Your Top 10 Cine Personalities

Joe,

I am a fan of kamal and rajni, (equal pref actually)

yet RAJNI wont fair in my top 10 list.

what to do :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by NOV

Joe, rather than affecting the cinema personalities who have been ignored, such lists reflect very greatly on the people putting up the list! :P

All, just imagine that you can honour only 10 people of the industry right from the 1930s. Who would your choice be?

In fact, I shudder to think that I mydelf have ignored earlier great personalities such as MKT, MS, GR, etc :shock:

---

Nov,
I got your point,but it is different from my point ..My observation starts from MGR ,sivaji period..But just because I am sivaji fan ,not include MGR in top 10 list is foolishness,IMO .Like wise People who can add kamal on the top ,ignoring Rajini and fillup with other very less achived people just for the sake ,it is also foolishness ,IMO ...Anyway Long live Jananayagam!

-deleted-

Shivaji Ganesan - Nil
M S V - Kannadasan
Nagesh - Manorama
Ilayaraja - SPB
Maniratnam - A R R - Vairamuthu

ivanga combo-output thaan enakku top 10 personalities. 10 peru correct thaane..

My list goes like this but no particular order except Kamal topping the list :D

1. Kamal Hassan
2. Sivaji Ganeshan
3. S P Balasubramaniam
4. Ilayarajah
5. Vairamuththu
6. ARR
7. Rajinikanth
8. K Balachandar
9. Radhika
10. Nagesh

Dr.SPB=Dr.Shivaji
Rajnikanth
Kamalhasan
S.Janaki=P.Susheela= Dr.KJY..............

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by joe

Kamal fans exclude rajini but add some funny names ,raijini fans exclude kamal but add some hardly achived people in the list ,Ajith fans saying he is the top no1 personality so far....guys ..pls give me a break..have some sense :cry:

---

You give preference to Kamal over Sivaji. I can argue MGR is better than them and Kamal Sivaji should be second in your list. Do you want us to list in the order you prefer? Then why/what are we supposed to discuss here? You CAN'T comment on our list as we can't comment on your list. I can make fun of your list and ask you do you have COMMON SENSE? But I'll not do that. I have common sense that says don't hurt others feelings. Hope you understand. I can just hope now. Achievement makes no sense in listing top ten personality.

Ajith tops my top 10 :D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by joe

Kamal fans exclude rajini but add some funny names ,raijini fans exclude kamal but add some hardly achived people in the list ,Ajith fans saying he is the top no1 personality so far....guys ..pls give me a break..have some sense :cry:

---

I donno, if u were hinting mine too ... But seriously speaking my intention is not to try hard to exclude rajni ... why would I try that ?? ... He can't get in my top 10 ... itz my top 10 , whoever I admired and kept me interested in tamil cinema...... I don't get what was funny in mine, they were all great achievers 8-) .. I still felt bad for excluding some other personalities in my top 10 ... but I was helpless ....
And I don't see anything wrong in Ajith fans ranking Ajith as no1 .... 8-) ...

BTW , if it were really to be , top 10 cine personalities based on their contribution to tamil cine arts, then again I don't think rajni would hold a candle to Kamal or other greatest contributors .... (sorry people(rajni fans) , I felt like saying this .... ) ... in that case , arguably Sivaji might top the list for his reportoire , for the range of characters he brought to life (from historical,devotional,....) and then Kamal (as well for his writing, producing as much an actor ), then a lot of writers like Kalaignar, ..... dirs like KB, BR, MR ....IR,ARR etc .... Even in such an ideal list would hardly rajni get a rank
8-)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by joe

Nov,
I got your point,but it is different from my point ..My observation starts from MGR ,sivaji period..But just because I am sivaji fan ,not include MGR in top 10 list is foolishness,IMO .Like wise People who can add kamal on the top ,ignoring Rajini and fillup with other very less achived people just for the sake ,it is also foolishness ,IMO ...Anyway Long live Jananayagam!

---

Makes no sense at all !
Itz our individual top 10 , it'll be utter foolishness to fill up with popular names, just to make it look attractive :oops:

My Top 10 Cine Personalities:

Madhavan :) (just because..... 8-) )
Maniratnam
Kamal
IR
ARR
Sivaji
Rajni
Prakash Raj
Raguvaran
Simran

Leave him guys, he just got awed by ur awesome list, and said few things carried away with emotions.

I guess even I said the same opinion too. You did not pick on me, but chose to pick on him.

*

Joe,

I think even I misunderstood the thread as TOP 10 achievers than TOP 10 FAV PPL.

Its THEIR TOP 10 FAV PPL (NOT ACHIEVERS). So their taste favours only certain ppl :wink: :D

:cheers: