வைக்கப்படாத வரை, என்னைப் போன்றோர் இதை ஏற்றுக்கொள்வது கடினம். ராஜா தான் greater!Quote:
Originally Posted by Sureshs65
raj & vijayr are still in that MSV discussion on BRangan's blog :-)
Interesting to see R Sundarrajan being dragged in ( i.e. like IRF's feeling he shouldn't be compared with MSV, MRF's can also feel he shouldn't be compared with Gautam it seems).
R Sundarrajan is not a correct comparison as he was far from someone "sticking to IR or only modern" :lol2:
His first film was with IR - payaNangaL mudivadhillai.
Second?
With KVM!
andha rAththirikku sAtchi illai, with that beautiful song 'ethir pArththEn iLankiLiya kANalliyE' (raaga.com erroneously mentions S-G as the MDs :-( It was an agmark KVM song)
Then he came back to IR for nAn pAdum pAdal. He did another with KVM, 'thoongAtha kaNNinRu onRu'.
So, it was no big deal that he did one with MSV, sugamAna rAgangaL.
Ofcourse, RS was the director for MTK where MSV-IR combo happened for the first time.
So, wrong comparison - nalla vELai BRangan didn't take that route, making Gautam = RS :-)
Because Bharathi's work is done in selfless manner, does mean it has to be better than someone else's art and cannot be compared. Can I argue his work is not better than an another freedom fighter poet who never wrote an apology letter to British in the fear of being in Jail?.