Sillunnu Oru Kadhal - A.R.Rahman - Vaali - Surya

Guys,

I am not yet heared the whole songs. I heared the samples only.

according to samples,

My Fav list (in the order)

1) munbe Vaa ---- superb tune. mesmerizing one. really good one. definitely the tune has IR style. my pick of the album. (may be because of raja style)

2) Machakari --- very excellent catchy tune. this one will reach the mass easily. i didnt see any ARR fan discussed this song. but this one has very good attraction.

3)New York Nagaram --- typical ARR melody. (same like "vellai pookkal" in KM). good one. this one may overtake "munbe vaa" after hearing full song. but success of this song depends on the movie success. because u know the hit status of vellai pookkal.

dislike List

i dont like other songs. maza, kummi adi, maricham are pretty ordinary songs. even below average IMHO. these songs might be hit because of picturisation. title song reminds 60's jazz.(MSV style)
i dont like MSV style of music. so i didnt like. maza maza is definitely rehash of "thazhuvuthu nazhuvuthu". i already irritated with "thazhuvuthu nazhuvuthu".

These impression happened with samples. after hearing of full album, i will post.

Totally 3 good songs out of 7. so once again ARR is depending on the movie success IMHO. ( i am saying after 2000/2001). they are going to have only 5 songs in movie. that is good sign. because the ratio will be 3/5.

(mmm.... oru kadhalan, minsara kanavu, rhythm mathiriyana complete musical films ARRkitta irunthu eppa varum?.recently RDB,boys. appadi vanthathan TFMla ippa competitive panna mudiyum. neenga enna sonnalum current TFM scene vera. ARRdo fan base and popularity is the + point for ARR.lets hope for SOK's BO success and the ever BIG sivaji.)

Dear Friends,

ARR fans or not, we must agree that 3 songs are super. Namely for me New York, Munbe Vaa and Macchakari. I also like Majja Majja very much even though it is same stlye as Thazhuvuthu from Ah Ahh.
The rest are just too ordinary (or craps!)to be ARR standard. KUmi songs sounds like some KR song from Dum Dum Dum. He is also showing strain in getting the tune/melody out as he used to even in songs like Macchakari where the verses tune becomes too flat to keep up with the songs starting melody.
Also I donno if anyone noticed New York has strange similarities to Alai Alai from Planet Galatta. Please listen to both.
But apart from the irritating fact that some fans are crooning as if the album of the year has been released, very sad to see ARR fans actually dieing to hear a good ARR standard album for too long. The sad truth is it is not SOK, perhaps they will hype and try to create an illusion as if it is the case. And please stop comparing with other good albums of YSR or HJ and get the response even stronger from neutrals and fans of other MDs.

SOK is a good album but not great.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MADDY

Mounam Pesiyathe,Ram dir by Ameer - mounam pesiyadhe is again abt rowdies isnt it?

---

appadiya ? :roll: .... Ellarum love stroy nu pesikraangale :roll:

Oru fight iruntha Rowdy padama... :rotfl:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ezy0265

ARR fans or not, we must agree that 3 songs are super. Namely for me New York, Munbe Vaa and Macchakari..

---

. :exactly: .....

Kinda hooked on to newyork and munbe vaa :musicsmile:

And please stop comparing with other good albums of YSR or HJ and get the response even stronger from neutrals and fans of other MDs.

Tell me one thing. Can YSR or HJ create any song thats even close to New York or Munbe Vaa? Think before you say something. Lets leave the best out of the way. Can they even create a song thats even close to Maaricham or Kummi Adi (the ones that u claim as craps)?

All YSR does is use the same precussions over and over again and copy tunes from the great Illayarajah. Lets not forget his classic remixes! Anyone can remix a song and I bet you the assitant of Himmesh Reshamaiya is better than YSR at remixes. You can visit Itwofs and check out how many songs YSR directly copied, note for note. Most songs from kadhal kondein is copied.

