Call it coincidence/ sheer genius...I dont know... but if copying was a crime, it will be so damn hard to prove that harris was guilty of copying..Even the CSI team will give up :lol: A genius indeed.. :)
Printable View
Call it coincidence/ sheer genius...I dont know... but if copying was a crime, it will be so damn hard to prove that harris was guilty of copying..Even the CSI team will give up :lol: A genius indeed.. :)
Thanks for accepting the fact finally. Your words says it all. Made my job easy.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
intha PKMC karu karu vizhigala song ? :roll:Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
:)Quote:
Originally Posted by kamarajc
Innum iruka? :D Any youtube clips?Quote:
Originally Posted by villan007
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
Mahen,
I dont know whether you are kidding or not..... Anyway here you go for some of the HJ copies......
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_f99Q...eature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bV7iLtx5p2w
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JmtYT...eature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sUkYl...eature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u2FjE...eature=related
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YDglyseP3Co
I would say harris is innovative...They way he indianised the tunes was quite impressive :D Anyway vasanth, im not supporting harris..Sometimes i wonder, if i were a MD, why would i wana copy a popular tune?? People will definitely hate me for that..So i feel its unfair to just label someone as copycats without knowing the actual reason..It might be because of director's request , maybe a genuine inspiration or even sheer coincidence..You never know the circumstances..Im sure MDs dont start their day in the studio by thinking of wat are the tunes they can copy etc because these people are passionate about music..Quote:
Originally Posted by vasanth2006
None of these are blatant lifts. Inspired may be the right word.Quote:
Originally Posted by vasanth2006
This is lame execuse IMO .....Western tuna indianise panna nalla visayama....Then y u r calling Deva as copycat??....Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
This is applicable for any MD ..... They can inspire and can give the same style of song....but not the same tune/song....
p.s : i am also lover of HJ's melodies....
I agree the bolded one...... But My point is if director forces, then MD has to reject the idea....Quote:
Originally Posted by Mahen
Thats what I feel about yuvan also....
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ramakrishna
Karu Karu is the inspiration?????..... :shock: :shock:....It is a pure copy.... same tune, guidar usage, orchastration, everything......
oru mugamo is inspiration??.... the tune is copy....
I can not accept that..... See i am not degrading HJ here...
We can say the others are inspirations.....