|| Azhagiya Tamizh Magan | Bharathan | Vijay ||

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by mahen01

Elapugalum sounds like ARR's Ararai kodi.. but def better than than. I only heared Rangu rangama few times so I cant give comment about similarities with that song.

Prassanna whether harris copy arr or not.. thats a different point. But U can identify that it is Harries song even on those songs ur claiming copied from ARR. I dont think YSR follows ARR Style. You cant just say whoever uses western music and modern equipments follows ARR Style. YSR have his own style. And marlyn manro does sounds 50% YSR style. (I am not saying copy)

---

Harris rahman pathu copy adikuraru ethu orukey therinja visiyam if u dont belive go and watch kadhal desam antha golf groungla spb tabu pesum pothu patha mudhal naal pattu re recordingga varum. appadiyae copy adichutaru copy(rahman) jeyaraj. ethu verum oru sample. summa pesanumnu pesa kudathu. harris has a.r.r style in his music even ysr has with a mix of western. Rahman made the path(roja) they r following
ethula marlyn song 50% yrs comedy of 2007 anna ethu a.r.r style na atha pathuthan ysr potturuparu. ethu pattu ysr stylena appa ethu anna rahman style
ok cumin back 2 atm songs r getting sweeter day by day. :D :lol:

pothum niruthungappaa unga HJ-ARR sandai... Enna Karumam saar ithu :banghead:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ramakrishna

pothum niruthungappaa unga HJ-ARR sandai... Enna Karumam saar ithu :banghead:

---

yoov po yaa enga alukku alu rahman ysr, harris pathu copy adicharunu comedy pannunvangal atha pathu summa irukka solriya poi sollalam anaa poruntha sollanum

"Best album of 2000's"
"Best ever Vijay album"
"Mass and Class at synergy"
"Oh my god.. I cant sleep"
"Rocking get a new meaning"
"Mozart in fine form"

Comments which would wake up any man/woman from sleep and ponder the worldwide web to get hold of the songs and grace through them. Not only comments from TFM, but also from people who are "supposedly" music critics with their own blogs, searched words for adoration. Hmmm then.. ARR must be back to his best ....

Keep listening one song after another .... makes you doubt if I had a different version of ATM than you guyz are listening to?... So I search again.. No there is no other version.. its the one and only one.... Pinch myself..is this it? Am i growing too old to comprehend even super hit music...So I become claustrophobic... waiting for some redemption... ah then they start to come....

" ARR has delivered what required of the movie"
"Vijay cant expect anything better"
"Keep listening more and more... you might be hooked...2 hooked so far"

That was normal..Someone suddenly compared IR and ARR... IR fans refuse to let go of the past.. past is eutopia...ARR fans just keep lowering expectation everytime... then came the mother of all comments

"We expected a disaster, but we were delivered a good album"

Yipeee.. Nuthing is wrong with me... !!! If we were all expecting a disaster, then this is certainly way above a disaster..!!! With my peanut music sense let me atleast cast a review...

"Ella pugalum"
For a moment I will ingore the comment someone made this being one of the best opening numbers ever... As I understand movie making is a team effort. Directors and MD give and take ideas. For a vijay movie, knowing his strengths and weakness...and his penchant for dance.. saying this song is a letdown is a huge understatement. Is he going to dance while preaching?. we'll see....
goign to be the weakest vijay opening number...

Songwise ..nuthing new... been there done that !! I will take anythign with ARR's voice.

Kelamal..

Again not playing to Vijay's strength...the song starts of with a beautiful tune...wait and thats about it... what follows is mere torture...I have to pat the guy who commented "it looks like some sound engineer with ARR mask ... did the song" ... no interludes.. not even new beats...who cares.... take a loop and spin it around... excuse of a song...

Maryln Monroe....

Finnaly we see some form ... defintely hit material with Namitha's oomph factor n Vijay going shirtless....typical 90's Rehman...the one we are used to...

Maduraiku...Valaypatti....
Decibels just increase.. go down .. increase.... ears get punished..."savadi" beats go up ... increase.. and yes ears get punished again.... if this is rehman's version of vijay's dance numbers .. Rehman needs a reminder

Ponmagal...
whoever did it..owes a treat from me... great satisfaction was derived...oh wait.. only after I hit the stop button... I felt like a lamb taken to the butcher...

The previous combination though not great had one melody which would rank in the list of all time melodies "Udaya Udaya"...it also had some decent (Now they sound good compared to this) numbers in "Pookum" , "Enna Enna" and "ThiruvelliKenni Rani". This one is an utter let down...

In the concluding part of the Oh La La La... Rehman was his usual unassuming self..impressing me with " To all the participants.. Maybe I forgot to tell you this, whenever you compose, just dont lose one thing ...Jeevan (soul) ".... Precisely... though people think Rehman westernized the tamil audio.. almost all his songs had one thing ...jeevan.. people could relate... Forget its a Vijay movie....Where's the jeevan rehman?????? Even a song like "Soniya Soniya" from Ratchagan .. had soul in it... sadly .. I am confounded by this album....

I wouldnt buy the arguement Vijay movie only deserves this.. you dont have to loook way beyond for best album for a commercial vijay starrer...."Thirumalai" should fit the bill... With the ongoing fights on RR..and the relaease of the movie by diwali..Almost everything points that this will be your last association with a vijay movie.. Not that Vijay deserves anything better, its just that we deserve better stuff from you .....

First Vel and now ATM... looks like TFM is in a period of mourning...!!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prasana84

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kamarajc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by A.ANAND

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kamarajc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cadburyboy

i think the Ellapughalum song 1st interlude jus aft the prelude is exactly same the way siru parvayale song frm bheema 1st interlude takes off....any idea?

---

cadburyboy, I think you are not getting the message that TFMPage is only for ARR Fans. Had it been HJ who did 'Ella Pugazhum' song,
I am sure some archaelogists here would have found 'Ella Pugazhum' as a rehash of 'Oru mugamo' and 'Siru Paarvaiyale'...

TFMpage is not active these days.. that is a good news for Tamil Film Music.

---

tho vanthutaru vaaya polanthukittu!!poda..poda ke**pu**

---

Thanks Anand. I didnt expect anything better from you. You only help me prove my point.

---

unga comedyku oru aalavae ilama pochu. sachin dhoni pathu batting kathukurarunu solra mathiri irukku comedy panunga anaa oru alava irukku :lol:

---

why talk about style and all that. We are not talking about the talent of ARR and HJ. Though I dont have the slightest eligibility to judge their potential, ARR is a genius by any standards. But, he needs no praise at the cost of a dig at HJ. Every other track of HJ is ridiculed. I simply used the same yardstick that all these so-called-ARR-fans (My god, who else do we you think we guys are!!) are using to measure others, especially, ESPECIALLY, HJ. I just want to be here and say that the guy you ridicule the most is not helpless.

Lets come to the point straight, close your eyes and just think that HJ has composed 'Ella pugazhum' (Though the super-judgemental-capability of some may not permit to do so) and then listen to the song with your Evaluator hat on. then, its your say! You guys are exposed with your standards and yards, atleast grow up with some better levels of language. There still are some people who are sheerly interested in music and wandering in this website.

[quote]3 . Have you heard the songs of ‘Azhagiya Thamizh Magan’?
--- Neetu, Washington

Thenali: With the re-mix of "ponmagal vandhaall...," Rehman has proved that he is the king of re-mixes. Other than that, Mani Sarma and Vidyasagar are apt composers for Vijay films.
[quote]

I did not comment on ATM since it did not appeal to me as shivaji did, probably i will have to hear a few times (without knowing it is ATM).

but this is an insult absolutely inexcusable, can somebody bring sense into "Thenali" of Cinesouth.com, I guess this person does not have any musical sense.

I hate it, it irritates me and frustrates me

[quote="MusicIsLife"][quote]3 . Have you heard the songs of ‘Azhagiya Thamizh Magan’?
--- Neetu, Washington

Thenali: With the re-mix of "ponmagal vandhaall...," Rehman has proved that he is the king of re-mixes. Other than that, Mani Sarma and Vidyasagar are apt composers for Vijay films.

Quote:

---

I did not comment on ATM since it did not appeal to me as shivaji did, probably i will have to hear a few times (without knowing it is ATM).

but this is an insult absolutely inexcusable, can somebody bring sense into "Thenali" of Cinesouth.com, I guess this person does not have any musical sense.

I hate it, it irritates me and frustrates me

---

Actually, I would take Thenali's word in a different way. Vijay's movies are mostly masala stuff.. it just needs some music fillers here and there for the vijay and his heroine to shake up themselves and keep pushing the movie. They have hardly demanded any fine musical appeal. Even yuvan has not worked with Vijay for more than one movie (Pudhiya Geethai). And, HJ with Vijay only on Coke ad (If you would count it :) ). Devisriprasad, Dheena, Srikanth Deva, MAnisharma and Vidyasagar are best for Vijay movies. Forget ARR, even GVP is too much for Vijay movies. And, if you want it to be classy, Vidyasagar is the right choice.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kamarajc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prasana84

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kamarajc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by A.ANAND

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kamarajc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cadburyboy

i think the Ellapughalum song 1st interlude jus aft the prelude is exactly same the way siru parvayale song frm bheema 1st interlude takes off....any idea?

---

cadburyboy, I think you are not getting the message that TFMPage is only for ARR Fans. Had it been HJ who did 'Ella Pugazhum' song,
I am sure some archaelogists here would have found 'Ella Pugazhum' as a rehash of 'Oru mugamo' and 'Siru Paarvaiyale'...