Harris Jeyaraj is the greatest composer of all times :lol:, look at his wonderful tunes :shock: in many of his movies that are copied directly from Rahman. Even the theme music of anniyan is copied from a jesus movie, you can check this in itwofs too.


We (I) dont accept all that Rahman does. Infact I didnt like Godfather and when people criticized it I kept quiet because I agreed with them. But when u talk about SOK, I cannot accept. How can you say this album is not better than any other album in the past few years?

I am really sorry if this hurt any of ur feelings. I just got a bit too emotional when you guys dissed this wonderful masterpiece.

Quote:

---

Dear Friends,

ARR fans or not, we must agree that 3 songs are super. Namely for me New York, Munbe Vaa and Macchakari. I also like Majja Majja very much even though it is same stlye as Thazhuvuthu from Ah Ahh.

---

It was indeed a sweet surprise that you liked it...more than the ARR fans, i would like to hear positive review (straight from the heart) from a neutral / anti guy .....

Maddy is right... JOK is above Aah aah (but still i love Aararai kodi more.. for me it is a song written for ARR..no such songs in JOK...) and below RDB.... Rang De Basanti was more fresh.... 2 songs of JOK sounds like (or atleast the mood) Ah Aah songs

[b]The sad truth is it is not SOK, perhaps they will hype and try to create an illusion as if it is the case.

We should say that its not SOK, even u said u liked 4 songs. Isnt that enough for us? 4/7 is a big hit. And I dont know what u find so bad about the other songs. To be honest, I didnt like those songs that u mentioned especially maaricham and JOK. I am serious, I had exact feeling about those songs as u did but later I listened to it a bit mroe and what gems they are. Trust me and go listen to them a bit more. Please do this for the good of music. I dont want you to miss out on any good stuff.
I am really sorry for my earlier post, I was in a really bad mood since my iPod battery ran out. Sorry about that, everyone forgive me. :oops: :(

guys who feel SOK album is average/good only.... the fact is its one of the BEST this year...im still thinking what album is AS GOOD as SOK....not even GF can be said as good as SOK....

the thing is i notice,when it comes to ARR,u guys rate it this way :

1.HJ - 1/2 songs GOOD out of 6 songs, it becomes SUPERB ALBUM.

2.YSR - 3 Songs good out of 6 songs,it becomes SUPERB ALBUM.

3.ARR - 4/5 songs good out of 6 songs,then only it becomes SUPERB ALBUM....

noticed that??? ;)... well for that fact...SOK is 5 songs is good out of 7 songs....so def its a SUPERB ALBUM!!! :twisted: [maja maja & maaricham]

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dinesh2002

3.ARR - 4/5 songs good out of 6 songs,then only it becomes SUPERB ALBUM....

noticed that??? ;)

---

exactly dinesh.........he is like sachin tendulkar.....they always xpect centuries out of this man......

anyways, i really thank Sanjeevi,Vasanth and ezy0265 who have come here to review this album......no album can do well with just a MD's fans.....it has to be accepted by the neutral ppl. and fans of other MDs then only it will do gud business.......


http://www.indiaglitz.com/channels/t...cle/24302.html

Suriya-Jo to wed on September 11

Avalukenna ambasamudharam aiyar hotel halva madhiri thazhampoovena thala thalavena vandha vandha paru

Avanukenna aalwar kurichi azhagu thevar aruvaa madhiri burma thekkena pala palavena vandha paru.....

romba sokanadhu indha sodinnnudhan andha aathadhan serthuputta

man, this surya guy is the luckiest guy in the world IMO, he has got ARR composing a song for his marriage :lol: ......

btw, (i know it may sound crude but for me ARR is important), what would be the business impact of this marriage on SOK's BO fate?

http://www.indiaglitz.com/channels/t...cle/24050.html

they say marriage'll have a positive impact........

yes really, nowadays girls dont mind ogling at maried guys... :lol: ......illena SRK and Aamir culdnt have ruled Bollywood for 15 yrs....... :lol: