IR News and Other Titbits Ver.2009

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dochu

Whatever it maybe......it is not good nor wise to slander others in public.

Poor valmiki guys ---they would have been embarassed. Yenda kupitom endru erunthirukkum.

---

1. Only when he gets hold of him, he could give back :-) I'm not supporting IR at all here, but trying to understand. (That he is capable of controversies is a well-known thingy).

In addition, I read that Myskin talked as if Raja needs a reco to get chances from the likes of Shankar. For his stature, it would have definitely irked. He had been there - seen that.

Doesn't need reco or chance from "nEththikku muLaichcha" pasanga.

2. Actually the vAlmeeki guys may be happy for the publicity now, otherwise the whole thing - audio release / movie release etc - would have gone totally unnoticed :-)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by app_engine

அப்பாடி, ஒரு சின்ன நிம்மதி - எலீலோ ராசா போட்டதில்லை :-) இப்படி ஒரு "வெறும் இரைச்சல்" ராசா கையிலிருந்தா என நினைக்க வைத்த சாதனம் அது!

தெரிவித்த விதம் எப்படி இருந்தாலும், நியாயமான கோபம் தான். அந்தப்பாட்டு திரையில் வந்தாலும் பரவாயில்லை, தட்டில் எப்படி வரலாம்?

ராசா ஒண்ணும் அப்படி அட்ரஸ் இல்லாத ஆளில்லையே - அவரது தட்டில் கண்டதையும் போட்டு வெளியிட?

---

நல்லா சொன்னீங்க

Dochu,

If the details of Mysskin doing some re-recording without IR's knowledge in Nandalala is true, then I can understand IR's anger.

Still he should have played little mild. No point in embarassing a guy who worked with him. For his stature he can forgive such mistakes.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by prasad_subbu

Still he should have played little mild. No point in embarassing a guy who worked with him. For his stature he can forgive such mistakes.

---

Definitely, yes!

However, most here know "IR & இங்கிதம்" often do not go together :-(

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by app_engine

However, most here know "IR & இங்கிதம்" often do not go together :-(

---

Is getting the soundtrack and disappearing, not giving a courtesy call, and inserting third party material into the soundtrack "இங்கிதம்"?

IMHO, IR is perfectly justified in what he did - its a breach of trust

this also exposes very clearly the unprofessional way in which the industry operates - I have rarely heard of such instances happening in Hollywood, where every piece of agreement is documented and protected by a legal framework - maybe thats what IR should be doing in the future - Mysskin should consider himself lucky that IR did not pursue some legal means (which he could very well do if he wants to) for this silly unprofessional crappy slip on his part

Guys,
whatever Mysskin did. It is totally inappropriate to talk about 'irrelevant' things in somebody's party especially when it is public. (it is like we go and shout at somebody else in somebody's marriage function - poor analogy? :-))

We all face 'mysskin' kind of crap in our life. We don't pull up a mic and 'vent' out. Especially this is SO ridiculuous to IR's stature and his 'age'.

IR not only showed his 'insensibility' but spoilt Valmiki's release.

(app_e - agreed it is a good publicity for Valmiki - However, I think now they might hesitate to work with this volatile person in future.).

With our growing list of IR deserters - we can add Mysskin as well.

Why is it not volatile when Mysskin says "I expected him to work with ARR but he came to IR"? Why is it not volatile when he says "new directors must work with IR 'at least once'" as if IR is not fit to work with, but just make one exception for the experience? Why is it volatile only when IR says "I've worked with so many new directors, so why this fuss?"?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ananth222

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by app_engine

However, most here know "IR & இங்கிதம்" often do not go together :-(

---

Is getting the soundtrack and disappearing, not giving a courtesy call, and inserting third party material into the soundtrack "இங்கிதம்"?

---

You're right . However, it's just that the senior master can ignore such remarks as these are not told by the host but another guest, in this case. So, walking off (as reported) is not that courteous...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dochu

With our growing list of IR deserters - we can add Mysskin as well.

---

Even otherwise Myskin came for just one film only (in his own admission and also per history)...so no damage done from that angle.