TFMpage is not active these days.. that is a good news for Tamil Film Music.

---

tho vanthutaru vaaya polanthukittu!!poda..poda ke**pu**

---

Thanks Anand. I didnt expect anything better from you. You only help me prove my point.

---

unga comedyku oru aalavae ilama pochu. sachin dhoni pathu batting kathukurarunu solra mathiri irukku comedy panunga anaa oru alava irukku :lol:

---

why talk about style and all that. We are not talking about the talent of ARR and HJ. Though I dont have the slightest eligibility to judge their potential, ARR is a genius by any standards. But, he needs no praise at the cost of a dig at HJ. Every other track of HJ is ridiculed. I simply used the same yardstick that all these so-called-ARR-fans (My god, who else do we you think we guys are!!) are using to measure others, especially, ESPECIALLY, HJ. I just want to be here and say that the guy you ridicule the most is not helpless.

Lets come to the point straight, close your eyes and just think that HJ has composed 'Ella pugazhum' (Though the super-judgemental-capability of some may not permit to do so) and then listen to the song with your Evaluator hat on. then, its your say! You guys are exposed with your standards and yards, atleast grow up with some better levels of language. There still are some people who are sheerly interested in music and wandering in this website.

---

Hey just wait tell wat makes u 2 think like ella pogalum has some resemblance with sila parvaiyalae and oru mugamoo dont give such a stupid statement this itself shows your musical sense. we considered rahman is the king of indian music. His style is followed with some new sounds. we know our standards our master is composing for hollywood, bollywood and kollywood. Your stupid comment will never work get lost :hammer:

Sloshed,

If you don't like the album, thats fine. But the way you have reviewed it, shows your hatred towards ARR.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prasana84

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kamarajc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prasana84

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kamarajc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by A.ANAND

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by kamarajc

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by cadburyboy

i think the Ellapughalum song 1st interlude jus aft the prelude is exactly same the way siru parvayale song frm bheema 1st interlude takes off....any idea?

---

cadburyboy, I think you are not getting the message that TFMPage is only for ARR Fans. Had it been HJ who did 'Ella Pugazhum' song,
I am sure some archaelogists here would have found 'Ella Pugazhum' as a rehash of 'Oru mugamo' and 'Siru Paarvaiyale'...

TFMpage is not active these days.. that is a good news for Tamil Film Music.

---

tho vanthutaru vaaya polanthukittu!!poda..poda ke**pu**

---

Thanks Anand. I didnt expect anything better from you. You only help me prove my point.

---

unga comedyku oru aalavae ilama pochu. sachin dhoni pathu batting kathukurarunu solra mathiri irukku comedy panunga anaa oru alava irukku :lol:

---

why talk about style and all that. We are not talking about the talent of ARR and HJ. Though I dont have the slightest eligibility to judge their potential, ARR is a genius by any standards. But, he needs no praise at the cost of a dig at HJ. Every other track of HJ is ridiculed. I simply used the same yardstick that all these so-called-ARR-fans (My god, who else do we you think we guys are!!) are using to measure others, especially, ESPECIALLY, HJ. I just want to be here and say that the guy you ridicule the most is not helpless.

Lets come to the point straight, close your eyes and just think that HJ has composed 'Ella pugazhum' (Though the super-judgemental-capability of some may not permit to do so) and then listen to the song with your Evaluator hat on. then, its your say! You guys are exposed with your standards and yards, atleast grow up with some better levels of language. There still are some people who are sheerly interested in music and wandering in this website.

---

Hey just wait tell wat makes u 2 think like ella pogalum has some resemblance with sila parvaiyalae and oru mugamoo dont give such a stupid statement this itself shows your musical sense. we considered rahman is the king of indian music. His style is followed with some new sounds. we know our standards our master is composing for hollywood, bollywood and kollywood. Your stupid comment will never work get lost :hammer:

---

Hey just wait tell wat makes u 2 think like ella pogalum has some resemblance with sila parvaiyalae and oru mugamoo dont give such a stupid statement this itself shows your musical sense.

- Thanks

we considered rahman is the king of indian music.

- Well, thats a fact. You have nothing to brag about it.

His style is followed with some new sounds.

- Very true. Thats why we call him a king (With due respect to emperor IR)

we know our standards our master is composing for hollywood, bollywood and kollywood.

- Well, I am interested to know what you know or not. Atleast, it doesnt suit the topic.

Your stupid comment will never work get lost

- Why should I get lost sir?

I was talking about the yardstick that most people (ARR fanatics in TFMPage) use here. I simply asked them to use the same yardstick to measure ARR's music itself. Why cry about it? If you dont see any resemblance, thats fine.. lets leave it to the judgement of common people.